This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/21/fred-phelps-westboro-baptist-church-dead-forgive-forget

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Fred Phelps doesn't deserve your grave dancing: let's forgive and forget his hate Fred Phelps doesn't deserve your grave dancing: let's forgive and forget his hate
(5 months later)
How to How to respond to the death of a monster? Dance? Rejoice? Sing (again) Ding Dong the Witch is Dead?
respond to the death of a monster? Dance? Rejoice? Sing (again) Ding Dong the For Fred Phelps, the founder and patriarch of the Westboro Baptist Church, infamous for picketing funerals with banners subtly proclaiming GOD HATES FAGS, it is inevitable that one other idea has already been widely suggested: picket his funeral.
Witch is Dead? How deliciously ironic, you might think. How apt. How Old Testament. But an eye for an eye doesn’t just make us all blind, it makes us stupid, inhumane, sinking to his subterranean level.
For Fred It is also distinctly impractical – the remaining members of the church have previously stated that Westboro does not hold funerals for their own, excommunicated or not. Of course. Funerals give comfort, catharsis, dignity – a holy trinity of human compassion, antithetical to hate-mongers.
Phelps, the founder and patriarch of the Westboro Baptist Church, infamous for No, the most befitting response to Phelps’s death lies in his life. We know about the funeral picketing. It wasn’t only the soldiers he shamed, deeming them puppets of a “fag-enabling” country. It was anyone with even the faintest association with gay people. And with any prominent LGBT people – the Westboro members were attention-seeking trolls long before the internet even existed. Phelps first gained international coverage for his family cult by picketing Matthew Shepard’s funeral.
picketing funerals with banners subtly proclaiming GOD HATES FAGS, it is This was the gay student – 21 years old – tortured, murdered and strung up on a fence in a Wyoming field in 1998. The police officer who found him later said that the only parts of his face not covered in blood were two streaks where tears had washed it away. Yet Phelps held in his right hand a placard reading MATT IN HELL, complete with a photograph of Shepard with a pink triangle on his forehead – the sign used by the Nazis in concentration camps. In his left hand stood a banner: NO SPECIAL LAW FOR FAGS.
inevitable that one other idea has already been widely suggested: picket Fred Phelps did not recognize hate crimes as anything special because he was a walking hate criminal.
his funeral. I spoke to Matthew Shepard’s mother Judy on the occasion of the tenth anniversary of her son’s death and brought up the protest.
How “Why would people go through their lives doing that?” she asked rhetorically, before offering a possible explanation.
deliciously ironic, you might think. How apt. How Old Testament. But an eye for “The depth of his hate speaks volumes. People who express that much hatred are unhappy with their own sexuality.”
an eye doesn’t just make us all blind, it makes us stupid, inhumane, sinking to I have always thought Fred Phelps was gay. Where else would such an inflamed, all-pervading obsession arise but from continually suppressed homoerotic fantasies? We hate what we can’t have. Freud identifies the defense mechanism “reaction formation” to denote those who so despise a part of their inner world that they outwardly campaign against it. Phelps is its utmost illustration.
his subterranean level. Judy Shepard also said that the demonstration played a part in her commitment to championing gay rights. She has dedicated her life since to speaking in schools around America against hate. That is how we can react to the death of Fred Phelps. To use it as fuel. To see him not as a monster, far removed, but as a symptom of an ill against which we must always remain vigilant.
It is also How, then, do we react to his family? In the last few months they have seemingly managed without him, having ostracized him for reasons still not fully explained. Some sources suggest a power struggle at the top of the church. It does not matter. Louis Theroux’s documentary dubbed the Phelpses, with not a small amount of accuracy, the “Most Hated Family in America”.
distinctly impractical – the remaining members of the church have I wish, however, we could view them differently: as victims. Three years ago I tracked down Nathan Phelps, Fred’s estranged son, who ran away from the church at the strike of midnight on his 18th birthday. He told me about the violence and abuse Fred inflicted.
previously stated that Westboro does not hold funerals for their own, excommunicated I would see him beat my brothers and sisters and kick them as they lay on the floor. He would grab me, pull me toward him and then put his knee up so it would go in my stomach. He would do that over and over and over. … Then there was the mattock. It’s a two-headed farming tool, with a hole on one side and an axe head on the other. He used that to beat us. He also had leather boxing gloves with a bar running through. He would put those on to hit me round the face and body. He would strangle me. … As he beat us he would tell us that we were evil and deserved to die.
or not. Of course. Funerals give comfort, catharsis, dignity – a holy trinity Nathan said, too, that their mother Margie, on one occasion, was trying to get away from Fred as he was beating her, started to fall down the stairs, reached out and ripped her arm out of its socket. Fred did not let her go to the hospital, Nathan said. Her body never properly healed.
of human compassion, antithetical to hate-mongers. The Phelps family is the freakishly hateful result of domestic abuse. To see them through any other prism is to dispense with our own humanity – however tempting. Theirs is a story far beyond the model of Stockholm syndrome. And so I suggest we stop hating them and fight them with something else, something they might possibly understand: a very Christian forgiveness. With love’s antithesis being indifference, forgiveness – that highest of virtues – is surely the real antidote to hate.
No, the Oscar Wilde, always a jester about the solemnest of subjects, advised, “Always forgive your enemies; nothing annoys them so much.” But I do not wish to annoy those who consider annoyance an art form. I wish that they would recover, get well, heal, lay to rest their leader’s twisted paranoia.
most befitting response to Phelps’s death lies in his life. We know about the funeral My ultimate wish, however, is that there would be, for a few revelatory moments, an afterlife, one in which Fred Phelps sees that there is no god, no hell, no damnation for we abominations, nor for anyone – not even him. And that he would see this void mirroring a life squandered on the pettiest of hates, sees that all along it was he who was the deviant, he who embodied humanity’s sickness. I wish too he would see Judy Shepherd, dignified, carrying on, and all the mothers of all those whose funerals he desecrated, unbowed and empathetic. And, finally, that he could see us, the opponents of hate, the inevitable victors in these bloody culture wars, looking back at him with pity, with forgiveness, with the humanity he never mustered, flags billowing, wedding bands glistening, emboldened, undeterred, marching, laughing, and with the grace forged on the ashes of bigotry, smiling in the face of perversity.
picketing. It wasn’t only the soldiers
he shamed, deeming them puppets of a “fag-enabling” country. It was anyone with
even the faintest association with gay people. And with any prominent LGBT
people – the Westboro members were attention-seeking trolls long before the internet even existed. Phelps first gained
international coverage for his family cult by picketing Matthew Shepard’s
funeral.
This was
the gay student – 21 years old – tortured, murdered and strung up on a fence in
a Wyoming field in 1998. The police officer who found him later said that the
only parts of his face not covered in blood were two streaks where tears had
washed it away. Yet Phelps held in his right hand a placard reading MATT IN
HELL, complete with a photograph of Shepard with a pink triangle on his
forehead – the sign used by the Nazis in concentration camps. In his left hand
stood a banner: NO SPECIAL LAW FOR FAGS.
Fred Phelps
did not recognize hate crimes as anything special because he was a walking hate
criminal.
I spoke to
Matthew Shepard’s mother Judy on the occasion of the tenth anniversary of her
son’s death and brought up the protest.
“Why would people go through their lives doing that?” she asked
rhetorically, before offering a possible explanation.
“The depth of his hate speaks volumes. People who express that much
hatred are unhappy with their own sexuality.”
I have always thought Fred Phelps was gay. Where else would such an
inflamed, all-pervading obsession arise but from continually suppressed
homoerotic fantasies? We hate what we can’t have. Freud identifies the defense mechanism “reaction formation” to denote those who
so despise a part of their inner world that they outwardly campaign against it.
Phelps is its utmost illustration.
Judy Shepard also said that the demonstration played a part in her
commitment to championing gay rights. She has dedicated her life since to
speaking in schools around America against hate. That is how we can react to the
death of Fred Phelps. To use it as fuel. To see him not as a monster, far
removed, but as a symptom of an ill against which we must always remain
vigilant.
How, then, do we react to his family? In the last few months they have
seemingly managed without him, having ostracized him for reasons still
not fully explained. Some sources suggest a power struggle at the top of the church. It does not matter. Louis
Theroux’s documentary dubbed the Phelpses, with
not a small amount of accuracy, the “Most Hated Family in America”.
I wish, however, we could view them differently: as victims. Three
years ago I tracked down Nathan Phelps, Fred’s estranged son, who ran away from
the church at the strike of midnight on his 18th birthday. He told me about the
violence and abuse Fred inflicted.
I would see him beat my brothers and sisters and
kick them as they lay on the floor. He would grab me, pull me toward him and
then put his knee up so it would go in my stomach. He would do that over and
over and over. … Then there was the mattock. It’s a two-headed farming tool,
with a hole on one side and an axe head on the other. He used that to beat us.
He also had leather boxing gloves with a bar running through. He would put
those on to hit me round the face and body. He would strangle me. … As he beat
us he would tell us that we were evil and deserved to die.
Nathan said, too, that their mother Margie, on one occasion, was trying
to get away from Fred as he was beating her, started to fall down the stairs,
reached out and ripped her arm out of its socket. Fred did not let her go to
the hospital, Nathan said. Her body never properly healed.
The Phelps family is the freakishly hateful result of domestic abuse. To
see them through any other prism is
to dispense with our own humanity – however tempting. Theirs is a story far
beyond the model of Stockholm syndrome. And so I suggest we stop hating them
and fight them with something else, something they might possibly understand: a
very Christian forgiveness. With
love’s antithesis being indifference, forgiveness – that highest of virtues –
is surely the real antidote to hate.
Oscar Wilde, always a jester about the solemnest of subjects, advised,
“Always forgive your enemies; nothing annoys them so much.” But I
do not wish to annoy those who consider annoyance an art form. I wish that they
would recover, get well, heal, lay to rest their leader’s twisted paranoia.
My ultimate
wish, however, is that there would be, for a few revelatory moments, an
afterlife, one in which Fred Phelps sees that there is no god, no hell,
no damnation for we abominations, nor for anyone – not even him. And
that he would see this void mirroring a life squandered on the pettiest
of hates, sees that all along it was he who was the deviant, he who
embodied humanity’s sickness. I wish too he would see Judy Shepherd,
dignified, carrying on, and all the mothers of all those whose funerals
he desecrated, unbowed and empathetic. And, finally, that he could see
us, the opponents of hate, the inevitable victors in these bloody
culture wars, looking back at him with pity, with forgiveness, with the
humanity he never mustered, flags billowing, wedding bands glistening,
emboldened, undeterred, marching, laughing, and with the grace forged on
the ashes of bigotry, smiling in the face of perversity.