This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/16/world/africa/oscar-pistorius-murder-trial.html
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Pistorius Re-enacts Moments After Girlfriend’s Shooting | |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| PRETORIA, South Africa — As the prosecution ended five days of grueling cross-examination, Oscar Pistorius, the disabled track star accused of murder, rose from the dock on Tuesday to re-enact the moment he broke down a locked toilet cubicle door with a cricket bat after opening fire on it with his girlfriend inside. | PRETORIA, South Africa — As the prosecution ended five days of grueling cross-examination, Oscar Pistorius, the disabled track star accused of murder, rose from the dock on Tuesday to re-enact the moment he broke down a locked toilet cubicle door with a cricket bat after opening fire on it with his girlfriend inside. |
| His girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp, 29, a model and law graduate, was shot to death in the early hours of Feb. 14, 2013. Mr. Pistorius denies the prosecution’s charge of premeditated murder, saying he made a mistake, believing at least one intruder was inside the cubicle when he fired four shots from a handgun. | His girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp, 29, a model and law graduate, was shot to death in the early hours of Feb. 14, 2013. Mr. Pistorius denies the prosecution’s charge of premeditated murder, saying he made a mistake, believing at least one intruder was inside the cubicle when he fired four shots from a handgun. |
| After the re-enactment, Mr. Pistorius testified that when he found Ms. Steenkamp, she was “sitting on the floor to the right. She was seated on her right buttocks with her right arm on top of the toilet bowl. Her head was on her shoulder.” | |
| The prosecutor then displayed a grisly photograph of the toilet with blood smearing the bowl and a pool of blood on the floor. | The prosecutor then displayed a grisly photograph of the toilet with blood smearing the bowl and a pool of blood on the floor. |
| Since last week, the double-amputee athlete has faced grueling interrogation by the state prosecutor, Gerrie Nel, who has accused Mr. Pistorius, 27, of lying, dissembling, changing his evidence and offering an improbable and untrue version of events. | Since last week, the double-amputee athlete has faced grueling interrogation by the state prosecutor, Gerrie Nel, who has accused Mr. Pistorius, 27, of lying, dissembling, changing his evidence and offering an improbable and untrue version of events. |
| “It’s got more and more improbable,” the prosecutor said Tuesday, shortly before he ended his cross-examination, which has frequently reduced Mr. Pistorius to tears. In a final summary of the prosecution’s case, Mr. Nel accused the athlete of intending to shoot and kill Ms. Steenkamp when he opened fire at the door. The couple had argued, the prosecutor said, and Ms. Steenkamp wanted to leave the house. “You were threatening her,” he said. | “It’s got more and more improbable,” the prosecutor said Tuesday, shortly before he ended his cross-examination, which has frequently reduced Mr. Pistorius to tears. In a final summary of the prosecution’s case, Mr. Nel accused the athlete of intending to shoot and kill Ms. Steenkamp when he opened fire at the door. The couple had argued, the prosecutor said, and Ms. Steenkamp wanted to leave the house. “You were threatening her,” he said. |
| But Mr. Pistorius repeated that he “believed there was someone coming out to attack” when he fired. After the shooting, Mr. Pistorius said, he ran on his stumps and put on his prosthetic legs. He then tried to break down the door with his shoulder and by kicking it, but when that did not work he went to find a cricket bat. “I was crying out for the Lord to help me,” Mr. Pistorius said. | But Mr. Pistorius repeated that he “believed there was someone coming out to attack” when he fired. After the shooting, Mr. Pistorius said, he ran on his stumps and put on his prosthetic legs. He then tried to break down the door with his shoulder and by kicking it, but when that did not work he went to find a cricket bat. “I was crying out for the Lord to help me,” Mr. Pistorius said. |
| “I was screaming for Reeva.” He added, “I was overcome with terror and despair.” | “I was screaming for Reeva.” He added, “I was overcome with terror and despair.” |
| “I checked if she was breathing, if she had a pulse,” he continued. “I heard her breathing and immediately tried to get her up and get her out of the toilet. I couldn’t pick her up and I scuttled around with my legs.” | “I checked if she was breathing, if she had a pulse,” he continued. “I heard her breathing and immediately tried to get her up and get her out of the toilet. I couldn’t pick her up and I scuttled around with my legs.” |
| “I managed to turn her around,” he said, adding that he then telephoned a friend to ask for help picking her up. | “I managed to turn her around,” he said, adding that he then telephoned a friend to ask for help picking her up. |
| “I was crying. I was saying: ‘Baby, please hold on. Jesus, help me.' ” He called emergency services, and an operator told him to get Ms. Steenkamp to a hospital as quickly as possible, without waiting for an ambulance. | “I was crying. I was saying: ‘Baby, please hold on. Jesus, help me.' ” He called emergency services, and an operator told him to get Ms. Steenkamp to a hospital as quickly as possible, without waiting for an ambulance. |
| When Mr. Pistorius finally managed to pick her up and carry her downstairs, Johan Stander, the manager of the gated complex where the athlete lived, arrived and told him to lay the body down. | When Mr. Pistorius finally managed to pick her up and carry her downstairs, Johan Stander, the manager of the gated complex where the athlete lived, arrived and told him to lay the body down. |
| Before Mr. Pistorius ended his testimony, his defense lawyer, Barry Roux, led him through a nine-minute re-examination during which he was asked to read from what the defense said was a Valentine’s Day card given to him by Ms. Steenkamp. In it, Mr. Pistorius said, she had written: “I think today is a good day to tell you I love you. | Before Mr. Pistorius ended his testimony, his defense lawyer, Barry Roux, led him through a nine-minute re-examination during which he was asked to read from what the defense said was a Valentine’s Day card given to him by Ms. Steenkamp. In it, Mr. Pistorius said, she had written: “I think today is a good day to tell you I love you. |
| On Monday, Mr. Pistorius was taken back to the early hours of the morning when he shot Ms. Steenkamp, in what the prosecution says was an act of premeditated murder and Mr. Pistorius contends was a mistake. | On Monday, Mr. Pistorius was taken back to the early hours of the morning when he shot Ms. Steenkamp, in what the prosecution says was an act of premeditated murder and Mr. Pistorius contends was a mistake. |
| Mr. Nel had Mr. Pistorius relive the final intimate moments of Ms. Steenkamp’s life, as the athlete walked unsteadily on his stumps down an unlit passage from his darkened bedroom, a pistol in his right hand, and into a bathroom where he fired four rounds at the locked door of the toilet cubicle. | Mr. Nel had Mr. Pistorius relive the final intimate moments of Ms. Steenkamp’s life, as the athlete walked unsteadily on his stumps down an unlit passage from his darkened bedroom, a pistol in his right hand, and into a bathroom where he fired four rounds at the locked door of the toilet cubicle. |
| Then, Mr. Pistorius said, “I ran down the passage; I ran past my bed” to look for his girlfriend and call for help. | Then, Mr. Pistorius said, “I ran down the passage; I ran past my bed” to look for his girlfriend and call for help. |
| “When I realized that Reeva wasn’t on the bed, that was the first time I thought it might be Reeva in the bathroom,” Mr. Pistorius said. | “When I realized that Reeva wasn’t on the bed, that was the first time I thought it might be Reeva in the bathroom,” Mr. Pistorius said. |
| But, Mr. Nel said, the “first thing you would think is that you would check whether she left through the bedroom door” rather than assume she had been in the locked cubicle. | But, Mr. Nel said, the “first thing you would think is that you would check whether she left through the bedroom door” rather than assume she had been in the locked cubicle. |
| It required a “great leap” for Mr. Pistorius to go from believing that he had shot intruders to suspecting that he had opened fire on his girlfriend, said Mr. Nel, whose reputation as a pugnacious prosecutor has earned him the nickname pit bull. | It required a “great leap” for Mr. Pistorius to go from believing that he had shot intruders to suspecting that he had opened fire on his girlfriend, said Mr. Nel, whose reputation as a pugnacious prosecutor has earned him the nickname pit bull. |
| “You see, Mr. Pistorius, this is one of the most crucial issues that makes your version so improbable,” Mr. Nel said, seeking to establish that the athlete’s evidence on the stand was, in the prosecutor’s words on Monday, “so improbable that it cannot possibly be true.” | “You see, Mr. Pistorius, this is one of the most crucial issues that makes your version so improbable,” Mr. Nel said, seeking to establish that the athlete’s evidence on the stand was, in the prosecutor’s words on Monday, “so improbable that it cannot possibly be true.” |
| The exchanges went to the core of a case that has drawn a global audience and transfixed many in South Africa as the hearings, which opened on March 3, focus in ever greater detail on the state of Mr. Pistorius’s mind in the early hours on Valentine’s Day 2013, when, the prosecution maintains, he killed Ms. Steenkamp in a jealous rage. | The exchanges went to the core of a case that has drawn a global audience and transfixed many in South Africa as the hearings, which opened on March 3, focus in ever greater detail on the state of Mr. Pistorius’s mind in the early hours on Valentine’s Day 2013, when, the prosecution maintains, he killed Ms. Steenkamp in a jealous rage. |
| The spectacle of the trial also offered a stark counterpoint to the days of 2012 when Mr. Pistorius, a double amputee since infancy, not only triumphed at the Paralympic Games but also competed against able-bodied athletes at the London Olympics a month earlier, earning great adulation. On his return home, he and Ms. Steenkamp, a model and law graduate, were depicted as a gilded couple. | The spectacle of the trial also offered a stark counterpoint to the days of 2012 when Mr. Pistorius, a double amputee since infancy, not only triumphed at the Paralympic Games but also competed against able-bodied athletes at the London Olympics a month earlier, earning great adulation. On his return home, he and Ms. Steenkamp, a model and law graduate, were depicted as a gilded couple. |
| But that glittery trajectory of success and celebrity has collapsed. Headlines that once lauded Mr. Pistorius now focus on his increasing discomfort as a hard-nosed prosecutor sets out to paint a picture of inconsistency, improbability and mendacity. If convicted of premeditated murder, he would face a minimum prison term of 25 years. | But that glittery trajectory of success and celebrity has collapsed. Headlines that once lauded Mr. Pistorius now focus on his increasing discomfort as a hard-nosed prosecutor sets out to paint a picture of inconsistency, improbability and mendacity. If convicted of premeditated murder, he would face a minimum prison term of 25 years. |
| Twice during Monday’s questioning, Mr. Pistorius broke down, as he has several times in the trial, his shoulders heaving as he sobbed. On other occasions, his voice quavered as he testified and, ashen-faced, he seemed on the brink of tears. | Twice during Monday’s questioning, Mr. Pistorius broke down, as he has several times in the trial, his shoulders heaving as he sobbed. On other occasions, his voice quavered as he testified and, ashen-faced, he seemed on the brink of tears. |
| But his displays of deepening distress drew only a sarcastic question from Mr. Nel, who asked, “You are not using your emotional state as an escape, are you?” | But his displays of deepening distress drew only a sarcastic question from Mr. Nel, who asked, “You are not using your emotional state as an escape, are you?” |
| Mr. Pistorius said repeatedly that he had not known who was in the cubicle. “I didn’t fire to attack,” he said. “I didn’t have time to think.” | Mr. Pistorius said repeatedly that he had not known who was in the cubicle. “I didn’t fire to attack,” he said. “I didn’t have time to think.” |
| “You fired at Reeva,” Mr. Nel said bluntly. | “You fired at Reeva,” Mr. Nel said bluntly. |
| “I did not fire at Reeva,” Mr. Pistorius said in a choked, strained voice, seeming overwhelmed. The court adjourned briefly to permit him to compose himself. But when the session resumed, Mr. Nel’s insistent questions did, too, despite objections from the defense that the prosecutor was repeatedly going over old ground. | “I did not fire at Reeva,” Mr. Pistorius said in a choked, strained voice, seeming overwhelmed. The court adjourned briefly to permit him to compose himself. But when the session resumed, Mr. Nel’s insistent questions did, too, despite objections from the defense that the prosecutor was repeatedly going over old ground. |
| Mr. Pistorius said he had heard a sound like “wood moving,” perhaps when a door was opened or a magazine rack inside the cubicle was moved. “I wasn’t thinking,” he said. “I was screaming to the person or persons to get out.” | Mr. Pistorius said he had heard a sound like “wood moving,” perhaps when a door was opened or a magazine rack inside the cubicle was moved. “I wasn’t thinking,” he said. “I was screaming to the person or persons to get out.” |
| “You never gave them the chance,” Mr. Nel responded. “You said to them to get out, then never gave them the chance to do it.” | “You never gave them the chance,” Mr. Nel responded. “You said to them to get out, then never gave them the chance to do it.” |
| “I fired in quick succession,” Mr. Pistorius said. “I discharged my firearm as quickly as I could.” | “I fired in quick succession,” Mr. Pistorius said. “I discharged my firearm as quickly as I could.” |
| So “why did you only fire four rounds?” Mr. Nel asked. “Why not empty the magazine?” | So “why did you only fire four rounds?” Mr. Nel asked. “Why not empty the magazine?” |
| Was it just by luck, then, that the gun was pointed at Ms. Steenkamp, Mr. Nel asked. | Was it just by luck, then, that the gun was pointed at Ms. Steenkamp, Mr. Nel asked. |
| “How could that be lucky?” Mr. Pistorius asked, choking up. “She lost her life.” | “How could that be lucky?” Mr. Pistorius asked, choking up. “She lost her life.” |
| “Mr. Pistorius, you are trying to get emotional again,” Mr. Nel said. | “Mr. Pistorius, you are trying to get emotional again,” Mr. Nel said. |