This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/apr/19/hoovers-fbi-todays-surveillance-state
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| The mentality of J Edgar Hoover’s FBI undergirds today’s surveillance state | The mentality of J Edgar Hoover’s FBI undergirds today’s surveillance state |
| (1 day later) | |
| The new documentary 1971, about the formerly anonymous | The new documentary 1971, about the formerly anonymous |
| FBI burglars who exposed the crimes of former FBI director J. Edgar | FBI burglars who exposed the crimes of former FBI director J. Edgar |
| Hoover, debuted to a rapt audience at the Tribeca film festival last | |
| night. As the filmmakers noted in an interview | night. As the filmmakers noted in an interview |
| with the AP, the parallels between Nixon-era FBI whistleblowers and | with the AP, the parallels between Nixon-era FBI whistleblowers and |
| Edward Snowden's NSA revelations are almost eerie in their similarity. | Edward Snowden's NSA revelations are almost eerie in their similarity. |
| But | But |
| while the NSA connection seems obvious, the movie will actually shed | while the NSA connection seems obvious, the movie will actually shed |
| light on the domestic intelligence agency with far more power over | light on the domestic intelligence agency with far more power over |
| ordinary Americans: the modern FBI. | ordinary Americans: the modern FBI. |
| Everyone | Everyone |
| seems to forget that the FBI is the NSA's primary partner in the | seems to forget that the FBI is the NSA's primary partner in the |
| latter's domestic spying operations and that, in fact, the NSA's job | latter's domestic spying operations and that, in fact, the NSA's job |
| would be impossible without them. Whenever you see a company deny giving | would be impossible without them. Whenever you see a company deny giving |
| any data to the NSA remember: It's because it's not the NSA asking (or | any data to the NSA remember: It's because it's not the NSA asking (or |
| demanding) the information of them, it's the FBI. They use the same Patriot Act authorities that the NSA does, and yet we have almost no idea what they do with it. | demanding) the information of them, it's the FBI. They use the same Patriot Act authorities that the NSA does, and yet we have almost no idea what they do with it. |
| In fact, the FBI has gone to extreme lengths to just keep their surveillance methods a secret from the public, just like the NSA. And the more we learn, the scarier it gets. | In fact, the FBI has gone to extreme lengths to just keep their surveillance methods a secret from the public, just like the NSA. And the more we learn, the scarier it gets. |
| On Monday, the EFF revealed | On Monday, the EFF revealed |
| through its Freedom of Information Act lawsuit that the FBI's "next | through its Freedom of Information Act lawsuit that the FBI's "next |
| generation" facial recognition program will have as many as 52m | generation" facial recognition program will have as many as 52m |
| photographs in it next year – including millions that were taken for | photographs in it next year – including millions that were taken for |
| "non-criminal purposes." It's massive biometric database already “may | "non-criminal purposes." It's massive biometric database already “may |
| hold records on as much as one third of the U.S. population,” EFF found. | hold records on as much as one third of the U.S. population,” EFF found. |
| Lavabit, the email provider once allegedly used | Lavabit, the email provider once allegedly used |
| by Edward Snowden, also lost an appeal this week, leaving its founder | by Edward Snowden, also lost an appeal this week, leaving its founder |
| Ladar Levinson in contempt of court for failing to hand over Lavabit's | Ladar Levinson in contempt of court for failing to hand over Lavabit's |
| encryption keys to the FBI that would have exposed all 400,000 users of | encryption keys to the FBI that would have exposed all 400,000 users of |
| Lavabit. The court failed to rule on the larger issue – leaving the door open for the FBI to try it again. | Lavabit. The court failed to rule on the larger issue – leaving the door open for the FBI to try it again. |
| And we know they want to. Foreign Policy's Shane Harris reported last year, the FBI "carries out its own signals intelligence | And we know they want to. Foreign Policy's Shane Harris reported last year, the FBI "carries out its own signals intelligence |
| operations and is trying to collect huge amounts of email and Internet | operations and is trying to collect huge amounts of email and Internet |
| data from U.S. companies – an operation that the NSA once conducted, was | data from U.S. companies – an operation that the NSA once conducted, was |
| reprimanded for, and says it abandoned." The FBI's activities include | reprimanded for, and says it abandoned." The FBI's activities include |
| trying to convince "telecom carriers and Internet service providers to | trying to convince "telecom carriers and Internet service providers to |
| install [port readers] on their networks so that the government can | install [port readers] on their networks so that the government can |
| collect large volumes of data about emails and Internet traffic." | collect large volumes of data about emails and Internet traffic." |
| We also know they | We also know they |
| routinely get cell phone location information without a warrant. (If | routinely get cell phone location information without a warrant. (If |
| you want to see how your cell phone location information reveals almost | you want to see how your cell phone location information reveals almost |
| every detail of your life, watch this amazing ACLU video.) We also know they're using Stingray devices, which are fake cell phone towers that vacuum up all cell phone activity in a particular area. | every detail of your life, watch this amazing ACLU video.) We also know they're using Stingray devices, which are fake cell phone towers that vacuum up all cell phone activity in a particular area. |
| We know that the FBI is still issuing thousands of oversight-free National Security Letters a year, despite multiple government reports detailing systematic abuse, and a federal court ruling that they are unconstitutional last year. (The ruling was put on hold pending appeal.) | We know that the FBI is still issuing thousands of oversight-free National Security Letters a year, despite multiple government reports detailing systematic abuse, and a federal court ruling that they are unconstitutional last year. (The ruling was put on hold pending appeal.) |
| The FBI has pushed Congress and the White House – and reportedly quietly lobbied the tech companies – to support a dangerous overhaul | The FBI has pushed Congress and the White House – and reportedly quietly lobbied the tech companies – to support a dangerous overhaul |
| to wiretapping laws that would require Internet companies like Google | to wiretapping laws that would require Internet companies like Google |
| and Facebook to create a backdoor into their services, giving the FBI | and Facebook to create a backdoor into their services, giving the FBI |
| direct access if they get the requisite legal authorities. And, at the | direct access if they get the requisite legal authorities. And, at the |
| same time, the FBI also wants to be able to expand their ability to hack suspects' computers. | same time, the FBI also wants to be able to expand their ability to hack suspects' computers. |
| (At least some judges have been | (At least some judges have been |
| pushing back, noting that the trove of information that the FBI can get | pushing back, noting that the trove of information that the FBI can get |
| from hacking suspects is often far beyond what the agency's | from hacking suspects is often far beyond what the agency's |
| investigation requires.) | investigation requires.) |
| Worse, Wired discovered FBI training materials | Worse, Wired discovered FBI training materials |
| in 2012 that told agents they had the "ability to bend or suspend the | in 2012 that told agents they had the "ability to bend or suspend the |
| law and impinge on freedoms of others," in national security cases. The | law and impinge on freedoms of others," in national security cases. The |
| materials were quickly withdrawn when they became public. | materials were quickly withdrawn when they became public. |
| All of this leads to why a comprehensive report released | All of this leads to why a comprehensive report released |
| by ACLU late in 2013 called the FBI a "secret domestic intelligence | by ACLU late in 2013 called the FBI a "secret domestic intelligence |
| agency" that "regularly overstepped the law, infringing on Americans' | agency" that "regularly overstepped the law, infringing on Americans' |
| constitutional rights while overzealously pursuing its domestic security | constitutional rights while overzealously pursuing its domestic security |
| mission." | mission." |
| After | After |
| watching 1971, or reading Betty Medsger's corresponding book The | watching 1971, or reading Betty Medsger's corresponding book The |
| Burglary, it should be a scandal to everyone that the FBI building is | Burglary, it should be a scandal to everyone that the FBI building is |
| still named after J. Edgar Hoover. Unfortunately, his ghost also still | still named after J. Edgar Hoover. Unfortunately, his ghost also still |
| seems to permeate in much of what they do. | seems to permeate in much of what they do. |