This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-27184269
The article has changed 15 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 8 | Version 9 |
|---|---|
| MPs reject calls for HS2 rail plans to be halted | MPs reject calls for HS2 rail plans to be halted |
| (about 7 hours later) | |
| MPs have rejected calls for the proposed HS2 rail link between London and the West Midlands to be scrapped, despite a Tory rebellion. | MPs have rejected calls for the proposed HS2 rail link between London and the West Midlands to be scrapped, despite a Tory rebellion. |
| MPs threw out a proposal by ex-minister Cheryl Gillan for the plan to be halted by 451 votes to 50, a majority of 401. | MPs threw out a proposal by ex-minister Cheryl Gillan for the plan to be halted by 451 votes to 50, a majority of 401. |
| Transport Minister Robert Goodwill said it was an "important step" in taking the controversial project forward. | Transport Minister Robert Goodwill said it was an "important step" in taking the controversial project forward. |
| A total of 34 Tories voted against the government, while a total of 46 Tories missed the vote or abstained. | |
| Thirty-two Conservatives backed Mrs Gillan's amendment, while one - James Gray - acted as a teller for the rebels. | Thirty-two Conservatives backed Mrs Gillan's amendment, while one - James Gray - acted as a teller for the rebels. |
| After rejecting Ms Gillan's amendment, MPs approved the general principles of the bill in a second vote by 452 to 41 votes, a majority of 411. | After rejecting Ms Gillan's amendment, MPs approved the general principles of the bill in a second vote by 452 to 41 votes, a majority of 411. |
| Most of the rebel Tories voted against the government again this time, as did two other Tories, John Redwood and Sir Richard Shepherd. | Most of the rebel Tories voted against the government again this time, as did two other Tories, John Redwood and Sir Richard Shepherd. |
| Last June, 21 Conservative backbenchers opposed the government in a Commons vote laying the groundwork for HS2 and the size of the rebellion was expected to be larger on Monday. | Last June, 21 Conservative backbenchers opposed the government in a Commons vote laying the groundwork for HS2 and the size of the rebellion was expected to be larger on Monday. |
| The High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Bill 2013-14, which would authorise the first phase of the multi-billion project, cleared its first parliamentary hurdle when it was given a second reading by MPs. | The High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Bill 2013-14, which would authorise the first phase of the multi-billion project, cleared its first parliamentary hurdle when it was given a second reading by MPs. |
| The proposed legislation would: | The proposed legislation would: |
| Speaking at the start of Monday's debate, Mr McLoughlin said the concerns of critics of the project must be addressed and that references to opponents as "either Luddites or nimbys" were unhelpful. | Speaking at the start of Monday's debate, Mr McLoughlin said the concerns of critics of the project must be addressed and that references to opponents as "either Luddites or nimbys" were unhelpful. |
| He said there would be "fair compensation" for those directly and indirectly affected by the scheme and the impact on the environment must be mitigated. | He said there would be "fair compensation" for those directly and indirectly affected by the scheme and the impact on the environment must be mitigated. |
| But he said there was an urgent need for new rail capacity and the plan would deliver better connectivity and wider economic benefits to the whole of the UK. | But he said there was an urgent need for new rail capacity and the plan would deliver better connectivity and wider economic benefits to the whole of the UK. |
| 'Careful scrutiny' | 'Careful scrutiny' |
| "This is a decision which we cannot duck. We have waited long enough," he said. | "This is a decision which we cannot duck. We have waited long enough," he said. |
| "Built right, on time and on budget, HS2 can help our great cities thrive... This project deserves careful scrutiny but Britain deserves it to go ahead." | "Built right, on time and on budget, HS2 can help our great cities thrive... This project deserves careful scrutiny but Britain deserves it to go ahead." |
| A number of ministers whose constituencies lie on the proposed route - including Europe Minister David Lidington and Attorney General Dominic Grieve - were given permission to miss Monday's vote. | A number of ministers whose constituencies lie on the proposed route - including Europe Minister David Lidington and Attorney General Dominic Grieve - were given permission to miss Monday's vote. |
| And recently appointed Treasury minister Andrea Leadsom, who has spoken out against the project in the past, is in Brussels and was not present in the Commons. | And recently appointed Treasury minister Andrea Leadsom, who has spoken out against the project in the past, is in Brussels and was not present in the Commons. |
| But a number of MPs stated their opposition to HS2 during the debate, scheduled to last six hours. | But a number of MPs stated their opposition to HS2 during the debate, scheduled to last six hours. |
| 'Broad consensus' | 'Broad consensus' |
| Conservative MP for North West Leicestershire Andrew Bridgen said 240,000 people living within a mile of the proposed route were not entitled to compensation and would be "trapped in houses they cannot sell". | Conservative MP for North West Leicestershire Andrew Bridgen said 240,000 people living within a mile of the proposed route were not entitled to compensation and would be "trapped in houses they cannot sell". |
| Former cabinet minister Cheryl Gillan, who tabled the amendment designed to derail the proposed legislation, said the £42.6bn project would threaten much-needed investment on the rest of the railway. | Former cabinet minister Cheryl Gillan, who tabled the amendment designed to derail the proposed legislation, said the £42.6bn project would threaten much-needed investment on the rest of the railway. |
| "I started as a nimby but I have looked at this project and I do not believe it is the best answer to the UK's transport problems," the Chesham and Amersham MP said. | "I started as a nimby but I have looked at this project and I do not believe it is the best answer to the UK's transport problems," the Chesham and Amersham MP said. |
| "Is this really a top priority and the best way to spend almost £50bn worth of taxpayers' money? | "Is this really a top priority and the best way to spend almost £50bn worth of taxpayers' money? |
| "Many colleagues also abstained this evening, which shows that the scepticism of this project runs much more deeply than the voting figures suggest." | "Many colleagues also abstained this evening, which shows that the scepticism of this project runs much more deeply than the voting figures suggest." |
| Labour's Barry Sheerman, MP for Huddersfield, said that, rather than spreading economic benefits more widely across the UK, it would "suck more powers to London and the South East". | Labour's Barry Sheerman, MP for Huddersfield, said that, rather than spreading economic benefits more widely across the UK, it would "suck more powers to London and the South East". |
| 'Another look' | 'Another look' |
| Labour's support had been in doubt because of rising costs, but shadow transport secretary Mary Creagh said the party "had had another look" to check it still provided value for money and would support the plan. | Labour's support had been in doubt because of rising costs, but shadow transport secretary Mary Creagh said the party "had had another look" to check it still provided value for money and would support the plan. |
| Although the government had mismanaged the project since it inherited it from the previous Labour administration in 2010, Ms Creagh said it was reassured that it was still needed. | Although the government had mismanaged the project since it inherited it from the previous Labour administration in 2010, Ms Creagh said it was reassured that it was still needed. |
| "We have a broad consensus across the parties that this is the right thing for the nation and I hope we can proceed on that basis," she said. | "We have a broad consensus across the parties that this is the right thing for the nation and I hope we can proceed on that basis," she said. |
| But in a new report, The Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) said the government risked misleading the public with claims that HS2 would transform the north of England. | But in a new report, The Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) said the government risked misleading the public with claims that HS2 would transform the north of England. |
| The report's author, Richard Wellings, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme he was sceptical about claims that HS2 would be "transformative, it is going to tackle the north-south divide". | The report's author, Richard Wellings, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme he was sceptical about claims that HS2 would be "transformative, it is going to tackle the north-south divide". |
| Alternatives | Alternatives |
| Mr Wellings said that instead of building HS2 the government should improve local and regional links in the north of England, including a cross-Pennine project linking Sheffield, Leeds and Manchester. | Mr Wellings said that instead of building HS2 the government should improve local and regional links in the north of England, including a cross-Pennine project linking Sheffield, Leeds and Manchester. |
| The Department for Transport said the IEA report was "flawed" and "simply wrong to say High Speed 1 hasn't brought significant benefits" to places like Ashford. | The Department for Transport said the IEA report was "flawed" and "simply wrong to say High Speed 1 hasn't brought significant benefits" to places like Ashford. |
| Meanwhile, the British Chambers of Commerce (BCC) has called on the government to speed up construction of the line. | Meanwhile, the British Chambers of Commerce (BCC) has called on the government to speed up construction of the line. |
| The BCC urged all political parties to set aside their short-term differences and Parliament to approve progress on the scheme quickly. | The BCC urged all political parties to set aside their short-term differences and Parliament to approve progress on the scheme quickly. |
| Both phases of the HS2 link are expected to cost £42.6bn, including contingencies, with another £7.5bn for trains. | Both phases of the HS2 link are expected to cost £42.6bn, including contingencies, with another £7.5bn for trains. |