This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/media/2014/jun/26/bbc-trust-chair-hours-reduced-lord-coe

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
BBC Trust chair hours reduced leading to claims that it encourages Coe BBC Trust chair hours reduced leading to claims that it encourages Coe
(about 7 hours later)
The time commitment required from potential candidates to become BBC Trust chair has been reduced, leading to claims that the change is to ensure the government’s preferred candidate, Lord Coe, can apply. A last minute change to the job description for the chairmanship of the BBC Trust has prompted Labour complaints that the change has been made to ensure that the government’s preferred candidate, Conservative peer Lord Coe, can apply.
The original advert for the £110,000-a-year role was placed by the culture secretary, Sajid Javid, on 30 May stating that the time commitment was the standard three to four days per week (12-16 days per month). The original advert for the £110,000-a-year role was placed by the culture secretary, Sajid Javid, on 30 May stating that the time commitment required was the standard three to four days per week, but in the last week that demand was watered down and applicants given an extra week, until today, to apply.
However, in the past week the ad has been amended to include a line opening up the position to candidates with less free time: “Suitable candidates able to offer a lesser time commitment will also be considered.” The deadline for applications has also been extended by a week from Friday 20 June. Labour MP Ben Bradshaw, a former culture secretary said: “I think it is an extremely worrying development. It gives the impression that the government have already made up their mind about who they want but that person can’t commit the time so they are moving the goalposts. To do this so last minute and with no transparency is extremely alarming.”
Observers believe that the change is designed to ensure the government’s favoured candidate, Coe, is able to meet the selection criteria. Political sources suggested that Coe, who has been sounded out about replacing Lord Patten as BBC Trust chair by top government officials, would struggle to juggle the role if he also fulfils his long-held ambition to win the presidency of the International Association of Athletics Federations.
It has been suggested that Coe, who has been sounded out about replacing Lord Patten as BBC Trust chair by top government officials, would struggle to juggle the role if he also fulfils his long-held ambition to win the presidency of the International Association of Athletics Federations. But Bradshaw said that the job demanded a high level of time commitment. “A lot of criticism levelled at Lord Patten was that he wasn’t committing enough time or attention to the job doing it four days per week,” he said. “It would be extraordinary for the government to appoint someone prepared to give less time, particularly given the importance of the charter renewal process they will oversee, and possible fundamental changes in the BBC’s government structure.”
Labour MP Ben Bradshaw, a member of the Commons culture, media and sport select committee, which will have a hearing to vet the government’s preferred candidate for the BBC job before their appointment is formally approved, said that the unusual and late change to the job description was an “alarming” move. Lord Coe told BBC Radio 5 Live earlier this month that he had some “thinking to do” about applying for the job. He said it was “very flattering” to be linked to the role and said he was “passionate about public service broadcasting”. But acting BBC Trust chair Diane Coyle is the only publicly confirmed candidate for the job.
“I think it is an extremely worrying development,” he said. “It gives the impression that government have already made up their mind about who they want but that person can’t commit the time so they are moving the goal posts. To do this so last minute and with no transparency is extremely alarming.” Deputy labour leader Harriet Harman, who has raised fears about political bias influencing the recruitment process, said that there had been no consultation about the changes. “The chair of the BBC Trust is an important role and the appointment must be made on merit and not on party political lines,” she said. “We have real concerns that these changes signal that the process is being changed to suit a particular applicant for political reasons. This is a significant difference in approach and there has been no consultation.”
He added that it has been proven that the BBC Trust chair role requires at least three to fours days a week time commitment, if not more. A spokesman for the DCMS said that the change was designed to attract the strongest field of candidates. “We will consider any suitable candidates who can commit to less than three to four days a week,” the spokesman said. “It is essential we appoint the best possible person to the position so we must ensure we have the widest possible field of candidates.”
“A lot of criticism levelled at Lord Patten was that he wasn’t committing enough time or attention to job doing it 4 days per week,” he said. “It would be extraordinary for government to appoint someone prepared to give less time, particularly given the importance of the charter renewal process they will oversee, and possible fundamental changes in the BBC’s government structure.” However, in the past week the ad has been amended to include a line opening up the position to candidates with less free time: “Suitable candidates able to offer a lesser time commitment will also be considered.” The deadline for applications has also been extended by a week from Friday 20 June.The BBC declined to comment. But one source said that the BBC had advised the DCMS that the role requires a three to four day time commitment.
A spokesman for the DCMS said that the change was designed to attract the strongest field of candidates.
“We will consider any suitable candidates who can commit to less than three to four days a week,” he said. “It is essential we appoint the best possible person to the position so we must ensure we have the widest possible field of candidates.”
A spokeswoman for the Commissioner for Public Appointments said that the changes to the job description had been cleared by Mark Addison, public appointments assessor.A spokeswoman for the Commissioner for Public Appointments said that the changes to the job description had been cleared by Mark Addison, public appointments assessor.
Acting BBC Trust chair Diane Coyle is the only publicly confirmed candidate for the job.
One source said that the BBC had advised the DCMS that the role requires a three to four day time commitment.
Deputy labour leader Harriet Harman, who has raised fears about political bias influencing the recruitment process, said that there had been no consultation about the changes.
“The chair of the BBC Trust is an important role and the appointment must be made on merit and not on party political lines,” she said. “We have real concerns that these changes signal that the process is being changed to suit a particular applicant for political reasons. This is a significant difference in approach and there has been no consultation.”
On Thursday the DCMS also revealed the three-strong panel who will interview the candidates in the week beginning 28 July.On Thursday the DCMS also revealed the three-strong panel who will interview the candidates in the week beginning 28 July.
Cabinet secretary Sir Jeremy Heywood, one of the country’s top civil servants, is named as the panellist “representing government”.Cabinet secretary Sir Jeremy Heywood, one of the country’s top civil servants, is named as the panellist “representing government”.
Carolyn Fairbairn, a former senior executive at the BBC and ITV, has been named for her “extensive experience of the industry”. Fairbairn, who left ITV in 2011, is a non-executive director at Capita and Lloyds Banking Group as well as the board of the Competition and Markets Authority.Carolyn Fairbairn, a former senior executive at the BBC and ITV, has been named for her “extensive experience of the industry”. Fairbairn, who left ITV in 2011, is a non-executive director at Capita and Lloyds Banking Group as well as the board of the Competition and Markets Authority.
Lord Kakkar, professor of surgery at University College London, who joined the House of Lords in 2010, is listed as the “independent” panel member.Lord Kakkar, professor of surgery at University College London, who joined the House of Lords in 2010, is listed as the “independent” panel member.
The interview panel is chaired by Addison, to make sure the process complies with the code of practice of the commissioner for public appointments.The interview panel is chaired by Addison, to make sure the process complies with the code of practice of the commissioner for public appointments.
According to that code appointments must be made based on three core principles: merit, openness and fairness.According to that code appointments must be made based on three core principles: merit, openness and fairness.
“The selection processes must be objective, impartial and applied consistently to all candidates,” states the code under the fairness principle. “The selection of appointable candidates is made on merit on the basis of fair and open competition.”“The selection processes must be objective, impartial and applied consistently to all candidates,” states the code under the fairness principle. “The selection of appointable candidates is made on merit on the basis of fair and open competition.”
One senior media industry executive considering applying for the post said that the development was “shocking” and unnerving.One senior media industry executive considering applying for the post said that the development was “shocking” and unnerving.
“I’ve heard that the BBC advised three to four days a week was necessary to do the job so this is quite shocking,” he said. “It looks like they are targeting a certain someone in particular. It is meant to be an open appointments process.”“I’ve heard that the BBC advised three to four days a week was necessary to do the job so this is quite shocking,” he said. “It looks like they are targeting a certain someone in particular. It is meant to be an open appointments process.”
• To contact the MediaGuardian news desk email media@theguardian.com or phone 020 3353 3857. For all other inquiries please call the main Guardian switchboard on 020 3353 2000. If you are writing a comment for publication, please mark clearly “for publication”.• To contact the MediaGuardian news desk email media@theguardian.com or phone 020 3353 3857. For all other inquiries please call the main Guardian switchboard on 020 3353 2000. If you are writing a comment for publication, please mark clearly “for publication”.
• To get the latest media news to your desktop or mobile, follow MediaGuardian on Twitter and Facebook.• To get the latest media news to your desktop or mobile, follow MediaGuardian on Twitter and Facebook.