This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-28144406
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Google removing BBC link was 'not a good judgement' | Google removing BBC link was 'not a good judgement' |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| Google's decision to remove a BBC article from some of its search results was "not a good judgement", a European Commission spokesman has said. | Google's decision to remove a BBC article from some of its search results was "not a good judgement", a European Commission spokesman has said. |
| A link to an article by Robert Peston was taken down under the European court's "right to be forgotten" ruling. | A link to an article by Robert Peston was taken down under the European court's "right to be forgotten" ruling. |
| But Ryan Heath, spokesman for the European Commission's vice-president, said he could not see a "reasonable public interest" for the action. | But Ryan Heath, spokesman for the European Commission's vice-president, said he could not see a "reasonable public interest" for the action. |
| He said the ruling should not allow people to "Photoshop their lives". | He said the ruling should not allow people to "Photoshop their lives". |
| The BBC understands that Google is sifting through more than 250,000 web links people wanted removed. | The BBC understands that Google is sifting through more than 250,000 web links people wanted removed. |
| 1,000 per day | 1,000 per day |
| The figure relates to more than 70,000 individual requests made between 29 May and 30 June - with an average of 3.8 links requested per person. | The figure relates to more than 70,000 individual requests made between 29 May and 30 June - with an average of 3.8 links requested per person. |
| After an initial surge, the rate of requests has levelled out at about 1,000 per day. | After an initial surge, the rate of requests has levelled out at about 1,000 per day. |
| The highest number of requests so far has originated in France, with 14,086 requests made in the same period. France is followed by Germany, with 12,678, and the UK with 8,497. | The highest number of requests so far has originated in France, with 14,086 requests made in the same period. France is followed by Germany, with 12,678, and the UK with 8,497. |
| It is not known how many of the requests have been successful. | It is not known how many of the requests have been successful. |
| Analysis | Analysis |
| Robert Peston, BBC economics editor | Robert Peston, BBC economics editor |
| What Google has done is not quite the assault on public-interest journalism that it might have seemed. | What Google has done is not quite the assault on public-interest journalism that it might have seemed. |
| Unless, that is, you believe that when someone makes a public comment on a media website, that is something that is voluntarily done and should not be stricken from the record - except when what is at stake is a matter of life and death. | Unless, that is, you believe that when someone makes a public comment on a media website, that is something that is voluntarily done and should not be stricken from the record - except when what is at stake is a matter of life and death. |
| Read more: Why has Google cast me into oblivion? | |
| Google has begun notifying media companies, including the BBC and the Guardian, that it started to remove links over the past week. | Google has begun notifying media companies, including the BBC and the Guardian, that it started to remove links over the past week. |
| Among them, were links to an article about the bank Merrill Lynch, posted by BBC economics editor Robert Peston in October 2007. | Among them, were links to an article about the bank Merrill Lynch, posted by BBC economics editor Robert Peston in October 2007. |
| The identity of the person who made the request is not yet known, although it is understood not to have been the subject of the article, former Merrill Lynch boss Stan O'Neal. | The identity of the person who made the request is not yet known, although it is understood not to have been the subject of the article, former Merrill Lynch boss Stan O'Neal. |
| Instead, the request relates to the reader comments that appear underneath the story. | Instead, the request relates to the reader comments that appear underneath the story. |
| The article will now no longer appear in Google search results whenever someone searches for the name of the person who made the request. | The article will now no longer appear in Google search results whenever someone searches for the name of the person who made the request. |
| However, if the same search is done outside Europe, the result will appear as normal. | However, if the same search is done outside Europe, the result will appear as normal. |
| 'Tactical' | 'Tactical' |
| Ryan Heath is the spokesman for Neelie Kroes, the European Commission's vice-president. Ms Kroes is leading Europe's efforts in enforcing new privacy legislation. | Ryan Heath is the spokesman for Neelie Kroes, the European Commission's vice-president. Ms Kroes is leading Europe's efforts in enforcing new privacy legislation. |
| Mr Heath argued Google's decision regarding the BBC article may have been "tactical". | Mr Heath argued Google's decision regarding the BBC article may have been "tactical". |
| "Google clearly has a strong interest in making sure that they're able to work with whatever the legal requirements are, so they position themselves in a particular way over that," he said. | "Google clearly has a strong interest in making sure that they're able to work with whatever the legal requirements are, so they position themselves in a particular way over that," he said. |
| "It doesn't come cheap to deal with all of these requests, so they need to find some way to come up with dealing with them. | "It doesn't come cheap to deal with all of these requests, so they need to find some way to come up with dealing with them. |
| A right to be forgotten? | A right to be forgotten? |
| "It may be that they've decided that it's simply cheaper to just say yes to all of these requests." | "It may be that they've decided that it's simply cheaper to just say yes to all of these requests." |
| He added: "That's going to spark its own debate, and rightly so." | He added: "That's going to spark its own debate, and rightly so." |
| Google has insisted it will look at each request on merit. | Google has insisted it will look at each request on merit. |
| "We have recently started taking action on the removals requests we've received after the European Court of Justice decision," the company said in an emailed statement. | "We have recently started taking action on the removals requests we've received after the European Court of Justice decision," the company said in an emailed statement. |
| "This is a new and evolving process for us. We'll continue to listen to feedback and will also work with data protection authorities and others as we comply with the ruling." | "This is a new and evolving process for us. We'll continue to listen to feedback and will also work with data protection authorities and others as we comply with the ruling." |
| Follow Dave Lee on Twitter @DaveLeeBBC | Follow Dave Lee on Twitter @DaveLeeBBC |