This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/wales/south_east/7125621.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Fake CV man loses racism job case | Fake CV man loses racism job case |
| (2 days later) | |
| A Pakistan-born engineer who claimed he was racially discriminated against by a company because of his name has lost his case. | |
| Qamar Mohammed Malik told an employment tribunal that construction company Amec Group Ltd's Treforest branch ignored a CV sent under his own name. | Qamar Mohammed Malik told an employment tribunal that construction company Amec Group Ltd's Treforest branch ignored a CV sent under his own name. |
| But when the 49-year-old, of Cardiff, sent a fake CV using a Welsh name he was granted an interview, he said. | But when the 49-year-old, of Cardiff, sent a fake CV using a Welsh name he was granted an interview, he said. |
| Amec, which had denied the claim, welcomed the tribunal's decision. | Amec, which had denied the claim, welcomed the tribunal's decision. |
| Mr Malik said he was "disappointed" with the ruling, which was announced on Monday. | Mr Malik said he was "disappointed" with the ruling, which was announced on Monday. |
| He added: "I have to accept the ruling and move on but I hope some lessons have been learned. | He added: "I have to accept the ruling and move on but I hope some lessons have been learned. |
| We are a major international company, employing many thousands of people around the world, and select people solely on their suitability for the particular job Amec spokesman | We are a major international company, employing many thousands of people around the world, and select people solely on their suitability for the particular job Amec spokesman |
| "I was not looking for compensation. I just wanted to make a point and stop discrimination happening. | "I was not looking for compensation. I just wanted to make a point and stop discrimination happening. |
| "I have four children and I don't want them to experience it when they get older and start looking for a career." | "I have four children and I don't want them to experience it when they get older and start looking for a career." |
| He told the Cardiff hearing last month that he first applied for a job in November 2006, e-mailing his CV to Amec's office manager in Treforest, near Pontypridd. | He told the Cardiff hearing last month that he first applied for a job in November 2006, e-mailing his CV to Amec's office manager in Treforest, near Pontypridd. |
| When he was told there were no vacancies, Mr Malik composed a similar CV with inferior qualifications, using the name Rhyddir Aled Lloyd-Hilbert. | When he was told there were no vacancies, Mr Malik composed a similar CV with inferior qualifications, using the name Rhyddir Aled Lloyd-Hilbert. |
| The fictional man had fewer O-levels than Mr Malik and was slightly older. | The fictional man had fewer O-levels than Mr Malik and was slightly older. |
| Mr Malik claimed Amec responded "positively" to the fictional CV of Mr Lloyd-Hilbert, who was told he could earn up to £33,000 with the firm. | Mr Malik claimed Amec responded "positively" to the fictional CV of Mr Lloyd-Hilbert, who was told he could earn up to £33,000 with the firm. |
| The company always denied Mr Malik's claims | The company always denied Mr Malik's claims |
| Speaking during the tribunal, he said he decided to send a fictitious CV using a Welsh-sounding name because the rejection by Amec had been at "severe odds" with advice he was previously given by the company. | Speaking during the tribunal, he said he decided to send a fictitious CV using a Welsh-sounding name because the rejection by Amec had been at "severe odds" with advice he was previously given by the company. |
| He added: "It smacked of the racism that I used to experience in the early 1980s." | He added: "It smacked of the racism that I used to experience in the early 1980s." |
| But Mike Hartwell, catchment manager for the construction arm of Amec at the time, told the tribunal the fictitious CV had also been rejected for the site engineer role Mr Malik originally applied for. | But Mike Hartwell, catchment manager for the construction arm of Amec at the time, told the tribunal the fictitious CV had also been rejected for the site engineer role Mr Malik originally applied for. |
| He said Mr Lloyd-Hilbert was contacted regarding a quality inspector role because he indicated he was planning to move to Wales, whereas Mr Malik had a Reading address on his CV. | He said Mr Lloyd-Hilbert was contacted regarding a quality inspector role because he indicated he was planning to move to Wales, whereas Mr Malik had a Reading address on his CV. |
| Unanimous | Unanimous |
| The tribunal panel ruled unanimously that his "claim of race discrimination is not well founded and is dismissed." | The tribunal panel ruled unanimously that his "claim of race discrimination is not well founded and is dismissed." |
| An Amec spokesman said: "We welcome the unanimous decision made by the Cardiff employment tribunal, which fully recognises that we did not racially discriminate against Mr Malik. | An Amec spokesman said: "We welcome the unanimous decision made by the Cardiff employment tribunal, which fully recognises that we did not racially discriminate against Mr Malik. |
| "We are a major international company, employing many thousands of people around the world, and select people solely on their suitability for the particular job. | "We are a major international company, employing many thousands of people around the world, and select people solely on their suitability for the particular job. |
| "Our code of business conduct, which all of our people are required to follow, makes it clear that discrimination on racial or other prohibited grounds is not tolerated under any circumstances." | "Our code of business conduct, which all of our people are required to follow, makes it clear that discrimination on racial or other prohibited grounds is not tolerated under any circumstances." |