This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk/7128181.stm
The article has changed 15 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Review of prison overcrowding due | Review of prison overcrowding due |
| (10 minutes later) | |
| Sentencing in England and Wales should be more closely linked to the number of jail places available, a major review is expected to recommend. | Sentencing in England and Wales should be more closely linked to the number of jail places available, a major review is expected to recommend. |
| Lord Carter of Coles will advise jail sentences in certain cases should be given only if there are empty cells - in a bid to balance demand with supply. | Lord Carter of Coles will advise jail sentences in certain cases should be given only if there are empty cells - in a bid to balance demand with supply. |
| He is also expected to propose limiting indeterminate prison sentences and expanding community penalties. | He is also expected to propose limiting indeterminate prison sentences and expanding community penalties. |
| Ministers are due to stress jail is the only option for dangerous offenders. | Ministers are due to stress jail is the only option for dangerous offenders. |
| The review was set up by ministers to look at prison overcrowding. | The review was set up by ministers to look at prison overcrowding. |
| 'Controversial move' | 'Controversial move' |
| Former Justice Secretary Lord Falconer tasked Lord Carter with investigating the supply of prison places and demand for them in the short, medium and longer term. | Former Justice Secretary Lord Falconer tasked Lord Carter with investigating the supply of prison places and demand for them in the short, medium and longer term. |
| However, the conclusions of the review are expected to be approved by his successor, Jack Straw. | However, the conclusions of the review are expected to be approved by his successor, Jack Straw. |
| BBC home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw said Lord Carter's recommendation for the long term - to only award jail sentences if prison cells are available - is likely to prove controversial. | BBC home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw said Lord Carter's recommendation for the long term - to only award jail sentences if prison cells are available - is likely to prove controversial. |
| Facts and figures on prisons in the UKIn graphics | Facts and figures on prisons in the UKIn graphics |
| But, our correspondent said, it was not yet clear how the system would operate. | But, our correspondent said, it was not yet clear how the system would operate. |
| Lord Carter consulted the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, Lord Phillips, who has also suggested linking resources to the setting of the sentencing framework. | Lord Carter consulted the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, Lord Phillips, who has also suggested linking resources to the setting of the sentencing framework. |
| Last month, Lord Philips told a Howard League for Penal Reform event that UK jails were "full to capacity", adding: "We simply cannot go on like this." | Last month, Lord Philips told a Howard League for Penal Reform event that UK jails were "full to capacity", adding: "We simply cannot go on like this." |
| He said the consequences of giving longer sentences for murder and other serious crimes had not been foreseen by ministers and called for more emphasis on fines and community rehabilitation as well as increased effort to tackle family breakdown. | He said the consequences of giving longer sentences for murder and other serious crimes had not been foreseen by ministers and called for more emphasis on fines and community rehabilitation as well as increased effort to tackle family breakdown. |
| Juliet Lyon, director of the Prison Reform Trust, welcomed the acknowledgement of overcrowding represented by the report. | Juliet Lyon, director of the Prison Reform Trust, welcomed the acknowledgement of overcrowding represented by the report. |
| She told the BBC: "It would be a recognition that we have got into a really terrible mess over a long period of time - prisons have been overcrowded since 1994." | She told the BBC: "It would be a recognition that we have got into a really terrible mess over a long period of time - prisons have been overcrowded since 1994." |
| 'Kafkaesque' | |
| She described indeterminate sentences as "badly drafted" and "Kafkaesque". | She described indeterminate sentences as "badly drafted" and "Kafkaesque". |
| Ms Lyon explained that in order to be released from an indeterminate sentence, prisoners must prove they are no longer a threat to the public by doing courses while in prison, but the courses are often not available to them. | Ms Lyon explained that in order to be released from an indeterminate sentence, prisoners must prove they are no longer a threat to the public by doing courses while in prison, but the courses are often not available to them. |
| But shadow justice minister Nick Herbert said the solution was to provide more prison places, not refrain from sentencing criminals to imprisonment. | But shadow justice minister Nick Herbert said the solution was to provide more prison places, not refrain from sentencing criminals to imprisonment. |
| Mr Herbert said: "The government should provide emergency short-term capacity to house these prisoners." | Mr Herbert said: "The government should provide emergency short-term capacity to house these prisoners." |
| Firstly, most have been through the gamut of community sentences already, and secondly, these community sentences aren't robust Nick Herbert, shadow justice minister | |
| He said it was "extraordinary" that the government was suggesting limits on indeterminate sentences because they had been brought in by Labour and previously worn as a "badge of honour". | He said it was "extraordinary" that the government was suggesting limits on indeterminate sentences because they had been brought in by Labour and previously worn as a "badge of honour". |
| Mr Herbert also criticised plans to expand the use of community sentences. | Mr Herbert also criticised plans to expand the use of community sentences. |
| He said: "Firstly, most have been through the gamut of community sentences already, and secondly, these community sentences aren't robust." | He said: "Firstly, most have been through the gamut of community sentences already, and secondly, these community sentences aren't robust." |
| The latest prison population figure for England and Wales show it has dropped to 81,455 from a record high earlier in November | The latest prison population figure for England and Wales show it has dropped to 81,455 from a record high earlier in November |
| The Ministry of Justice says that since Labour came into power in 1997, there are 20,000 more prison places - 3,100 of which were built in the last two years. | The Ministry of Justice says that since Labour came into power in 1997, there are 20,000 more prison places - 3,100 of which were built in the last two years. |