This article is from the source 'washpo' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/texas-is-fuming-because-mexico-isnt-sending-the-water-it-owes/2014/09/07/fb82914c-463d-409e-853c-be44e386cc45_story.html?wprss=rss_world
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Amid drought, Texas is fuming because Mexico isn’t sending the water it owes | Amid drought, Texas is fuming because Mexico isn’t sending the water it owes |
| (about 4 hours later) | |
| CIUDAD ACUÑA, Mexico — In 1944, President Harry S. Truman signed a treaty intended to bring fair play to the fight for water in the parched deserts of the U.S.-Mexico borderlands. | CIUDAD ACUÑA, Mexico — In 1944, President Harry S. Truman signed a treaty intended to bring fair play to the fight for water in the parched deserts of the U.S.-Mexico borderlands. |
| Seventy years later, engineer Roberto Enriquez de la Garza stood on the lip of the Amistad dam — vultures circling overhead, grassy islands poking out of the depleted reservoir below — and explained why Mexico can’t hold up its share of the bargain. | Seventy years later, engineer Roberto Enriquez de la Garza stood on the lip of the Amistad dam — vultures circling overhead, grassy islands poking out of the depleted reservoir below — and explained why Mexico can’t hold up its share of the bargain. |
| “The U.S. gets angry: Why aren’t you giving us water? Well, how can we when there is no water?” he asked. “I can’t do anything. It’s not raining.” | “The U.S. gets angry: Why aren’t you giving us water? Well, how can we when there is no water?” he asked. “I can’t do anything. It’s not raining.” |
| The historic drought across the western United States that has drained the water table in California, and devastated rivers and reservoirs in Arizona, has intensified a diplomatic dispute here along the Texas border. Under the terms of the treaty, the United States is obliged to give Mexico water from the Colorado River, while Mexico must transfer water from the Rio Grande and its tributaries. | The historic drought across the western United States that has drained the water table in California, and devastated rivers and reservoirs in Arizona, has intensified a diplomatic dispute here along the Texas border. Under the terms of the treaty, the United States is obliged to give Mexico water from the Colorado River, while Mexico must transfer water from the Rio Grande and its tributaries. |
| But in recent years, Mexico has fallen behind on its obligation. The accounting for the water sharing gets tallied in five-year cycles. And at this point, in the fourth year of the cycle, Mexico currently owes the United States 380,000 acre-feet of water, more than all the water consumed in a year by the 1.5 million Texas residents living in the Lower Rio Grande Valley. | But in recent years, Mexico has fallen behind on its obligation. The accounting for the water sharing gets tallied in five-year cycles. And at this point, in the fourth year of the cycle, Mexico currently owes the United States 380,000 acre-feet of water, more than all the water consumed in a year by the 1.5 million Texas residents living in the Lower Rio Grande Valley. |
| “This issue is life or death for some of our farmers, their ability to support their families and make a living,” said Texas state Rep. Eddie Lucio III (D), who has been leading the charge to make Mexico give from its rivers. “We’ve been good neighbors. We just want to share and share alike.” | “This issue is life or death for some of our farmers, their ability to support their families and make a living,” said Texas state Rep. Eddie Lucio III (D), who has been leading the charge to make Mexico give from its rivers. “We’ve been good neighbors. We just want to share and share alike.” |
| The Amistad dam, with its one-quarter-full, border-straddling reservoir, is ground zero for the dispute. Finished during the Nixon administration in 1969, the dam is jointly administered by the two countries: Of the 16 floodgates, eight are maintained by Mexico and eight by the United States. Each country operates a hydroelectric power plant at the dam, and water levels and releases are calculated and coordinated by engineers from both countries. In the Cold War-era control rooms, clocks show both Mexican and U.S. time zones. | The Amistad dam, with its one-quarter-full, border-straddling reservoir, is ground zero for the dispute. Finished during the Nixon administration in 1969, the dam is jointly administered by the two countries: Of the 16 floodgates, eight are maintained by Mexico and eight by the United States. Each country operates a hydroelectric power plant at the dam, and water levels and releases are calculated and coordinated by engineers from both countries. In the Cold War-era control rooms, clocks show both Mexican and U.S. time zones. |
| Mexico doesn’t dispute its water debt, but says that its own shortages make it impossible, at this point, to comply with the annual 350,000 acre-feet to be given to the United States. | Mexico doesn’t dispute its water debt, but says that its own shortages make it impossible, at this point, to comply with the annual 350,000 acre-feet to be given to the United States. |
| “We have had a prolonged drought since 1994 until now. It has been difficult for Mexico to give this water,” said Ignacio Peña Treviño, Mexico’s representative here on the International Boundary and Water Commission. “There isn’t rain like there was in the past.” | “We have had a prolonged drought since 1994 until now. It has been difficult for Mexico to give this water,” said Ignacio Peña Treviño, Mexico’s representative here on the International Boundary and Water Commission. “There isn’t rain like there was in the past.” |
| The treaty stipulates that in the event of a dam failure or “extraordinary drought,” either side could make up its shortage in the next five-year cycle. But water officials in Texas don’t think Mexico’s weather conditions meet that standard. | The treaty stipulates that in the event of a dam failure or “extraordinary drought,” either side could make up its shortage in the next five-year cycle. But water officials in Texas don’t think Mexico’s weather conditions meet that standard. |
| “They haven’t been in any sort of significant drought conditions since March of 2012,” said Carlos Rubinstein, chairman of the Texas Water Development Board. “That excuse, pardon the pun, doesn’t hold water.” | |
| Texas’s water supply has improved since its most acute drought a few years ago — in 2011, all 254 counties were suffering drought conditions. But pockets of the state are still suffering. Cities such as Raymondville and Rio Hondo have had to purchase water from other jurisdictions. | Texas’s water supply has improved since its most acute drought a few years ago — in 2011, all 254 counties were suffering drought conditions. But pockets of the state are still suffering. Cities such as Raymondville and Rio Hondo have had to purchase water from other jurisdictions. |
| A Texas A&M study estimated that Mexico’s failure to share water was causing a loss of nearly 5,000 jobs and $229 million in revenues from crops such as cotton, corn, sorghum and citrus fruits. | A Texas A&M study estimated that Mexico’s failure to share water was causing a loss of nearly 5,000 jobs and $229 million in revenues from crops such as cotton, corn, sorghum and citrus fruits. |
| Texas officials of all ranks clamor for relief. Gov. Rick Perry (R) wrote to President Obama last year about the problem. Federal and state legislators are demanding the State Department take further action to pressure Mexico to comply with the treaty. U.S. and Mexican technical officials regularly discuss the issue, Rubinstein said, but “without State Department support, none of it has translated into a meaningful agreement.” | |
| “In my mind,” he said of the State Department’s efforts, “they have failed.” | “In my mind,” he said of the State Department’s efforts, “they have failed.” |
| The diplomats insist they are engaged. Roberta Jacobson, the State Department’s top official for Latin America, wrote in a letter last year that she and her colleagues raise the water issue “everywhere we encounter Mexican leaders.” She said “we will persist in our advocacy until we achieve our goal of securing sufficient water deliveries from Mexico to relieve the hardship of south Texas communities.” A U.S. official who was not authorized to speak publicly said that they are "continuing to stress to the government of Mexico the importance we place on reaching agreement on a durable solution quickly." | The diplomats insist they are engaged. Roberta Jacobson, the State Department’s top official for Latin America, wrote in a letter last year that she and her colleagues raise the water issue “everywhere we encounter Mexican leaders.” She said “we will persist in our advocacy until we achieve our goal of securing sufficient water deliveries from Mexico to relieve the hardship of south Texas communities.” A U.S. official who was not authorized to speak publicly said that they are "continuing to stress to the government of Mexico the importance we place on reaching agreement on a durable solution quickly." |
| Whether their drought qualifies as “extraordinary” or not, on the Mexican side the signs of a dwindling water supply are everywhere. Grim little tributaries seem to barely clear the rocks before they reach the Rio Grande. Even if the floodgates were opened at the Amistad dam, the water level wouldn’t reach them. | Whether their drought qualifies as “extraordinary” or not, on the Mexican side the signs of a dwindling water supply are everywhere. Grim little tributaries seem to barely clear the rocks before they reach the Rio Grande. Even if the floodgates were opened at the Amistad dam, the water level wouldn’t reach them. |
| Though the United States may not be getting its full legal share, Mexican officials point out that their northern neighbor still draws far more out of the reservoir than they do. Of the 23 cubic meters per second flowing out of the reservoir on an average day, the U.S. is using 20 of them. Texas officials argue that if Mexico managed its tributaries better there would be more water for both sides. | Though the United States may not be getting its full legal share, Mexican officials point out that their northern neighbor still draws far more out of the reservoir than they do. Of the 23 cubic meters per second flowing out of the reservoir on an average day, the U.S. is using 20 of them. Texas officials argue that if Mexico managed its tributaries better there would be more water for both sides. |
| At the same time, demand for water in Mexico has also grown sharply. Many people have moved to Ciudad Acuña, the town closest to the dam, to fill factory jobs making parts for Mexico’s booming auto industry. The population in the past 20 years has nearly doubled. | At the same time, demand for water in Mexico has also grown sharply. Many people have moved to Ciudad Acuña, the town closest to the dam, to fill factory jobs making parts for Mexico’s booming auto industry. The population in the past 20 years has nearly doubled. |
| In these dry times, Mexican officials argue, the need to drink and irrigate crops trumps Truman’s treaty. | In these dry times, Mexican officials argue, the need to drink and irrigate crops trumps Truman’s treaty. |
| “You can’t leave people without water,” Enriquez said. | “You can’t leave people without water,” Enriquez said. |
| Correction: An earlier version of this story misspelled Carlos Rubinstein’s note. It has been corrected. |