This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-china-29125768
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Why China's wary of Scottish independence | Why China's wary of Scottish independence |
(about 14 hours later) | |
The scale of the Great Wall of China as it snakes up and down the hills outside Beijing is stunning. | The scale of the Great Wall of China as it snakes up and down the hills outside Beijing is stunning. |
China built the wall centuries ago to defend the country from its northern neighbours. | China built the wall centuries ago to defend the country from its northern neighbours. |
On the day we visited you could hear the strains of the bagpipes floating over its watch towers. | |
The instrument was played by George Tian - one of just a handful of Chinese pipers. The 31-year-old can wax lyrical about all things Scottish despite having never set foot in the country. | The instrument was played by George Tian - one of just a handful of Chinese pipers. The 31-year-old can wax lyrical about all things Scottish despite having never set foot in the country. |
He first heard pipe music a decade ago and was instantly smitten. "It makes me cry, it cheers me up," he said, explaining his passion for the music. | He first heard pipe music a decade ago and was instantly smitten. "It makes me cry, it cheers me up," he said, explaining his passion for the music. |
But on the issue of Scottish politics, George became uncharacteristically quiet. | But on the issue of Scottish politics, George became uncharacteristically quiet. |
Despite standing in a kilt with bagpipes tucked under his arm, he refused to be drawn on whether he'd like to see an independent Scotland. | Despite standing in a kilt with bagpipes tucked under his arm, he refused to be drawn on whether he'd like to see an independent Scotland. |
"I'm not Scottish, I'm not even British," said George. "It's up to the Scottish people and I will respect their right." | "I'm not Scottish, I'm not even British," said George. "It's up to the Scottish people and I will respect their right." |
His personal reticence was a reflection of China's official policy of "non-interference" in other countries' internal affairs. But as Beijing's influence grows on the world stage, it is a policy that is increasingly under strain. | His personal reticence was a reflection of China's official policy of "non-interference" in other countries' internal affairs. But as Beijing's influence grows on the world stage, it is a policy that is increasingly under strain. |
Becoming "second-rate" | Becoming "second-rate" |
Perhaps, inevitably, on a visit to Britain earlier this year, China's Premier Li Keqiang was asked where he stood on Scottish independence. | Perhaps, inevitably, on a visit to Britain earlier this year, China's Premier Li Keqiang was asked where he stood on Scottish independence. |
Mr Li said he wanted to see a "united" United Kingdom, adding that he believed the UK could "stay at the forefront in leading the world's growth and development". | Mr Li said he wanted to see a "united" United Kingdom, adding that he believed the UK could "stay at the forefront in leading the world's growth and development". |
His reply should not have come as a surprise. It reflects Beijing's worry about any independence movement - even one half the world away - inspiring its own minorities. | His reply should not have come as a surprise. It reflects Beijing's worry about any independence movement - even one half the world away - inspiring its own minorities. |
Whereas in Scotland people are being offered a vote to determine their future, in China any talk of separation is regarded as treason and will get you locked up. | Whereas in Scotland people are being offered a vote to determine their future, in China any talk of separation is regarded as treason and will get you locked up. |
In its western region of Xinjiang, Beijing has launched a huge security crackdown against what it calls Uighur separatists. In Tibet, people have long claimed of repression under Chinese rule. | In its western region of Xinjiang, Beijing has launched a huge security crackdown against what it calls Uighur separatists. In Tibet, people have long claimed of repression under Chinese rule. |
And in the case of Taiwan, Beijing says it has the right to use military force if the island declares formal independence. | And in the case of Taiwan, Beijing says it has the right to use military force if the island declares formal independence. |
"In history whenever China has been united it has done better," said Victor Gao, a political analyst. "The economy does better and the living standards of people improve. When the country's been fragmented or occupied, ordinary people have been worse off." | "In history whenever China has been united it has done better," said Victor Gao, a political analyst. "The economy does better and the living standards of people improve. When the country's been fragmented or occupied, ordinary people have been worse off." |
For that reason, Mr Gao says most Chinese find it "unbelievable" that London would even allow the Scots to vote on separation, never mind actually letting the UK split up. | For that reason, Mr Gao says most Chinese find it "unbelievable" that London would even allow the Scots to vote on separation, never mind actually letting the UK split up. |
The state-run Global Times newspaper said in an editorial this week that if Scotland votes yes then Britain will descend from "a first-class country to a second-rate one." | The state-run Global Times newspaper said in an editorial this week that if Scotland votes yes then Britain will descend from "a first-class country to a second-rate one." |
It said the move "would break the balance of power within Europe" and may even "wield influence upon international geopolitics." | It said the move "would break the balance of power within Europe" and may even "wield influence upon international geopolitics." |
Too many questions | Too many questions |
One of the small ironies is that the First Minister and leader of the Yes campaign, Alex Salmond, says he'll make Beijing a key economic partner if Scotland achieves independence. | One of the small ironies is that the First Minister and leader of the Yes campaign, Alex Salmond, says he'll make Beijing a key economic partner if Scotland achieves independence. |
At a whisky fair in the capital, it's clear that the Chinese have acquired a thirst for what comes out of Scotland. | At a whisky fair in the capital, it's clear that the Chinese have acquired a thirst for what comes out of Scotland. |
Total Scottish exports - including whisky - to China were their highest ever last year, worth more than a half a billion pounds. | Total Scottish exports - including whisky - to China were their highest ever last year, worth more than a half a billion pounds. |
Stephen Notman, the event's co-organiser, was bullish about the growth of Scottish exports in China. But when it came to Scottish politics, he was staying out of it. | Stephen Notman, the event's co-organiser, was bullish about the growth of Scottish exports in China. But when it came to Scottish politics, he was staying out of it. |
"The Chinese are always asking us about it with genuine interest," he said. "They want to know what's going to happen." | "The Chinese are always asking us about it with genuine interest," he said. "They want to know what's going to happen." |
"But it can be sensitive here and raises other questions about issues we probably don't want to talk about." | "But it can be sensitive here and raises other questions about issues we probably don't want to talk about." |
All politics in China is sensitive, even the politics of a nation thousands of miles away. | All politics in China is sensitive, even the politics of a nation thousands of miles away. |
And while more people are enjoying a wee dram here, there's certainly no clamour for Scottish independence in China. | And while more people are enjoying a wee dram here, there's certainly no clamour for Scottish independence in China. |
Previous version
1
Next version