This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/11/world/europe/petro-poreshenko-voices-hope-on-cease-fire.html

The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 1 Version 2
Most Russian Forces Now Out of Ukraine, Kiev Says Most Russian Forces Now Out of Ukraine, Kiev Says
(about 2 hours later)
KIEV, Ukraine — President Petro O. Poroshenko of Ukraine said on Wednesday that the bulk of Russian forces had withdrawn from Ukrainian territory, a move that he said augmented the chances for a lasting cease-fire in the southeast.KIEV, Ukraine — President Petro O. Poroshenko of Ukraine said on Wednesday that the bulk of Russian forces had withdrawn from Ukrainian territory, a move that he said augmented the chances for a lasting cease-fire in the southeast.
Speaking at the start of a cabinet meeting that was broadcast nationally, the president also announced plans to move ahead with laws designed to cement the wobbly truce reached last Friday. Speaking at the start of a cabinet meeting that was broadcast nationally, the president also announced plans to move ahead with a law intended to cement the wobbly truce reached last Friday.
Mr. Poroshenko appeared to be trying to create a sense of momentum around the peace process, even though a final outcome remains the subject of arduous negotiations. The very law he discussed, for example, has been the source of widely different interpretations.Mr. Poroshenko appeared to be trying to create a sense of momentum around the peace process, even though a final outcome remains the subject of arduous negotiations. The very law he discussed, for example, has been the source of widely different interpretations.
“Based on the latest information I have received from our intelligence services, 70 percent of the Russian troops have moved back across the border,” Mr. Poroshenko said. “This bolsters our hope that the peace initiatives enjoy good prospects.”“Based on the latest information I have received from our intelligence services, 70 percent of the Russian troops have moved back across the border,” Mr. Poroshenko said. “This bolsters our hope that the peace initiatives enjoy good prospects.”
Still, he noted that the cease-fire remained shaky, accusing Russian-backed militias of constantly trying to provoke the Ukrainian forces. He sounded a hopeful note overall, however, saying the situation had “radically changed.”Still, he noted that the cease-fire remained shaky, accusing Russian-backed militias of constantly trying to provoke the Ukrainian forces. He sounded a hopeful note overall, however, saying the situation had “radically changed.”
A day after Russia accused Ukraine of massing its forces in the east, Mr. Poroshenko said that the military was redeploying its troops there to defend Ukrainian territory against any possible renewed attack. With peace prospects still uncertain the European Union was considering a timetable for imposing sanctions against Russia’s energy and banking sectors in an effort to compel the Kremlin to support the cease-fire more actively.
Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany told the Parliament in Berlin on Wednesday that the new sanctions, approved by leaders of the European Union on Monday, should be applied immediately because the cease-fire protocol had not been put fully into effect, even if the situation had improved. Ms. Merkel’s assessment did not differ markedly from that of Ukraine, but she chose to emphasize the “lack of clarity” in the fulfillment of numerous points of the plan.
ederica Mogherini, the Italian foreign minister and the European Union’s new foreign policy chief-designate, told reporters on Wednesday that Ukraine’s foreign minister, Pavlo Klimkin, had told her the cease-fire was “basically holding” but asked for more European pressure on Russia.
“He told me we need new sanctions,” Ms. Mogherini said.
She indicated that European countries were struggling to find a common position on when to actually impose the new sanctions. She said some countries wanted a new discussion by 28 leaders, which would in effect put matters back where they started when they met in Brussels on Aug 30. Ambassadors, meanwhile, are meeting in Brussels on Wednesday y to try to chart a unified course.
In late August, Ukrainian troops were overwhelmed by separatists, widely believed to be backed by Russian forces, who reversed weeks of gains. The cease-fire agreement was reached in Minsk, Belarus, soon afterward.In late August, Ukrainian troops were overwhelmed by separatists, widely believed to be backed by Russian forces, who reversed weeks of gains. The cease-fire agreement was reached in Minsk, Belarus, soon afterward.
Russia has long denied sending arms or troops across the border. But NATO has said that at least 1,000 Russians were deployed in late August, and even a separatist commander said that up to 4,000 Russians, including active troops, had fought in Ukraine, although he described them as volunteers who were using their vacation time.Russia has long denied sending arms or troops across the border. But NATO has said that at least 1,000 Russians were deployed in late August, and even a separatist commander said that up to 4,000 Russians, including active troops, had fought in Ukraine, although he described them as volunteers who were using their vacation time.
Mr. Poroshenko, who is due to meet with President Obama in Washington on Sept. 18, also said he would introduce a law as early as next week that would grant parts of the breakaway regions of Donetsk and Luhansk temporary self-rule.Mr. Poroshenko, who is due to meet with President Obama in Washington on Sept. 18, also said he would introduce a law as early as next week that would grant parts of the breakaway regions of Donetsk and Luhansk temporary self-rule.
Even though representatives of the two main breakaway regions signed the cease-fire agreement, their goals are not always clear. Some leaders have said they would continue to push for independence. They began fighting five months ago to join Russia, although the Kremlin has never signaled it would take them.Even though representatives of the two main breakaway regions signed the cease-fire agreement, their goals are not always clear. Some leaders have said they would continue to push for independence. They began fighting five months ago to join Russia, although the Kremlin has never signaled it would take them.
“Ukraine has made no concessions with regard to its territorial integrity,” Mr. Poroshenko told the cabinet. “There is no question of federalization or separation of any Ukrainian territory.”“Ukraine has made no concessions with regard to its territorial integrity,” Mr. Poroshenko told the cabinet. “There is no question of federalization or separation of any Ukrainian territory.”
The president said that 700 Ukrainian prisoners had been released, with another 500 in custody. Most of those would appear to be soldiers, because a government spokesman said Wednesday that only 20 soldiers had been released so far.The president said that 700 Ukrainian prisoners had been released, with another 500 in custody. Most of those would appear to be soldiers, because a government spokesman said Wednesday that only 20 soldiers had been released so far.
Mr. Poroshenko gave no specifics about the bill on special status for the areas held by the rebels. The agreement reached in Minsk last Friday calls for Ukraine to move toward “decentralization,” first by adopting a temporary law that gives special status to certain districts of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions.Mr. Poroshenko gave no specifics about the bill on special status for the areas held by the rebels. The agreement reached in Minsk last Friday calls for Ukraine to move toward “decentralization,” first by adopting a temporary law that gives special status to certain districts of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions.
Officials and analysts noted that important questions remain about that provision. Officials at the Foreign Ministry in Kiev declined to comment on Ukraine’s negotiating position.Officials and analysts noted that important questions remain about that provision. Officials at the Foreign Ministry in Kiev declined to comment on Ukraine’s negotiating position.
But a political adviser to Mr. Poroshenko said that each of the 12 points in the cease-fire protocol needed to be negotiated in detail, with the government focused first on silencing the guns and obtaining the release of hundreds of prisoners.But a political adviser to Mr. Poroshenko said that each of the 12 points in the cease-fire protocol needed to be negotiated in detail, with the government focused first on silencing the guns and obtaining the release of hundreds of prisoners.
“Nobody knows what special status means,” said the adviser, speaking on the condition of anonymity because he was not directly involved in the talks. He said Ukraine rejected the idea of federalization, particularly since the area held by the rebels only represented about one-third of the territory of two provinces. “Nobody knows what special status means,” said the adviser, speaking on the condition of anonymity because he was not directly involved in the talks. He said Ukraine rejected the idea of federalization, particularly since the area held by the rebels represented only about one-third of the territory of the two regions.
Russia has been pushing since March for federalization, seen as a means to give the regions sufficient autonomy so that they could veto any national legislation that might move Ukraine closer to the West, particularly joining NATO. Regardless of whether Russia accomplishes that goal, there has been concern that Mr. Putin might try to create a frozen conflict in the area, leaving Ukraine permanently destabilized.Russia has been pushing since March for federalization, seen as a means to give the regions sufficient autonomy so that they could veto any national legislation that might move Ukraine closer to the West, particularly joining NATO. Regardless of whether Russia accomplishes that goal, there has been concern that Mr. Putin might try to create a frozen conflict in the area, leaving Ukraine permanently destabilized.
Ukraine believes that since Russia is one of the signatories to the agreement, and since the protocol does not mention federalization or either the self-proclaimed people’s republics in Donetsk or Luhansk, that means Moscow is not seeking a broad interpretation of autonomy. Mr. Putin has steadily maintained that Russia is not a party to the conflict. Ukraine believes that since Russia is one of the signatories to the agreement, and since the protocol does not mention federalization or either of the self-proclaimed people’s republics in Donetsk or Luhansk, Moscow is not seeking a broad interpretation of autonomy. Mr. Putin has steadily maintained that Russia is not a party to the conflict.
District parliaments would run local budgets and select their governor, but they would not have veto power over national legislation, the adviser said. It is unclear whether Russia accepts that as sufficient. The law is still in draft form and temporary, and Kiev has not said what powers it would grant the regions.District parliaments would run local budgets and select their governor, but they would not have veto power over national legislation, the adviser said. It is unclear whether Russia accepts that as sufficient. The law is still in draft form and temporary, and Kiev has not said what powers it would grant the regions.
“The real issue is whether they will allow veto power on various institutional decisions,” said Adrian Karatnycky, a Ukrainian expert at the Atlantic Council.“The real issue is whether they will allow veto power on various institutional decisions,” said Adrian Karatnycky, a Ukrainian expert at the Atlantic Council.
At the moment, however, with peace prospects uncertain, the European Union was considering a timetable for further sanctions against Russia’s energy and banking sectors in an attempt to compel Moscow to support the cease-fire.
Angela Merkel, the German chancellor, told the parliament in Berlin on Wednesday that the new sanctions should be implemented immediately because the cease-fire protocol had not been fully implemented, even if the situation had improved.
Ms. Merkel’s assessment did not differ markedly from that of Ukraine or the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, but she chose to emphasize the “lack of clarity” in fulfilling numerous points of the plan.
Ambassadors from the European Union’s 28 member states were due to convene in Brussels later Wednesday to discuss the question of additional sanctions.
In Prague, the chairman of the O.S.C.E., which helped negotiate the cease-fire and is in charge of monitoring it, said the truce should be given more time before new sanctions were imposed.
Didier Burkhalter, the president of Switzerland and the O.S.C.E. chairman, also said the organization would shortly start using drones to monitor the truce.
In Moscow, the defense minister, Sergei Shoigu, repeated Russia’s claim that Ukraine was responsible for the downing of a Malaysian civilian airplane over the war zone last July because it started the conflict.
“The catastrophe took place in air space belonging to Ukraine, which bears full responsibility for what happened,” he was quoted as saying Wednesday by Interfax news agency.
The Dutch Safety Board said in a preliminary report released Tuesday that Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 by a shower of “high-energy objects from outside the aircraft.”