This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29185604
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Rival US senators Flake and Heinrich film survival show | Rival US senators Flake and Heinrich film survival show |
(2 days later) | |
Two US senators from rival political parties are taking bipartisan co-operation to a new level, starring in a reality survival show filmed on a desert island. Will this shrewd media manoeuvre spur a gridlocked Congress to stop bickering and start taking action? | Two US senators from rival political parties are taking bipartisan co-operation to a new level, starring in a reality survival show filmed on a desert island. Will this shrewd media manoeuvre spur a gridlocked Congress to stop bickering and start taking action? |
Rival Survival - premiering in the US on 29 October - will show Republican Senator Jeff Flake of Arizona and Democratic Senator Martin Heinrich of New Mexico enduring six days and nights together on Eru in the Marshall Islands. | Rival Survival - premiering in the US on 29 October - will show Republican Senator Jeff Flake of Arizona and Democratic Senator Martin Heinrich of New Mexico enduring six days and nights together on Eru in the Marshall Islands. |
Used to navigating the metaphorical shark-infested waters of Washington DC politics, the two men will encounter real life predators as they work together to stave off hunger and thirst. | Used to navigating the metaphorical shark-infested waters of Washington DC politics, the two men will encounter real life predators as they work together to stave off hunger and thirst. |
As Congress' overall approval ratings sink to all-time lows ahead of the November mid-term elections, Matthew Baum, professor of global communications and public policy at Harvard University's John F Kennedy School of Government, says this type of spectacle was inevitable. | As Congress' overall approval ratings sink to all-time lows ahead of the November mid-term elections, Matthew Baum, professor of global communications and public policy at Harvard University's John F Kennedy School of Government, says this type of spectacle was inevitable. |
He says it is an effort to reach and attract a shrinking pool of "persuadables", or people who do not have a strong connection to either party. | He says it is an effort to reach and attract a shrinking pool of "persuadables", or people who do not have a strong connection to either party. |
But political polarisation and media fragmentation have made that increasingly difficult. | But political polarisation and media fragmentation have made that increasingly difficult. |
"There is a tacit understanding that people have to do more extreme things to get attention and to move voters," he says. | "There is a tacit understanding that people have to do more extreme things to get attention and to move voters," he says. |
A reality shows draw a lot of less partisan and politically engaged - thus potentially movable - voters, Baum adds. | A reality shows draw a lot of less partisan and politically engaged - thus potentially movable - voters, Baum adds. |
The idea of pushing media boundaries is not new, Baum says, noting former US President Bill Clinton's surprising election-era appearance playing the saxophone on the late-night Arsenio Hall Show in 1992. | The idea of pushing media boundaries is not new, Baum says, noting former US President Bill Clinton's surprising election-era appearance playing the saxophone on the late-night Arsenio Hall Show in 1992. |
"[People] went ballistic about how this was demeaning the presidency and was going to cost him the nomination," he says. "And they, frankly, had it backwards." | "[People] went ballistic about how this was demeaning the presidency and was going to cost him the nomination," he says. "And they, frankly, had it backwards." |
Republican strategist Ford O'Connell says President Barack Obama has shrewdly adopted this type of outside-the-box media approach, appearing on daytime and late-night talk shows and discussing many things other than politics. | Republican strategist Ford O'Connell says President Barack Obama has shrewdly adopted this type of outside-the-box media approach, appearing on daytime and late-night talk shows and discussing many things other than politics. |
"These days we live in an HBO, TMZ, ESPN society," he says of the entertainment television channel, a celebrity gossip website and a top sport media brand. "Politicians need to get outside of the political media echo chamber. You've got to go where the eyeballs are." | "These days we live in an HBO, TMZ, ESPN society," he says of the entertainment television channel, a celebrity gossip website and a top sport media brand. "Politicians need to get outside of the political media echo chamber. You've got to go where the eyeballs are." |
The Discovery Channel has plenty of eyeballs. Their survival shows - such as Naked and Afraid, where nude contestants battle the elements - draw big audiences. | The Discovery Channel has plenty of eyeballs. Their survival shows - such as Naked and Afraid, where nude contestants battle the elements - draw big audiences. |
Flake and Heinrich approached the network with the unusual concept several months ago, hoping to highlight cross-party co-operation. | Flake and Heinrich approached the network with the unusual concept several months ago, hoping to highlight cross-party co-operation. |
Network spokeswoman Laurie Goldberg says she was thrilled at the prospect. She is careful to point out that the senators performed all tasks related to the show in their off-work hours, in accordance with strict Senate ethics rules. | Network spokeswoman Laurie Goldberg says she was thrilled at the prospect. She is careful to point out that the senators performed all tasks related to the show in their off-work hours, in accordance with strict Senate ethics rules. |
They filmed the programme in August over their Congressional recess, and donated all compensation to charity. | They filmed the programme in August over their Congressional recess, and donated all compensation to charity. |
What was important to both the politicians and the network, she adds, was airing the show prior to Congressional mid-term elections on 4 November. | What was important to both the politicians and the network, she adds, was airing the show prior to Congressional mid-term elections on 4 November. |
Neither of the politicians is up for re-election then, but control of the US Senate and House of Representatives will be up for grabs. | Neither of the politicians is up for re-election then, but control of the US Senate and House of Representatives will be up for grabs. |
"We wanted to make sure it was out before, and maybe we'll make a point so when the new guys come in, they'll think about it," Goldberg says. | "We wanted to make sure it was out before, and maybe we'll make a point so when the new guys come in, they'll think about it," Goldberg says. |
But how can watching two grown men spear fishing together help what many consider to be a hopelessly gridlocked Congress? | But how can watching two grown men spear fishing together help what many consider to be a hopelessly gridlocked Congress? |
"Right now, in a lot of ways, America is soured on both parties," O'Connell says. "The idea of being able to show them [working] together toward a common goal is a good thing overall." | "Right now, in a lot of ways, America is soured on both parties," O'Connell says. "The idea of being able to show them [working] together toward a common goal is a good thing overall." |
It can also increase the pressure to co-operate, he says, and encourage more "team building exercises" across the political spectrum. | It can also increase the pressure to co-operate, he says, and encourage more "team building exercises" across the political spectrum. |
O'Connell also contends that, barring any major gaffes, the move can offer positive brand recognition for both parties. | |
"Talking about anything other than politics is generally a plus," he says. "The fact is, if you can survive... the Pacific Islands, then you can pretty much survive anything." | "Talking about anything other than politics is generally a plus," he says. "The fact is, if you can survive... the Pacific Islands, then you can pretty much survive anything." |
But what of Flake and Heinrich's credibility with their more staid Congressional cohorts? | But what of Flake and Heinrich's credibility with their more staid Congressional cohorts? |
"These guys' reputations with their colleagues are going to turn on what they do in the Senate, not what they do in their private lives," Baum says. "This isn't a scandal, it's just kowtowing to cotemporary media mores." | "These guys' reputations with their colleagues are going to turn on what they do in the Senate, not what they do in their private lives," Baum says. "This isn't a scandal, it's just kowtowing to cotemporary media mores." |
Previous version
1
Next version