This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/sep/29/soviet-ussr-monuments-should-be-protected
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Why Soviet monuments should be protected | Why Soviet monuments should be protected |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| Few reminders of Soviet rule are quite as powerful as the towering statues of Vladimir Lenin that, even now, keep watch over the region. | Few reminders of Soviet rule are quite as powerful as the towering statues of Vladimir Lenin that, even now, keep watch over the region. |
| And with fears that Russia is once again in the mood for expansion, it’s no surprise that these monuments to the Soviet legacy are under attack. | And with fears that Russia is once again in the mood for expansion, it’s no surprise that these monuments to the Soviet legacy are under attack. |
| Crowds cheered as Ukrainian nationalists tore down a statue of Lenin in the centre of Ukraine’s second-largest city, Kharkiv, yesterday – with the support of local officials. | Crowds cheered as Ukrainian nationalists tore down a statue of Lenin in the centre of Ukraine’s second-largest city, Kharkiv, yesterday – with the support of local officials. |
| In Ukraine, more than 100 Lenin statues are said to have been dismantled since the overthrow of the government last December. Even in Moscow, the Ukrainian colours were recently painted over a Soviet star on skyscrapers known as Stalin’s towers. | In Ukraine, more than 100 Lenin statues are said to have been dismantled since the overthrow of the government last December. Even in Moscow, the Ukrainian colours were recently painted over a Soviet star on skyscrapers known as Stalin’s towers. |
| These acts show that memories of Soviet aggression are just as raw today as they were when the USSR fell. But is this anger misplaced? | These acts show that memories of Soviet aggression are just as raw today as they were when the USSR fell. But is this anger misplaced? |
| Symbols of power | Symbols of power |
| During the Soviet era, successive leaderships intent on leaving their mark went about building thousands of monuments to their power. With the dissolution of the USSR in 1991, the Russian government made the preservation of Red Army monuments one of the conditions of the troops’ withdrawal from the newly independent countries. | During the Soviet era, successive leaderships intent on leaving their mark went about building thousands of monuments to their power. With the dissolution of the USSR in 1991, the Russian government made the preservation of Red Army monuments one of the conditions of the troops’ withdrawal from the newly independent countries. |
| In Warsaw, for example, despite calls for all remnants of Soviet times to be demolished, a large Red Army memorial is protected and was even recently renovated. A cemetery for Soviet soldiers is part of that memorial, and to attack it would be to desecrate a grave. | In Warsaw, for example, despite calls for all remnants of Soviet times to be demolished, a large Red Army memorial is protected and was even recently renovated. A cemetery for Soviet soldiers is part of that memorial, and to attack it would be to desecrate a grave. |
| However, the different countries that emerged from Soviet rule have dealt with this legacy in very different ways. | However, the different countries that emerged from Soviet rule have dealt with this legacy in very different ways. |
| In those countries that have nurtured close ties with Moscow, Soviet monuments claim pride of place in city centres and manicured parks. In those that chose to move towards the west, however, most that could be destroyed were pulled down. Only a few survive as dubious tourist attractions, placed within special zones or theme parks, such as Gruto Parkas in Lithuania or Szoborpark in Budapest. | In those countries that have nurtured close ties with Moscow, Soviet monuments claim pride of place in city centres and manicured parks. In those that chose to move towards the west, however, most that could be destroyed were pulled down. Only a few survive as dubious tourist attractions, placed within special zones or theme parks, such as Gruto Parkas in Lithuania or Szoborpark in Budapest. |
| Their artistic value varies. Yet their characteristically heavy, socialist-realist style, does not fit well in some post-communist cities, where they are seen to detract from a desirable modern image. | Their artistic value varies. Yet their characteristically heavy, socialist-realist style, does not fit well in some post-communist cities, where they are seen to detract from a desirable modern image. |
| In Bulgaria, the Soviet memorial in central Sofia is regularly painted/defaced (depending on your view). Once the soldiers on the monument were painted to resemble American comic books superheroes; last year they were painted pink. | In Bulgaria, the Soviet memorial in central Sofia is regularly painted/defaced (depending on your view). Once the soldiers on the monument were painted to resemble American comic books superheroes; last year they were painted pink. |
| It did not amuse Russian authorities, who issued a request that the monument was no longer defaced this way. And I’d argue that in this case, they’re right. | It did not amuse Russian authorities, who issued a request that the monument was no longer defaced this way. And I’d argue that in this case, they’re right. |
| Sacrifice | Sacrifice |
| Red Army monuments are a reminder of the astounding Soviet sacrifice during the war. You find them not only in the ex-communist bloc but in western Europe too – Berlin and Vienna being most prominent. Those two cities even feature quotations from Stalin, which they remain in place without harassment. The degree of the Soviet sacrifice seems to be appreciated there. | Red Army monuments are a reminder of the astounding Soviet sacrifice during the war. You find them not only in the ex-communist bloc but in western Europe too – Berlin and Vienna being most prominent. Those two cities even feature quotations from Stalin, which they remain in place without harassment. The degree of the Soviet sacrifice seems to be appreciated there. |
| The Soviet army played a major role in saving this part of Europe from the realisation of Hitler’s master plan in the east, which proposed the colonisation, enslavement and eventual extermination of the Slavic population. | The Soviet army played a major role in saving this part of Europe from the realisation of Hitler’s master plan in the east, which proposed the colonisation, enslavement and eventual extermination of the Slavic population. |
| The Lenin statues have been a poor substitute for understandable anger | The Lenin statues have been a poor substitute for understandable anger |
| Up to 25 million Soviet civilians and soldiers were killed during the second world war. Much of this happened in Russia itself during horrific episodes such as the battle of Stalingrad and the siege of Leningrad, when women and children starved to death and as many as two million were killed. | Up to 25 million Soviet civilians and soldiers were killed during the second world war. Much of this happened in Russia itself during horrific episodes such as the battle of Stalingrad and the siege of Leningrad, when women and children starved to death and as many as two million were killed. |
| In some areas of the former USSR that are keen to shrug off Moscow’s influence, Russia’s role in the second world war is seen largely through the initial collaboration with Hitler. But it is the Soviet Union’s later actions and subsequent role in the defeat of the Nazis in Europe that should be dominant. | In some areas of the former USSR that are keen to shrug off Moscow’s influence, Russia’s role in the second world war is seen largely through the initial collaboration with Hitler. But it is the Soviet Union’s later actions and subsequent role in the defeat of the Nazis in Europe that should be dominant. |
| The countries that suffered the greatest loss of life during the war were Russia, Belarus, Ukraine and Poland. In Belarus, a quarter of the population was killed, and though unspeakable suffering took place across the region it happened with special cruelty there. | The countries that suffered the greatest loss of life during the war were Russia, Belarus, Ukraine and Poland. In Belarus, a quarter of the population was killed, and though unspeakable suffering took place across the region it happened with special cruelty there. |
| Political statements | Political statements |
| Of course not all Soviet monuments are the same. Desecrating a statue of a Red Army soldier is different to toppling a Lenin memorial or painting the Ukrainian flag on the spire of one of Moscow’s Stalin towers. The latter can and should be separated from the events of 70 years ago. The people who died in Stalingrad shouldn’t get mixed up with people sending arms to Donetsk separatists. To see it otherwise is to fall into the irresponsible, habitual comparisons of Putin with Stalin and Hitler, conflating things from very different historical orders. | Of course not all Soviet monuments are the same. Desecrating a statue of a Red Army soldier is different to toppling a Lenin memorial or painting the Ukrainian flag on the spire of one of Moscow’s Stalin towers. The latter can and should be separated from the events of 70 years ago. The people who died in Stalingrad shouldn’t get mixed up with people sending arms to Donetsk separatists. To see it otherwise is to fall into the irresponsible, habitual comparisons of Putin with Stalin and Hitler, conflating things from very different historical orders. |
| Somehow hatred for former Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych became confused with hatred of Lenin, which is strange because Yanukovych’s ally Vladimir Putin has criticised the Soviet leader for including Odessa, Donbass and Kharkiv (so-called Novorossiya) in the Ukrainian borders drawn in early 1920s. During political turmoil, details get lost. In some instances, the unwanted Soviet legacy has been replaced by new monuments to controversial western Ukrainian nationalists, such as Stepan Bandera. | Somehow hatred for former Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych became confused with hatred of Lenin, which is strange because Yanukovych’s ally Vladimir Putin has criticised the Soviet leader for including Odessa, Donbass and Kharkiv (so-called Novorossiya) in the Ukrainian borders drawn in early 1920s. During political turmoil, details get lost. In some instances, the unwanted Soviet legacy has been replaced by new monuments to controversial western Ukrainian nationalists, such as Stepan Bandera. |
| It was just the same in Tallinn, the Estonian capital, in 2007 when riots between the country’s Estonian and Russian speakers were sparked by the removal of a memorial to a Red Army Soldier in the city centre. | It was just the same in Tallinn, the Estonian capital, in 2007 when riots between the country’s Estonian and Russian speakers were sparked by the removal of a memorial to a Red Army Soldier in the city centre. |
| Large Russian populations remain in some countries of the former USSR that want to escape these “Russian” symbols. These Russian minorities face hostility, and often lack basic civil rights, as if they have to pay for the communist past. The conflict in Ukraine that built a false distinction between “Ukrainians” and “Russians” was rehearsed in those countries, where controversies over historical symbols serve present political aims to divide and rule local populations. | |
| Past and present | Past and present |
| Ultimately, the past informs our present. In some ways the Soviet legacy and the emotions it provokes explain part of the current conflict in Ukraine but so too do many other factors in recent history – the corruption and chaos of the capitalist transition is just one example. | Ultimately, the past informs our present. In some ways the Soviet legacy and the emotions it provokes explain part of the current conflict in Ukraine but so too do many other factors in recent history – the corruption and chaos of the capitalist transition is just one example. |
| The destruction of Yanukovych’s Disneyland-like villa outside Kiev at least aimed at the right target, the unequal economy. The Lenin statues have been a poor substitute for understandable anger. | The destruction of Yanukovych’s Disneyland-like villa outside Kiev at least aimed at the right target, the unequal economy. The Lenin statues have been a poor substitute for understandable anger. |
| In some parts of the former USSR the Soviet legacy is used to explain all ills while in others it is the source of fond nostalgia for better days. In conflating the past and present, we run the risk of re-enacting old battles, not properly assessing what our problems are today. | In some parts of the former USSR the Soviet legacy is used to explain all ills while in others it is the source of fond nostalgia for better days. In conflating the past and present, we run the risk of re-enacting old battles, not properly assessing what our problems are today. |