This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/oct/06/syria-refugees-syria-civil-war-guide
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| 3m refugees have fled Syria's civil war – why is the US accepting so few of them? | 3m refugees have fled Syria's civil war – why is the US accepting so few of them? |
| (about 17 hours later) | |
| Since the start of the war in Syria in early 2011, the number of people fleeing the country has swelled to more than 3 million – half of them children. The US has accepted only a staggering few – just 36 in 2013. | Since the start of the war in Syria in early 2011, the number of people fleeing the country has swelled to more than 3 million – half of them children. The US has accepted only a staggering few – just 36 in 2013. |
| Though the US has recently pledged to accept thousands more over the next few years, the resettlement process is complex and protracted. In some cases, refugees are left waiting in camps for up to three years before they are cleared to board a plane to America. This is in part due to sweeping US counter-terrorism laws that have, until recently, been ensnaring Syrians who pose no threat. | |
| With no end in sight to the country’s brutal war, which has claimed upwards of 190,000 lives, according to the UN’s latest figures, refugee advocacy groups are calling on the US to fast-track the process for Syria’s most vulnerable and absorb a greater number of its refugees. Since the US-led coalition against Isis began conducting air strikes within Syria two weeks ago, likely pushing more refugees across borders, there is a heightened sense of urgency. | With no end in sight to the country’s brutal war, which has claimed upwards of 190,000 lives, according to the UN’s latest figures, refugee advocacy groups are calling on the US to fast-track the process for Syria’s most vulnerable and absorb a greater number of its refugees. Since the US-led coalition against Isis began conducting air strikes within Syria two weeks ago, likely pushing more refugees across borders, there is a heightened sense of urgency. |
| Less than a year ago, the number of registered Syrian refugees stood at just 2 million, spread across Syria’s neighbouring countries. The UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR) recently pointed to “increasingly horrifying conditions inside the country”, which likely included atrocities committed by the Assad regime and extremist militant groups like Isis, to explain the explosion in the number of refugees over the past year. | Less than a year ago, the number of registered Syrian refugees stood at just 2 million, spread across Syria’s neighbouring countries. The UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR) recently pointed to “increasingly horrifying conditions inside the country”, which likely included atrocities committed by the Assad regime and extremist militant groups like Isis, to explain the explosion in the number of refugees over the past year. |
| The majority of displaced Syrians have crossed into Lebanon, Jordan and Turkey, with close to 1.2 million of those in Lebanon alone – though aid agencies concede the number could be much higher owing to unregistered refugees who have settled in makeshift communities. | The majority of displaced Syrians have crossed into Lebanon, Jordan and Turkey, with close to 1.2 million of those in Lebanon alone – though aid agencies concede the number could be much higher owing to unregistered refugees who have settled in makeshift communities. |
| Additionally, the war has also displaced 6.5 million people within Syria, meaning that roughly 50% of all Syrians have been forced to flee their homes. | Additionally, the war has also displaced 6.5 million people within Syria, meaning that roughly 50% of all Syrians have been forced to flee their homes. |
| “The key challenge in the Middle East is the fast-moving situation and high numbers of refugees and internally displaced people involved. In the past week in Turkey for example, we had another 160,000 refugees flee and need urgent life-saving aid,” said Ariane Rummery, a spokeswoman for the UNHCR’s Middle East and North Africa division. | “The key challenge in the Middle East is the fast-moving situation and high numbers of refugees and internally displaced people involved. In the past week in Turkey for example, we had another 160,000 refugees flee and need urgent life-saving aid,” said Ariane Rummery, a spokeswoman for the UNHCR’s Middle East and North Africa division. |
| Resettlement: not a top priority | Resettlement: not a top priority |
| The US – which traditionally accepts more refugees than any other country– has resettled 191 Syrian refugees since March 2011, although the vast majority of these applied for resettlement before the conflict broke out, a State Department spokesperson said in an email. | The US – which traditionally accepts more refugees than any other country– has resettled 191 Syrian refugees since March 2011, although the vast majority of these applied for resettlement before the conflict broke out, a State Department spokesperson said in an email. |
| The UN has repeatedly called on world leaders to resettle Syria’s displaced, and relieve the heavy burden placed on its neighbours. The international community has pledged to resettle more than 33,000 displaced Syrians by the end of 2014, with the UNHCR setting a new target of 130,000 by the end of 2016. | The UN has repeatedly called on world leaders to resettle Syria’s displaced, and relieve the heavy burden placed on its neighbours. The international community has pledged to resettle more than 33,000 displaced Syrians by the end of 2014, with the UNHCR setting a new target of 130,000 by the end of 2016. |
| The US, however, does not view resettlement as its top priority. | The US, however, does not view resettlement as its top priority. |
| “Our primary goal is to provide humanitarian assistance and protection to refugees in the places to which they have fled,” a State Department representative said. The US has so far donated more than $2.9bn in humanitarian aid funds, making it the largest single donor. | “Our primary goal is to provide humanitarian assistance and protection to refugees in the places to which they have fled,” a State Department representative said. The US has so far donated more than $2.9bn in humanitarian aid funds, making it the largest single donor. |
| Shannon Scribner, humanitarian policy manager at Oxfam America, said the US needs to increase its response to the growing refugee crisis. | Shannon Scribner, humanitarian policy manager at Oxfam America, said the US needs to increase its response to the growing refugee crisis. |
| “The recent military intervention does put an onus on the US to think about and strategise a plan for the impact that [the air strikes] may have on the region and the refugees it creates,” Scribner said. | “The recent military intervention does put an onus on the US to think about and strategise a plan for the impact that [the air strikes] may have on the region and the refugees it creates,” Scribner said. |
| The slow journey to America | The slow journey to America |
| The reason the US has taken only a tiny number of refugees to date is more procedural than political, said Anna Greene, the policy and advocacy director for US programmes at the International Rescue Committee (IRC). | The reason the US has taken only a tiny number of refugees to date is more procedural than political, said Anna Greene, the policy and advocacy director for US programmes at the International Rescue Committee (IRC). |
| “It’s not a question of the US refusing to take cases,” she said. “This was a structural reality.” | “It’s not a question of the US refusing to take cases,” she said. “This was a structural reality.” |
| Greene said the UN prioritised sending refugees to other countries, especially European ones like Germany, because they had already made specific pledges. | Greene said the UN prioritised sending refugees to other countries, especially European ones like Germany, because they had already made specific pledges. |
| Though the US has still not committed to taking a certain number of refugees, a State Department representative said the US expects to resettle “many thousands more in 2015 and 2016”. Given that the US resettlement process can take an average of 12 months to complete, Greene said she would “expect to see those cases coming to the US next summer and fall”. | Though the US has still not committed to taking a certain number of refugees, a State Department representative said the US expects to resettle “many thousands more in 2015 and 2016”. Given that the US resettlement process can take an average of 12 months to complete, Greene said she would “expect to see those cases coming to the US next summer and fall”. |
| The US formally set up a resettlement programme for refugees fleeing the Syrian conflict last fall. A refugee’s resettlement process to the US typically begins with a referral from the UNHCR. The refugees then undergo extensive background checks and are interviewed abroad by a Department of Homeland Security field officer. | The US formally set up a resettlement programme for refugees fleeing the Syrian conflict last fall. A refugee’s resettlement process to the US typically begins with a referral from the UNHCR. The refugees then undergo extensive background checks and are interviewed abroad by a Department of Homeland Security field officer. |
| When a person or family is finally deemed admissible, they will complete a final security and medical check and cultural orientation training before boarding the plane to America. The entire process generally takes 12 months, but it can last up to three years. | When a person or family is finally deemed admissible, they will complete a final security and medical check and cultural orientation training before boarding the plane to America. The entire process generally takes 12 months, but it can last up to three years. |
| “It should be noted in the case of the US and in other countries, refugees also pay for some of their resettlement costs – such as airplane tickets,” said Larry Yungk, the senior resettlement officer at UNHCR Washington. “In the US, refugees pay for these costs through a loan system,” which can be an added complication for some. | “It should be noted in the case of the US and in other countries, refugees also pay for some of their resettlement costs – such as airplane tickets,” said Larry Yungk, the senior resettlement officer at UNHCR Washington. “In the US, refugees pay for these costs through a loan system,” which can be an added complication for some. |
| But when refugees are relocated to the US, it’s for good. The resettlement programme is designed to set refugees on a path to citizenship. Upon arrival, refugees are initially cared for by one of the more than a dozen NGOs, which will help them find housing, work and schools for their children. | But when refugees are relocated to the US, it’s for good. The resettlement programme is designed to set refugees on a path to citizenship. Upon arrival, refugees are initially cared for by one of the more than a dozen NGOs, which will help them find housing, work and schools for their children. |
| Material support: a barrier to admission? | Material support: a barrier to admission? |
| Many Syrians fleeing violence in their native country will qualify for refugee status based on the US definition, which requires a “fear of persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group or political opinion.” | Many Syrians fleeing violence in their native country will qualify for refugee status based on the US definition, which requires a “fear of persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group or political opinion.” |
| But US counter-terrorism laws, beefed up in the wake of 9/11, can be a real barrier to admission. | But US counter-terrorism laws, beefed up in the wake of 9/11, can be a real barrier to admission. |
| Until recently, Syrians who provided “material support” to groups the US identified as terror organisations could be barred from refugee status, even if they did not actually pose any threat to the US. Human Rights First gives as one hypothetical example the owner of a food stand in a neighbourhood under opposition control who sold falafel sandwiches to fighters. | Until recently, Syrians who provided “material support” to groups the US identified as terror organisations could be barred from refugee status, even if they did not actually pose any threat to the US. Human Rights First gives as one hypothetical example the owner of a food stand in a neighbourhood under opposition control who sold falafel sandwiches to fighters. |
| In February, however, the US loosened the entry requirements so that refugees who provided “insignificant material support” to armed groups would not be categorically denied entry. The policy change was directed specifically at refugees who interacted with Syria’s rebel forces, some of which the US has pledged to train and support. | In February, however, the US loosened the entry requirements so that refugees who provided “insignificant material support” to armed groups would not be categorically denied entry. The policy change was directed specifically at refugees who interacted with Syria’s rebel forces, some of which the US has pledged to train and support. |
| Greene of the IRC said this was a critical change, because in the context of Syria’s war, the material support policy unduly punished refugees. She said there is not enough evidence yet to know how the rules will be applied. | Greene of the IRC said this was a critical change, because in the context of Syria’s war, the material support policy unduly punished refugees. She said there is not enough evidence yet to know how the rules will be applied. |
| Choosing among ‘the vulnerable of the vulnerable’ | Choosing among ‘the vulnerable of the vulnerable’ |
| The US places a strict, but not immoveable, ceiling on the number of refugees it admits annually. The president, in consultation with Congress, sets a global limit, which is then broken down by region. For 2015, the US will accept 70,000 refugees from across the globe; 33,000 of those spots are reserved for refugees from the Near East and south Asia. The US will not create a separate refugee programme for Syrians, as it did for Iraqi refugees. | The US places a strict, but not immoveable, ceiling on the number of refugees it admits annually. The president, in consultation with Congress, sets a global limit, which is then broken down by region. For 2015, the US will accept 70,000 refugees from across the globe; 33,000 of those spots are reserved for refugees from the Near East and south Asia. The US will not create a separate refugee programme for Syrians, as it did for Iraqi refugees. |
| Michael Kagan, an expert in international refugee law at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, said there are serious ethical concerns, not to mention administrative hurdles, to consider when deciding which of the refugees to accept. | Michael Kagan, an expert in international refugee law at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, said there are serious ethical concerns, not to mention administrative hurdles, to consider when deciding which of the refugees to accept. |
| “These programmes are often looking for the vulnerable of the vulnerable,” Kagan said, a category that can include unaccompanied children, medical cases, at-risk women, and victims of torture. | “These programmes are often looking for the vulnerable of the vulnerable,” Kagan said, a category that can include unaccompanied children, medical cases, at-risk women, and victims of torture. |
| Kagan said it will take an “incredible” administrative apparatus to screen every refugee, and even then, there will be ethical concerns about how the decisions are made. | Kagan said it will take an “incredible” administrative apparatus to screen every refugee, and even then, there will be ethical concerns about how the decisions are made. |
| However, “given the large needs in the Syrian refugee population and the relatively small number of resettlement places available globally – not every refugee who falls into these vulnerable categories can be resettled,” Yungk said. | However, “given the large needs in the Syrian refugee population and the relatively small number of resettlement places available globally – not every refugee who falls into these vulnerable categories can be resettled,” Yungk said. |
| Since the US hasn’t pledged a specific number, aid groups have made varying requests. Refugee Council USA (RCUSA), a key umbrella group, recommended the US resettle 65,000 Syrian refugees over the next three years. The council said the number is based on the expectation that the US honors its “tradition of accepting at least half of all UNHCR referrals for any given population”. | Since the US hasn’t pledged a specific number, aid groups have made varying requests. Refugee Council USA (RCUSA), a key umbrella group, recommended the US resettle 65,000 Syrian refugees over the next three years. The council said the number is based on the expectation that the US honors its “tradition of accepting at least half of all UNHCR referrals for any given population”. |
| However, Greene said at this point the US is only accepting Syrians as part of the global ceiling; she is not aware of a dedicated programme that would accept Syrian refugees outside the limit. | However, Greene said at this point the US is only accepting Syrians as part of the global ceiling; she is not aware of a dedicated programme that would accept Syrian refugees outside the limit. |
| Furthermore, Kagan cautioned against establishing a special programme for Syrians, in part because it sends the message that one refugee’s case is more compelling than another’s. | Furthermore, Kagan cautioned against establishing a special programme for Syrians, in part because it sends the message that one refugee’s case is more compelling than another’s. |
| “There are always other refugee crises around the world that are not on the front pages,” he said. “If a programme were developed where all of the energy and all of the refugee resettlement places went to refugees from a single country, it might not really be an equitable programme and it might abandon other people who have equally compelling situations.” | “There are always other refugee crises around the world that are not on the front pages,” he said. “If a programme were developed where all of the energy and all of the refugee resettlement places went to refugees from a single country, it might not really be an equitable programme and it might abandon other people who have equally compelling situations.” |
| With each day the war drags on, more refugees are being created, exacerbating what is already the largest global refugee crisis since the second world war. The UN estimates that the number could rise to more than 4 million by the end of this year. | With each day the war drags on, more refugees are being created, exacerbating what is already the largest global refugee crisis since the second world war. The UN estimates that the number could rise to more than 4 million by the end of this year. |
| “Historically, the world does a terrible job of resolving refugee crises,” Kagan said. | “Historically, the world does a terrible job of resolving refugee crises,” Kagan said. |
| “What’s scary when you look at the Syrians is that it’s certainly possible that many of these millions of refugees could still be in limbo years or decades from now.” | “What’s scary when you look at the Syrians is that it’s certainly possible that many of these millions of refugees could still be in limbo years or decades from now.” |