This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-29821698

The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 7 Version 8
Drugs policy: End 'robotic rhetoric' says minister Drugs policy: End 'robotic rhetoric' says minister
(35 minutes later)
The "genie is out of the bottle" on drugs policy, MPs were told as they backed calls for a review of 40-year-old laws.The "genie is out of the bottle" on drugs policy, MPs were told as they backed calls for a review of 40-year-old laws.
Lib Dem Home Office Minister Norman Baker said politicians were out of step with public opinion and called for an end to "robotic mindless rhetoric".Lib Dem Home Office Minister Norman Baker said politicians were out of step with public opinion and called for an end to "robotic mindless rhetoric".
Backbench Conservatives also expressed doubts about current policy but Downing Street said there would be no change.Backbench Conservatives also expressed doubts about current policy but Downing Street said there would be no change.
A report found no obvious link between tough laws and levels of drug use.A report found no obvious link between tough laws and levels of drug use.
The findings of the Home Office report, commissioned by the Liberal Democrats to compare drugs policies in different countries, prompted a row at the top of the coalition.The findings of the Home Office report, commissioned by the Liberal Democrats to compare drugs policies in different countries, prompted a row at the top of the coalition.
Lib Dem deputy prime minister Nick Clegg accused his Conservative colleagues of trying to block the report, and of a "totally misplaced, outdated, backward-looking view".Lib Dem deputy prime minister Nick Clegg accused his Conservative colleagues of trying to block the report, and of a "totally misplaced, outdated, backward-looking view".
'Scourge of drugs''Scourge of drugs'
Downing Street in turn accused Mr Clegg of sending "an incredibly dangerous message" and said that drug use in the UK was "plummeting" because of existing policy.Downing Street in turn accused Mr Clegg of sending "an incredibly dangerous message" and said that drug use in the UK was "plummeting" because of existing policy.
But during the Commons debate brought by Green MP Caroline Lucas, Conservative MPs Robert Syms, Bob Stewart and Zac Goldsmith expressed unease with the current approach.But during the Commons debate brought by Green MP Caroline Lucas, Conservative MPs Robert Syms, Bob Stewart and Zac Goldsmith expressed unease with the current approach.
Mr Syms said: "Contrary to press reports, there are many of us on these benches, the Conservative benches, that believe in evidence-based reform to have a more effective policy in dealing with the scourge of drugs."Mr Syms said: "Contrary to press reports, there are many of us on these benches, the Conservative benches, that believe in evidence-based reform to have a more effective policy in dealing with the scourge of drugs."
The Misuse of Drugs Act was passed in 1971. Ms Lucas brought the debate noting that current policies are "often counter-productive", urging the government to "consider all the alternatives to the UK's failing drug laws and learn from countries that have adopted a more evidence-based approach" and calling for an independent review of the existing Misuse of Drugs Act, introduced in 1971, within the next 12 months.
Ms Lucas's motion, which was backed by Labour's Bob Ainsworth and Lib Dem Julian Huppert, told MPs that "fear of the tabloids" had driven UK drug policy for decades. She has said she worded it to be as uncontroversial as possible, and it was backed by Labour's Bob Ainsworth and Lib Dem Julian Huppert.
It was passed, unopposed, by MPs, but will not be binding on the government.
'Evil cartels'
Ms Lucas told MPs that "fear of the tabloids" had driven UK drug policy for decades.
She said successive governments had consistently refused to take an "evidence-based approach" out of "fear of the tabloids", while Labour's Paul Flynn said drug policy since 1971 had been "evidence-free and prejudice-rich".She said successive governments had consistently refused to take an "evidence-based approach" out of "fear of the tabloids", while Labour's Paul Flynn said drug policy since 1971 had been "evidence-free and prejudice-rich".
The Liberal Democrats' Julian Huppert claimed public opinion was turning in support of drug policy reform, and said that now "lots of newspapers are coming out in favour". The Liberal Democrats' Julian Huppert claimed public opinion was turning in support of drug policy reform, and said that now "lots of newspapers are coming out in favour". Conservative Stephen Phillips said MPs were regarded as "dinosaurs" on the issue by young people.
But Tory Sarah Wollaston, chairman of the Health Select Committee and a former GP, said that although she had "no moralistic objection" to those who used drugs, as opposed to those involved in the drug trade, it was "factually incorrect" to say the UK was losing the war on drugs. But Conservative MP Sarah Wollaston, chairman of the Health Select Committee and a former GP, said that it was "factually incorrect" to say the UK was losing the war on drugs, adding that drug use was falling, thanks to the government's policy.
She added: "I don't have any moralistic view on taking drugs other than the fact that I object to people supporting one of the most evil businesses and cartels worldwide.
"It always surprises me that people who would perhaps object to buying coffee in Starbucks and would refuse to support Amazon are quite happy to support these cartels that cause untold misery to hundreds of thousands of people around the world."
'One-sided debate''One-sided debate'
She claimed drug use was falling, thanks to the government's policy. Conservative Crispin Blunt, who was a junior minister in the Ministry of Justice, said it was a "big step forward to even get the government to say what the international comparators are".
He told MPs Mr Cameron's government "plainly" felt it would get a "kicking" from the tabloids, if it considered moving away from tough drugs laws.
For Labour, shadow Home Office minister Diane Johnson said it was "important not to have a one-sided debate and just say everything's failed". She also argued that there was much evidence to suggest that the policies pursued by successive governments had worked to reduce drug abuse.For Labour, shadow Home Office minister Diane Johnson said it was "important not to have a one-sided debate and just say everything's failed". She also argued that there was much evidence to suggest that the policies pursued by successive governments had worked to reduce drug abuse.
But she was criticised by Labour backbencher Diane Abbott, who told her: "When you say that the status quo isn't failing I don't know what world you are living in. It is failing young people in London."
At the end of the debate Mr Baker announced that the government was amending regulations to make the drug Naloxone more widely available - to try to prevent prisoners overusing heroin on their release and dying.At the end of the debate Mr Baker announced that the government was amending regulations to make the drug Naloxone more widely available - to try to prevent prisoners overusing heroin on their release and dying.
"That's already available on prescription but we are amending regulations to make it more widely available from next year which will help prevent people come out of prison, overusing heroin and causing sudden death in that situation," he said.
He said he hoped the Commons debate would be the start of a wider debate on drugs policy. "The genie is out of the bottle and is not going back in. The days of robotic. mindless rhetoric will no long do," he said, adding that the evidence would not allow it.He said he hoped the Commons debate would be the start of a wider debate on drugs policy. "The genie is out of the bottle and is not going back in. The days of robotic. mindless rhetoric will no long do," he said, adding that the evidence would not allow it.
Ms Lucas said at the close of the sometimes-sparsely attended debate, that her only regret was that MPs who were not convinced of the arguments to change existing policy were not in the chamber to hear them.Ms Lucas said at the close of the sometimes-sparsely attended debate, that her only regret was that MPs who were not convinced of the arguments to change existing policy were not in the chamber to hear them.
Thursday's debate was granted by the Commons Backbench Business Committee - after an e-petition calling for an impact assessment of drugs laws was signed by 135,000 people - and its conclusions will not be binding on the government. Thursday's debate was granted by the Commons Backbench Business Committee - after an e-petition calling for an impact assessment of drugs laws was signed by 135,000 people.
Home Office study
The reports released on Thursday say there is "no obvious relationship" between tough drug laws and levels of drug abuse.
One explored different ways in which 13 countries approach drug misuse and compared them with the UK.
After examining a range of approaches, from zero-tolerance to decriminalisation, the research concluded that drug use is influenced by factors "more complex and nuanced than legislation and enforcement alone".
The motion considered by MPs said an "evidence-based approach" should be at the centre of an effective drugs policy and calls on the government to consider "all the alternatives to the UK's failing drug laws".
Ms Lucas has said it was worded so as to be as uncontroversial as possible and had received backing from other parties.
Although Norman Baker has responsibility for drugs policy, his boss - Conservative Home Secretary Theresa May - has made clear no major changes are on the agenda, maintaining that existing approaches are working.