This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/nov/03/george-brandis-in-bankstown-qa-wrap-up
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| George Brandis in Bankstown: Q&A wrap up | George Brandis in Bankstown: Q&A wrap up |
| (5 months later) | |
| Monday night’s “Brandis in Bankstown” episode of Q&A was strange: about Muslims but not really; about accountability for George Brandis but not quite; an “adventure in democracy” without a panel; and an audience, raring to get stuck into the attorney general, that was instead stacked with Muslim leaders, academics and the AFP. | Monday night’s “Brandis in Bankstown” episode of Q&A was strange: about Muslims but not really; about accountability for George Brandis but not quite; an “adventure in democracy” without a panel; and an audience, raring to get stuck into the attorney general, that was instead stacked with Muslim leaders, academics and the AFP. |
| The overwhelming impression was of something very stage managed – although as Comment is Free regular Jason Wilson pointed out back in May, that’s the way Q&A works. | The overwhelming impression was of something very stage managed – although as Comment is Free regular Jason Wilson pointed out back in May, that’s the way Q&A works. |
| Nonetheless the Twitter feed rolled on. Some well-known Muslim tweeters were not happy with the set-up of the programme: | Nonetheless the Twitter feed rolled on. Some well-known Muslim tweeters were not happy with the set-up of the programme: |
| Am disappointed that #QandA Execs didn't treat QandA guests (@lydia_shelly ) with respect to be seated next to Brandis as a panelist @QandA | Am disappointed that #QandA Execs didn't treat QandA guests (@lydia_shelly ) with respect to be seated next to Brandis as a panelist @QandA |
| many key voices in the Muslim community boycotting tonight's #qanda event when Brandis does Bankstown. Producers wont tell you that #auspol | many key voices in the Muslim community boycotting tonight's #qanda event when Brandis does Bankstown. Producers wont tell you that #auspol |
| Not everyone was happy with the boycott: | Not everyone was happy with the boycott: |
| At #QandA very sad at those who boycotted this evening. Looking forward to giving the AG some tough questions | At #QandA very sad at those who boycotted this evening. Looking forward to giving the AG some tough questions |
| Brandis’ line this evening was that, when it comes to counter-terrorism and national security, the government and Muslim community are “partners” and radicalisation is a “shared problem”. | Brandis’ line this evening was that, when it comes to counter-terrorism and national security, the government and Muslim community are “partners” and radicalisation is a “shared problem”. |
| The attorney general insisted to Muslim leaders in the audience that “You are not the problem, you are the solution”. The Muslim community is also the victim, Brandis said, of a “small number of people who move in your community”. | The attorney general insisted to Muslim leaders in the audience that “You are not the problem, you are the solution”. The Muslim community is also the victim, Brandis said, of a “small number of people who move in your community”. |
| Again, the tweets rolled on: | Again, the tweets rolled on: |
| I get the feeling Muslims have been permanently benched on Team Australia #QandA | I get the feeling Muslims have been permanently benched on Team Australia #QandA |
| Brandis is disingenuous - he didn't adopt any of the feedback given to him at the countless 'consultation meetings'. #QandA | |
| Talking on the foreign fighters’ laws with lawyer Lydia Shelley, Brandis noted 73 people have had their passports cancelled. In doing so, we’re meeting our obligations under international law. | Talking on the foreign fighters’ laws with lawyer Lydia Shelley, Brandis noted 73 people have had their passports cancelled. In doing so, we’re meeting our obligations under international law. |
| Shelley said it was “a sustained attack by the government on civil liberties”. | Shelley said it was “a sustained attack by the government on civil liberties”. |
| Brandis replied: | Brandis replied: |
| We can’t pretend that there isn’t a specific problem here. This is what we know. We know that at the moment there are... 71 young Australians fighting in the Northern Iraq and Syrian theatres for Isil and associated terror organisations. More than 20 have returned. 15 have been killed, 2 have suicided. Every last one of those people have been recruited from within this community. | We can’t pretend that there isn’t a specific problem here. This is what we know. We know that at the moment there are... 71 young Australians fighting in the Northern Iraq and Syrian theatres for Isil and associated terror organisations. More than 20 have returned. 15 have been killed, 2 have suicided. Every last one of those people have been recruited from within this community. |
| You mightn’t like to hear me say the word victim ... but the government thinks this community is being preyed upon ... ensnared, cajoled. | You mightn’t like to hear me say the word victim ... but the government thinks this community is being preyed upon ... ensnared, cajoled. |
| Muslim cleric Mohamed Abdallah remarked that radicalisation has been “painted as a massive problem but is not that grave”. The real failure is in not addressing the root causes of radicalisation. He said the government’s approach has been superficial. One tweeter disagreed: | Muslim cleric Mohamed Abdallah remarked that radicalisation has been “painted as a massive problem but is not that grave”. The real failure is in not addressing the root causes of radicalisation. He said the government’s approach has been superficial. One tweeter disagreed: |
| We just had a man shot outside a mosque and this guy claims it isn't much of a problem?#qanda | We just had a man shot outside a mosque and this guy claims it isn't much of a problem?#qanda |
| Questions rolled on: what about foreign fighters in the IDF? What about white supremacists back home – should they get more attention from Asio? | Questions rolled on: what about foreign fighters in the IDF? What about white supremacists back home – should they get more attention from Asio? |
| More Muslim women have been victims of racist attacks from white supremacists than any "Islamist terror" in this country. #qanda | More Muslim women have been victims of racist attacks from white supremacists than any "Islamist terror" in this country. #qanda |
| A lot of questions were thrown to the AFP’s representative, Neil Gaughan from the counter-terrorism unit. But he wasn’t on the panel – it was almost like he was a consultant for Tony Jones. After the terror raids, was this a good idea? | A lot of questions were thrown to the AFP’s representative, Neil Gaughan from the counter-terrorism unit. But he wasn’t on the panel – it was almost like he was a consultant for Tony Jones. After the terror raids, was this a good idea? |
| It was a DECORATIVE sword. Not a weapon. #qanda | It was a DECORATIVE sword. Not a weapon. #qanda |
| Not everyone thought it was a problem though: | Not everyone thought it was a problem though: |
| Muslim communities are being targeted because that's where the problem is. Should Buddhists be targeted to show a lack of bias? #qanda | Muslim communities are being targeted because that's where the problem is. Should Buddhists be targeted to show a lack of bias? #qanda |
| "How dare you try to stop me getting killed!?!" - Everyone complaining about raids #qanda | |
| Especially not Brandis: | Especially not Brandis: |
| Let us get this straight... the police operation Appleby was not over the top, it was not overreach. There was specific actionable intelligence that an individual was imminently about to commit ... an act of lethal violence ... here in Sydney. | Let us get this straight... the police operation Appleby was not over the top, it was not overreach. There was specific actionable intelligence that an individual was imminently about to commit ... an act of lethal violence ... here in Sydney. |
| How is an accompanying media stunt to police raids in the public interest? Unless fear is seen in the public interest? #QandA | How is an accompanying media stunt to police raids in the public interest? Unless fear is seen in the public interest? #QandA |
| Brandis gave his usual lines on bigotry – “the point I make is that you can’t say you believe in freedom of speech unless you accept that everyone has the right to freedom of speech” and said the new natsec laws would not penalise journalists. | Brandis gave his usual lines on bigotry – “the point I make is that you can’t say you believe in freedom of speech unless you accept that everyone has the right to freedom of speech” and said the new natsec laws would not penalise journalists. |
| Then there was the moment we’d all been waiting for: | Then there was the moment we’d all been waiting for: |
| I missed the start. Has anyone asked him to define metadata yet? #qanda | I missed the start. Has anyone asked him to define metadata yet? #qanda |
| Brandis cleared up AFP commissioner Andrew Colvin’s remarks that metadata could be used to catch illegal downloaders: “Can’t be and won’t be.” | Brandis cleared up AFP commissioner Andrew Colvin’s remarks that metadata could be used to catch illegal downloaders: “Can’t be and won’t be.” |
| But it will catch those committing paedophilia and child exploitation offences, he added. | But it will catch those committing paedophilia and child exploitation offences, he added. |
| also Big Bang theory downloaders could be euthanised #qanda | also Big Bang theory downloaders could be euthanised #qanda |
| Did you think more time should have been given to metadata? Was Brandis’ solo appearance in Bankstown courageous, or brazen? And after he was accused of ignoring the submissions from the Muslim community on counter-terror laws, are they really a partner? Jump in the thread and let us know what you reckon. | Did you think more time should have been given to metadata? Was Brandis’ solo appearance in Bankstown courageous, or brazen? And after he was accused of ignoring the submissions from the Muslim community on counter-terror laws, are they really a partner? Jump in the thread and let us know what you reckon. |