This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/nov/09/remembrance-sunday-fought-war

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Remembrance isn’t only about those who fought, but also those who refused Remembrance isn’t only about those who fought, but also those who refused
(about 2 hours later)
As an RAF veteran of the second world war I know that November is a cruel month for both remembering and forgetting the cost of armed conflict. During these past few days when the light grows dim, I have stumbled around London and remembered a time when, as a young man, I witnessed our capital face death from swarms of Nazi bomber planes.As an RAF veteran of the second world war I know that November is a cruel month for both remembering and forgetting the cost of armed conflict. During these past few days when the light grows dim, I have stumbled around London and remembered a time when, as a young man, I witnessed our capital face death from swarms of Nazi bomber planes.
In this day and age we like to impose uniformity to our past conflicts. We see them through a nostalgic lens of wartime propaganda films in which the hero gladly sacrifices his life for a green and pleasant land. But the past is not as simple or as clear-cut as our TV presenters like to suggest during Remembrance Sunday services. For every act of unique heroism we remember, we often forget or ignore all those who, because of post-traumatic stress disorder or moral or religious objections, were unwilling to put their lives on the line for king and country. In this day and age we like to impose uniformity on our past conflicts. We see them through a nostalgic lens of wartime propaganda films in which the hero gladly sacrifices his life for a green and pleasant land. But the past is not as simple or as clear-cut as our TV presenters like to suggest during Remembrance Sunday services. For every act of unique heroism we remember, we often forget or ignore all those who, because of post-traumatic stress disorder or moral or religious objections, were unwilling to put their lives on the line for king and country.
Today, we forget too easily that our resolve during the first two years of battle with Hitler wasn’t as great as popular history likes to imagine. In fact, Lord Halifax, who was a member of Neville Chamberlain’s cabinet, wanted to broker a peace deal between Britain and the Nazis, as did many other aristocrats and businesses leaders. Moreover, many working-class citizens who had been hit by austerity during the Great Depression didn’t feel particularly patriotic about Britain in either peace or war.Today, we forget too easily that our resolve during the first two years of battle with Hitler wasn’t as great as popular history likes to imagine. In fact, Lord Halifax, who was a member of Neville Chamberlain’s cabinet, wanted to broker a peace deal between Britain and the Nazis, as did many other aristocrats and businesses leaders. Moreover, many working-class citizens who had been hit by austerity during the Great Depression didn’t feel particularly patriotic about Britain in either peace or war.
I remember that before I volunteered for the RAF my employer begged me to become a conscientious objector. His issues against the war were more about lost commerce than moral outrage at the shedding of blood. Yet despite his promises of promotion and material reward, I didn’t take his advice because, although I had grave concerns over the inequalities of 1930s Britain, I still believed my place during a time of national emergency was in uniform. Many, however, didn’t feel as strongly as I and my friends who volunteered, because during the second world war 60,000 men registered as conscientious objectors. Moreover, there were more than 100,000 men in uniform who during the course of the conflict against Nazism deserted their posts or failed to return from leave.I remember that before I volunteered for the RAF my employer begged me to become a conscientious objector. His issues against the war were more about lost commerce than moral outrage at the shedding of blood. Yet despite his promises of promotion and material reward, I didn’t take his advice because, although I had grave concerns over the inequalities of 1930s Britain, I still believed my place during a time of national emergency was in uniform. Many, however, didn’t feel as strongly as I and my friends who volunteered, because during the second world war 60,000 men registered as conscientious objectors. Moreover, there were more than 100,000 men in uniform who during the course of the conflict against Nazism deserted their posts or failed to return from leave.
It is unfortunate that too many in this present age look upon these men as cowards whose objections to battle are best forgotten. But I believe it is important that we remember those who dissent in a time of war even if we believe our struggle to be true and just. How a nation treats those who oppose their war aims is the true measure of its enlightenment.It is unfortunate that too many in this present age look upon these men as cowards whose objections to battle are best forgotten. But I believe it is important that we remember those who dissent in a time of war even if we believe our struggle to be true and just. How a nation treats those who oppose their war aims is the true measure of its enlightenment.
Present-day Britain has a lot to learn from our second world war history because, despite popular myth, conscientious objectors weren’t always shunned by society but compelled to contribute to the war effort through ambulance and paramedic work or rebuilding neighbourhoods that had suffered extensive bomb damage. Even the treatment of deserters was more humane in the second world war than the first, when many were shot out of hand. Still, there is no question that deserters and their families were treated harshly by both the police and government authorities during the second world war. Fortunately, many were able to get on with their lives in postwar Britain with no lasting stigma.Present-day Britain has a lot to learn from our second world war history because, despite popular myth, conscientious objectors weren’t always shunned by society but compelled to contribute to the war effort through ambulance and paramedic work or rebuilding neighbourhoods that had suffered extensive bomb damage. Even the treatment of deserters was more humane in the second world war than the first, when many were shot out of hand. Still, there is no question that deserters and their families were treated harshly by both the police and government authorities during the second world war. Fortunately, many were able to get on with their lives in postwar Britain with no lasting stigma.
This is but one of the reasons I will no longer wear the poppy today: it represents only what is seen as the “courage” of war – those who stood and fought, but not those who stood and disagreed. It is the reason why, when I recently went to see the ceramic poppies that surround the Tower of London like a turgid lake of blood, I recalled not only lives lost in battles from ancient and modern wars but also those that were changed irrevocably by the consequences of having an individual conscience during a time of collective insecurity. I feel we must find a way to remember them too.This is but one of the reasons I will no longer wear the poppy today: it represents only what is seen as the “courage” of war – those who stood and fought, but not those who stood and disagreed. It is the reason why, when I recently went to see the ceramic poppies that surround the Tower of London like a turgid lake of blood, I recalled not only lives lost in battles from ancient and modern wars but also those that were changed irrevocably by the consequences of having an individual conscience during a time of collective insecurity. I feel we must find a way to remember them too.