This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/nov/23/winter-sleep-review-powerful-meditation-guilt-nuri-bilge-ceylan

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Winter Sleep review – a powerful meditation upon guilt Winter Sleep review – a powerful meditation upon guilt
(1 day later)
“You are an unbearable man,” declares Melisa Sözen in the third hour of this quietly intense tale of wealth and poverty, religion and politics, husbands and wives from Turkish auteur Nuri Bilge Ceylan. “You are selfish, spiteful and cynical,” she continues, before conceding that her target is also an “honest, fair, and conscientious man. But sometimes you use these virtues to suffocate people – to crush and humiliate them.”“You are an unbearable man,” declares Melisa Sözen in the third hour of this quietly intense tale of wealth and poverty, religion and politics, husbands and wives from Turkish auteur Nuri Bilge Ceylan. “You are selfish, spiteful and cynical,” she continues, before conceding that her target is also an “honest, fair, and conscientious man. But sometimes you use these virtues to suffocate people – to crush and humiliate them.”
The tension between morality and malice is at the heart of Ceylan’s sprawlingly wordy and cumulatively powerful meditation upon Dostoevskian guilt that credits Chekhov (several stories were initially inspirational), quotes Shakespeare (there’s more than a touch of Lear here), acknowledges Sartre (hell is indeed other people) and nods stylistically toward the architectural psychologies of Bergman. The unfashionably expansive dialogue is proudly argumentative and unashamedly literary; these are the kind of conversations one might expect to encounter in a novel or play rather than a film.The tension between morality and malice is at the heart of Ceylan’s sprawlingly wordy and cumulatively powerful meditation upon Dostoevskian guilt that credits Chekhov (several stories were initially inspirational), quotes Shakespeare (there’s more than a touch of Lear here), acknowledges Sartre (hell is indeed other people) and nods stylistically toward the architectural psychologies of Bergman. The unfashionably expansive dialogue is proudly argumentative and unashamedly literary; these are the kind of conversations one might expect to encounter in a novel or play rather than a film.
Yet for all its oppressive staginess and perversely withheld cinematic pleasures (the eye-catching Cappadocian settings are eschewed for interiors shot by Gökhan Tiryaki in what is best termed “widescreen claustrophobia”), Winter Sleep is an engrossing work, a finely observed portrait of collapsing social contracts, public and private. While it may not scale the spine-tingling heights of Once Upon a Time in Anatolia, this Cannes Palme d’Or winner reconfirms Ceylan as a film-maker at the peak of his powers – singular, insightful, compassionate.Yet for all its oppressive staginess and perversely withheld cinematic pleasures (the eye-catching Cappadocian settings are eschewed for interiors shot by Gökhan Tiryaki in what is best termed “widescreen claustrophobia”), Winter Sleep is an engrossing work, a finely observed portrait of collapsing social contracts, public and private. While it may not scale the spine-tingling heights of Once Upon a Time in Anatolia, this Cannes Palme d’Or winner reconfirms Ceylan as a film-maker at the peak of his powers – singular, insightful, compassionate.
Haluk Bilginer is monumental as Aydin, a former actor who proudly declares that he “never did soaps” (a cheeky nod to Bilginer’s time on EastEnders?) and who now claims to be working on a significantly unstarted history of Turkish theatre. Much of Aydin’s time is taken up writing pompous newspaper columns for “Voices of the Steppe” in which he pontificates about matters of art, morality and religion – columns that provoke obsequious fan mail that he duly reads aloud in his bijou hilltop hotel. In his mind, he is an artist and benefactor; in reality, he is a landlord, delegating managerial duties to his long-suffering aide Hidayet (Ayberk Pekcan) and to faceless debt collectors who aren’t afraid to get tough with the tenants. When the son of one such harassed family throws a stone at Aydin’s car, it is more than a window that is broken; over the ensuing hours we watch Aydin’s private life quietly shattering as the facade of his benevolence fractures, falters and falls away.Haluk Bilginer is monumental as Aydin, a former actor who proudly declares that he “never did soaps” (a cheeky nod to Bilginer’s time on EastEnders?) and who now claims to be working on a significantly unstarted history of Turkish theatre. Much of Aydin’s time is taken up writing pompous newspaper columns for “Voices of the Steppe” in which he pontificates about matters of art, morality and religion – columns that provoke obsequious fan mail that he duly reads aloud in his bijou hilltop hotel. In his mind, he is an artist and benefactor; in reality, he is a landlord, delegating managerial duties to his long-suffering aide Hidayet (Ayberk Pekcan) and to faceless debt collectors who aren’t afraid to get tough with the tenants. When the son of one such harassed family throws a stone at Aydin’s car, it is more than a window that is broken; over the ensuing hours we watch Aydin’s private life quietly shattering as the facade of his benevolence fractures, falters and falls away.
Ceylan describes Aydin as “a very typical modern Turkish intellectual” (his name itself is a pointed Turkish pun) and Winter Sleep deftly etches the strange slights of a life that have turned him into someone who hates “practically everybody”. Ever eager to recall a fleeting encounter with Omar Sharif to his gradually departing guests, Aydin is left in the disconsolate company of his close family; divorced sister Necla (Demet Akbag) whose discussions of “not resisting evil” veil a tragic desire to return to the husband who wronged her; and trapped wife Nihal (Sözen), seeking solace and self-justification in charitable work that is met with fiery disdain. Each is intuitively observed and perfectly played, Ceylan coaxing performances of extraordinary candour through extended takes that reinforce both the theatricality and naturalism of the piece. Ceylan describes Aydin as “a very typical modern Turkish intellectual” (his name itself is a pointed Turkish pun) and Winter Sleep deftly etches the strange slights of a life that have turned him into someone who hates “practically everybody”. Ever eager to recall a fleeting encounter with Omar Sharif to his gradually departing guests, Aydin is left in the disconsolate company of his close family; divorced sister Necla (Demet Akbag) whose discussions of “not resisting evil” veil a tragic desire to return to the husband who wronged her; and trapped wife Nihal (Sözen), seeking solace and self-justification in charitable work that is met with fiery disdain. Each is intuitively observed and perfectly played, Ceylan coaxing performances of extraordinary candour through extended takes that reinforce both the theatricality and naturalism of the piece.
Collaborating on the screenplay (as they have done since 2006’s Climates), husband-and-wife team Nuri Bilge and Ebru Ceylan get under the skin of their male and female characters with equal dexterity. “It’s by arguing about a scene that we make it deeper,” the director has said in interview. “We’re able to see it from both the man’s and the woman’s point of view.”Collaborating on the screenplay (as they have done since 2006’s Climates), husband-and-wife team Nuri Bilge and Ebru Ceylan get under the skin of their male and female characters with equal dexterity. “It’s by arguing about a scene that we make it deeper,” the director has said in interview. “We’re able to see it from both the man’s and the woman’s point of view.”
Yet this balance extends beyond gender boundaries; in a drama in which wealth and poverty are juxtaposed as starkly as religion and secularism, the motivations, aspirations and disappointments of every character are described with pointillist precision, tiny details combining to create utterly coherent portraits. Take Hamdi (Serhat Kiliç), embattled uncle of the young boy who casts the stone, now desperately attempting to reconcile his hot-headed brother and passively threatening landlord, his lips permanently stretched in a grimace of desperation and decency that speaks volumes about his inner anguish.Yet this balance extends beyond gender boundaries; in a drama in which wealth and poverty are juxtaposed as starkly as religion and secularism, the motivations, aspirations and disappointments of every character are described with pointillist precision, tiny details combining to create utterly coherent portraits. Take Hamdi (Serhat Kiliç), embattled uncle of the young boy who casts the stone, now desperately attempting to reconcile his hot-headed brother and passively threatening landlord, his lips permanently stretched in a grimace of desperation and decency that speaks volumes about his inner anguish.
While the narrative thrust of this story about a landlord at loggerheads with his tenants may be interpreted as political, the devil is in the personal detail of Hamdi’s smile, Nihal’s frown, Aydin’s smirk.While the narrative thrust of this story about a landlord at loggerheads with his tenants may be interpreted as political, the devil is in the personal detail of Hamdi’s smile, Nihal’s frown, Aydin’s smirk.
There are moments of pure cinema too; a captured horse, pulled exhausted from a stream, escaping into the glowing night; a lordly hand presented to be kissed, causing a child to collapse in a dead faint; a blanket of white that cleanses and freezes the awe-inspiring landscape and its inhabitants, the wintry sleep of the title implying both hibernation and/or death.There are moments of pure cinema too; a captured horse, pulled exhausted from a stream, escaping into the glowing night; a lordly hand presented to be kissed, causing a child to collapse in a dead faint; a blanket of white that cleanses and freezes the awe-inspiring landscape and its inhabitants, the wintry sleep of the title implying both hibernation and/or death.
“Don’t judge people,” Aydin is warned. “Accept things as they are.” Perhaps it is that absence of judgment that lends Winter Sleep its even-handed strength. We are left not with a sense of tragedy but of sympathy – the possibility of redemption raised, if not fulfilled, the complexities of these intertwining life stories still falling like unsettled snow.“Don’t judge people,” Aydin is warned. “Accept things as they are.” Perhaps it is that absence of judgment that lends Winter Sleep its even-handed strength. We are left not with a sense of tragedy but of sympathy – the possibility of redemption raised, if not fulfilled, the complexities of these intertwining life stories still falling like unsettled snow.