This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/dec/04/hillsborough-inquest-ambulance-service-response
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Hillsborough inquest: faster ambulance response could have saved lives | Hillsborough inquest: faster ambulance response could have saved lives |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| Some of the 96 people who died in the Hillsborough disaster in 1989 could have been saved if the ambulance service had organised a better response, a senior ambulance officer who was on duty within the football ground has said. | Some of the 96 people who died in the Hillsborough disaster in 1989 could have been saved if the ambulance service had organised a better response, a senior ambulance officer who was on duty within the football ground has said. |
| Paul Eason, then a station officer for the South Yorkshire Metropolitan Ambulance Service (SYMAS), agreed at the new inquests into the 96 deaths that the response to the disaster had not been successful and was not the service’s “finest hour.” | |
| He agreed that some of the victims may have died while being carried up the Hillsborough pitch on makeshift stretchers by police and other supporters, because they were on their backs, not in the recovery position. | |
| Eason, whose role inside the ground at the FA Cup semi-final between Liverpool and Nottingham Forest was to be the “eyes and ears” of the ambulance service, admitted to a series of personal failings. These included that he failed to recognise the lethal nature of the crush soon enough, failed to declare a major incident until 3.22pm which was too late, and did not communicate the seriousness of the crisis to ambulance control. | |
| The court, in Warrington, heard that SYMAS control declined a police request to send a fleet of ambulances because they had Eason and another officer at the ground who were supposed to assess the degree of emergency. | |
| Mark George QC, representing 22 families whose relatives died in the crush, put to Eason that the scene on the pitch as the disaster unfolded was “unmanageable chaos” and it was an “obscenity” that people emerging from the overcrowded Leppings Lane terrace pens were “literally falling over” injured and dead bodies of people who had been “dumped” there. As hundreds of South Yorkshire police officers were on duty, George suggested that Eason should have become involved in organising a protected area, on the pitch, in which people could have been treated, had airways cleared, given oxygen and been laid on their sides in the recovery position, according to priority. | Mark George QC, representing 22 families whose relatives died in the crush, put to Eason that the scene on the pitch as the disaster unfolded was “unmanageable chaos” and it was an “obscenity” that people emerging from the overcrowded Leppings Lane terrace pens were “literally falling over” injured and dead bodies of people who had been “dumped” there. As hundreds of South Yorkshire police officers were on duty, George suggested that Eason should have become involved in organising a protected area, on the pitch, in which people could have been treated, had airways cleared, given oxygen and been laid on their sides in the recovery position, according to priority. |
| Implementing this plan “would probably have saved the lives of some of those who died; do you not accept that?” George asked. | Implementing this plan “would probably have saved the lives of some of those who died; do you not accept that?” George asked. |
| “I can’t disagree with that,” Eason replied. | “I can’t disagree with that,” Eason replied. |
| In the absence of such a plan, George said that people who had difficulty breathing because they had been crushed were carried on the makeshift stretchers – advertising hoardings were used – 150 yards to the Hillsborough gymnasium, on their backs, “mostly because of a lack of knowledge” from those carrying them. | In the absence of such a plan, George said that people who had difficulty breathing because they had been crushed were carried on the makeshift stretchers – advertising hoardings were used – 150 yards to the Hillsborough gymnasium, on their backs, “mostly because of a lack of knowledge” from those carrying them. |
| “There is a real chance that people probably died in that time,” George said. If people were unconscious, their tongues could have lolled back, obstructing their airways, he said, and those who were in danger were “beyond redemption” when they arrived at the gymnasium. | “There is a real chance that people probably died in that time,” George said. If people were unconscious, their tongues could have lolled back, obstructing their airways, he said, and those who were in danger were “beyond redemption” when they arrived at the gymnasium. |
| “That’s possible, yes,” Eason replied. | “That’s possible, yes,” Eason replied. |
| Eason’s role had been described by another SYMAS officer as the “eyes and ears” of the service within the ground but, George said: “The eyes were blurred and the ears were blocked, weren’t they?” | Eason’s role had been described by another SYMAS officer as the “eyes and ears” of the service within the ground but, George said: “The eyes were blurred and the ears were blocked, weren’t they?” |
| “Yes,” Eason replied. | “Yes,” Eason replied. |
| He accepted George’s assertions that he failed “properly to assess the situation” when the crush happened; failed to declare a major incident until 3.21pm or 3.22pm, which he should have done earlier; failed to liaise with the police during the course of the afternoon; and failed to “convey all relevant information” to ambulance control. | He accepted George’s assertions that he failed “properly to assess the situation” when the crush happened; failed to declare a major incident until 3.21pm or 3.22pm, which he should have done earlier; failed to liaise with the police during the course of the afternoon; and failed to “convey all relevant information” to ambulance control. |
| Each ambulance was equipped with bolt cutters, the court heard, but the lack of ambulances meant cutters were not used to cut the wire mesh fence in front of the pens. Eason said the cutters may not have worked on the wire, but, shown film of supporters and police trying to tear down the fences with their bare hands, he agreed with George that the sight was “pitiful.” | |
| George referred to a SYMAS report after the disaster which described it as “a successful exercise” by the ambulance service. | George referred to a SYMAS report after the disaster which described it as “a successful exercise” by the ambulance service. |
| “That is not only an insult to the dead and injured,” George said, “it is complete rubbish isn’t it, and you wouldn’t associate yourself with that, would you?” | “That is not only an insult to the dead and injured,” George said, “it is complete rubbish isn’t it, and you wouldn’t associate yourself with that, would you?” |
| “No,” Eason said. | “No,” Eason said. |
| He accepted it is “not often” that a major disaster happens “right in front” of one of the emergency services, and Hillsborough was “perhaps unique,” as it happened in front of two emergency services: the South Yorkshire police and SYMAS. In response to George’s suggestion that his response inside the stadium to the lethal crush was “a complete shambles,” Eason said: “We had a delayed response.” | He accepted it is “not often” that a major disaster happens “right in front” of one of the emergency services, and Hillsborough was “perhaps unique,” as it happened in front of two emergency services: the South Yorkshire police and SYMAS. In response to George’s suggestion that his response inside the stadium to the lethal crush was “a complete shambles,” Eason said: “We had a delayed response.” |
| “You had a delayed response,” George said. “It wasn’t SYMAS’s finest hour, was it?” | “You had a delayed response,” George said. “It wasn’t SYMAS’s finest hour, was it?” |
| “No,” Eason replied. | “No,” Eason replied. |
| Approximately 40 people whose relatives were killed in the crush, mostly parents whose children died, listened in silence as Eason gave his evidence. | Approximately 40 people whose relatives were killed in the crush, mostly parents whose children died, listened in silence as Eason gave his evidence. |
| The inquests continue. | The inquests continue. |