This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-30752515
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| SpaceX launches cargo ship but rocket recovery test ends in crash | SpaceX launches cargo ship but rocket recovery test ends in crash |
| (1 day later) | |
| The American SpaceX firm says its experiment to bring part of its Falcon rocket down to a soft landing on a floating sea platform did not work. | The American SpaceX firm says its experiment to bring part of its Falcon rocket down to a soft landing on a floating sea platform did not work. |
| The vehicle was launched on a mission to send a cargo capsule to the International Space Station. | The vehicle was launched on a mission to send a cargo capsule to the International Space Station. |
| But once the first-stage of the rocket completed its part of this task, it tried to make a controlled return. | But once the first-stage of the rocket completed its part of this task, it tried to make a controlled return. |
| The company CEO Elon Musk tweeted that the booster had hit the platform hard. | |
| "Close, but no cigar," he added. "Bodes well for the future tho'. Ship itself is fine. Some of the support equipment on the deck will need to be replaced." And he continued: "Didn't get good landing/impact video. Pitch dark and foggy. Will piece it together from telemetry and... actual pieces." | "Close, but no cigar," he added. "Bodes well for the future tho'. Ship itself is fine. Some of the support equipment on the deck will need to be replaced." And he continued: "Didn't get good landing/impact video. Pitch dark and foggy. Will piece it together from telemetry and... actual pieces." |
| SpaceX intends to keep trying. If this kind of capability can be proven, it promises to dramatically lower launch costs in the future. | SpaceX intends to keep trying. If this kind of capability can be proven, it promises to dramatically lower launch costs in the future. |
| It would mean that normally disposable rockets could be recovered, refurbished and re-used. | It would mean that normally disposable rockets could be recovered, refurbished and re-used. |
| It might also point to new ways of bringing spacecraft back down to Earth in general. | It might also point to new ways of bringing spacecraft back down to Earth in general. |
| Lift-off from Cape Canaveral, Florida, for the Falcon 9 with its Dragon freighter occurred at 04:47 local time (09:47 GMT). The cargo ship was confirmed in orbit and en route to the ISS nine minutes later - at about the same time the first stage was expected at the drone ship. Dragon's arrival at the station is set for Monday. | Lift-off from Cape Canaveral, Florida, for the Falcon 9 with its Dragon freighter occurred at 04:47 local time (09:47 GMT). The cargo ship was confirmed in orbit and en route to the ISS nine minutes later - at about the same time the first stage was expected at the drone ship. Dragon's arrival at the station is set for Monday. |
| This is the first American re-supply mission to the orbiting platform since October's spectacular explosion of a freighter system operated by competitor Orbital Sciences Corporation. | This is the first American re-supply mission to the orbiting platform since October's spectacular explosion of a freighter system operated by competitor Orbital Sciences Corporation. |
| Traditionally, rockets have had an expendable architecture. | Traditionally, rockets have had an expendable architecture. |
| As they head skyward, they dump engines and empty propellant tanks to save the weight that allows their upper-stage, including the satellite payload, to make the jump to orbit. | As they head skyward, they dump engines and empty propellant tanks to save the weight that allows their upper-stage, including the satellite payload, to make the jump to orbit. |
| Any discarded hardware simply tumbles back towards the planet and is torn apart. | Any discarded hardware simply tumbles back towards the planet and is torn apart. |
| And this approach means every new mission needs an expensive new rocket. | And this approach means every new mission needs an expensive new rocket. |
| SpaceX, on the other hand, believes it can recycle key elements of its rockets. | SpaceX, on the other hand, believes it can recycle key elements of its rockets. |
| It has been testing first-stage boosters that relight their engines to try to slow their fall through the atmosphere, attaching fins to help guide them downwards and legs to make a stable touchdown. | It has been testing first-stage boosters that relight their engines to try to slow their fall through the atmosphere, attaching fins to help guide them downwards and legs to make a stable touchdown. |
| Until Saturday, these were all mock landings, in which the stage was brought to a hovering position at the surface of the ocean, where, without a solid platform to set down, every booster was then subsequently lost into the water. | Until Saturday, these were all mock landings, in which the stage was brought to a hovering position at the surface of the ocean, where, without a solid platform to set down, every booster was then subsequently lost into the water. |
| This latest experiment marked the first use of the drone platform. | This latest experiment marked the first use of the drone platform. |
| SpaceX conceded that reaching this touchdown pad at the first attempt would be an immense challenge. | SpaceX conceded that reaching this touchdown pad at the first attempt would be an immense challenge. |
| The barge is less than 100m wide, and all previous experiments had been working on a landing accuracy of some 10km. | The barge is less than 100m wide, and all previous experiments had been working on a landing accuracy of some 10km. |
| Nonetheless, the company will be encouraged that it got so close to the platform. | Nonetheless, the company will be encouraged that it got so close to the platform. |
| Analysis | Analysis |
| By Jonathan Amos, BBC science correspondent | By Jonathan Amos, BBC science correspondent |
| Reusability in rockets has been studied for decades. On the face of it, it seems extremely attractive, says John Logsdon, professor emeritus at the Space Policy Institute, George Washington University. | Reusability in rockets has been studied for decades. On the face of it, it seems extremely attractive, says John Logsdon, professor emeritus at the Space Policy Institute, George Washington University. |
| "Because launches would be cheaper you can afford a failure. That means you can design satellites that are much less expensive; you won't have to spend so much money to ensure they work, because if they don't work another launch is relatively cheap." | "Because launches would be cheaper you can afford a failure. That means you can design satellites that are much less expensive; you won't have to spend so much money to ensure they work, because if they don't work another launch is relatively cheap." |
| And Dr Adam Baker, the director of the Rocket Lab at the UK's Kingston University, concurred: "Space exploration is currently extremely expensive. If SpaceX is successful in reducing the cost by 50% or more, more space applications become possible - more satellites, more benefits and services to society from space, for example space solar power, and potentially more astronauts. | And Dr Adam Baker, the director of the Rocket Lab at the UK's Kingston University, concurred: "Space exploration is currently extremely expensive. If SpaceX is successful in reducing the cost by 50% or more, more space applications become possible - more satellites, more benefits and services to society from space, for example space solar power, and potentially more astronauts. |
| "There could be more flights into space for you and I, expeditions to the Moon, exploring Mars, perhaps colonising Mars and going further out into the Solar System." | "There could be more flights into space for you and I, expeditions to the Moon, exploring Mars, perhaps colonising Mars and going further out into the Solar System." |
| But realising these benefits is not so straightforward. | But realising these benefits is not so straightforward. |
| People will remember that the space shuttle was designed as a partially reusable system, and yet the complexities of refurbishing the vehicle swamped any savings. The shuttle main engine - an engineering marvel - contained 50,000 parts. | People will remember that the space shuttle was designed as a partially reusable system, and yet the complexities of refurbishing the vehicle swamped any savings. The shuttle main engine - an engineering marvel - contained 50,000 parts. |
| SpaceX has to avoid this trap if it is to make reusability practical. It says its Merlin engines should be able to complete 40 firing cycles without significant parts exchange. | SpaceX has to avoid this trap if it is to make reusability practical. It says its Merlin engines should be able to complete 40 firing cycles without significant parts exchange. |
| And they would also have to get satellite operators comfortable with the idea of launching their precious hardware on what would essentially be second-hand rockets. | And they would also have to get satellite operators comfortable with the idea of launching their precious hardware on what would essentially be second-hand rockets. |
| "The customer doesn't ask for reusability; they ask for reliability at the cheapest cost possible," said Rachel Villain, with the space intelligence company Euroconsult. | "The customer doesn't ask for reusability; they ask for reliability at the cheapest cost possible," said Rachel Villain, with the space intelligence company Euroconsult. |
| "Reusability is the problem of the supplier, not of the client. A satellite operator has basically three demands - on time, on quality and on price," she told me. | "Reusability is the problem of the supplier, not of the client. A satellite operator has basically three demands - on time, on quality and on price," she told me. |
| Whatever results from SpaceX's experiments, the California-based outfit is certainly making the rocket industry sit up. | Whatever results from SpaceX's experiments, the California-based outfit is certainly making the rocket industry sit up. |
| It already offers commercial launch prices that undercut its competitors, and Europe has been so alarmed by the American firm's progress that it has ordered a new, lower-cost version of its Ariane rocket, which should enter service in 2020. It will not, however, be reusable. | It already offers commercial launch prices that undercut its competitors, and Europe has been so alarmed by the American firm's progress that it has ordered a new, lower-cost version of its Ariane rocket, which should enter service in 2020. It will not, however, be reusable. |
| It will be interesting to see how competitors like Ariane further react if SpaceX makes a real go of reusability. | It will be interesting to see how competitors like Ariane further react if SpaceX makes a real go of reusability. |
| Jonathan.Amos-INTERNET@bbc.co.uk and follow me on Twitter: @BBCAmos | Jonathan.Amos-INTERNET@bbc.co.uk and follow me on Twitter: @BBCAmos |