This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-31016446
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Why is Apple sitting on $142bn? | Why is Apple sitting on $142bn? |
(35 minutes later) | |
King Midas, you may remember, had a problem with gold. Everything he touched turned to the yellow stuff. | King Midas, you may remember, had a problem with gold. Everything he touched turned to the yellow stuff. |
Fine for a while, but not when he realised "everything" meant just that - everything. | Fine for a while, but not when he realised "everything" meant just that - everything. |
He might have had some sympathy with Apple's problem of simply having too much money. | He might have had some sympathy with Apple's problem of simply having too much money. |
And the biggest quarterly profit in history, $18bn, is actually adding to Apple's biggest headache - an excess of cash. | And the biggest quarterly profit in history, $18bn, is actually adding to Apple's biggest headache - an excess of cash. |
In short the company is making money far faster than it can spend it. | In short the company is making money far faster than it can spend it. |
Its cash pile now stands at close to $142bn (£93.5bn). | Its cash pile now stands at close to $142bn (£93.5bn). |
The problem is how to generate a return with that money for shareholders. | The problem is how to generate a return with that money for shareholders. |
It has enough, in theory, to buy 480 or so of the companies in the S&P 500. | It has enough, in theory, to buy 480 or so of the companies in the S&P 500. |
Or Lithuania, three times over. | Or Lithuania, three times over. |
But simply buying up companies is a complex and intricate business and suitable take-over targets are few and far between. | But simply buying up companies is a complex and intricate business and suitable take-over targets are few and far between. |
Its latest, the subscription music service Beats, cost just $3bn - and that was its largest purchase ever. | Its latest, the subscription music service Beats, cost just $3bn - and that was its largest purchase ever. |
Apple Campus | Apple Campus |
It can invest in its own development, and it is spending an estimated $5bn on the 176-acre Apple Campus headquarters site. | It can invest in its own development, and it is spending an estimated $5bn on the 176-acre Apple Campus headquarters site. |
But still the money keeps rolling in. | But still the money keeps rolling in. |
Most of it gets parked in what the accounts call "cash and cash equivalents" and short and long term marketable securities: government and corporate bonds. | Most of it gets parked in what the accounts call "cash and cash equivalents" and short and long term marketable securities: government and corporate bonds. |
Apple manages the cash through a subsidiary, Braeburn Capital, based in Reno, Nevada which has no state corporate income tax, or taxes on corporate shares. | Apple manages the cash through a subsidiary, Braeburn Capital, based in Reno, Nevada which has no state corporate income tax, or taxes on corporate shares. |
It is in effect one of the largest hedge funds in the world. | It is in effect one of the largest hedge funds in the world. |
But shareholders like shareholder activist, Carl Icahn, have been demanding the company simply must hand some of that cash back to shareholders by buying back shares. | But shareholders like shareholder activist, Carl Icahn, have been demanding the company simply must hand some of that cash back to shareholders by buying back shares. |
Share buybacks | Share buybacks |
Hedge fund manager David Einhorn of Greenlight Capital went so far as to sue the company two years ago to try to get a payout. | Hedge fund manager David Einhorn of Greenlight Capital went so far as to sue the company two years ago to try to get a payout. |
They argue that cash, invested largely in government securities gives a paltry rate of return. | They argue that cash, invested largely in government securities gives a paltry rate of return. |
Einhorn argued that getting the excess cash off Apple's balance sheet and back to shareholders would increase the value of the company by $50 per share or more. | Einhorn argued that getting the excess cash off Apple's balance sheet and back to shareholders would increase the value of the company by $50 per share or more. |
So the company obliged and in 2012 started buying back its own stock . Last year it spent some $45bn buying back Apple shares. | So the company obliged and in 2012 started buying back its own stock . Last year it spent some $45bn buying back Apple shares. |
The problem is it has not made much difference. The latest set of results show it has as much cash as it has ever had. | The problem is it has not made much difference. The latest set of results show it has as much cash as it has ever had. |
In total, the amount of cash in the group is around $178bn. Some $35bn in debt reduces that figure to the $142bn mentioned above. | In total, the amount of cash in the group is around $178bn. Some $35bn in debt reduces that figure to the $142bn mentioned above. |
Debt? Why on earth, when you have more wealth in your piggy bank than the average developing nation generates in a year, would you want to borrow more? | Debt? Why on earth, when you have more wealth in your piggy bank than the average developing nation generates in a year, would you want to borrow more? |
The answer is that little of that cash is easily accessible to pay shareholders. Some 89% of it lies offshore out of the hands of the Internal Revenue Service. | |
Tax reform | Tax reform |
Bringing it back would subject it to a top corporate tax rate of 35%. | Bringing it back would subject it to a top corporate tax rate of 35%. |
Far easier to borrow the money instead. And since it has a such a cash pile behind it, banks are happy to lend to Apple at rock bottom rates - even by today's standards. | Far easier to borrow the money instead. And since it has a such a cash pile behind it, banks are happy to lend to Apple at rock bottom rates - even by today's standards. |
Last year Apple funded its share buy-back with a $17bn bond issue. | Last year Apple funded its share buy-back with a $17bn bond issue. |
So, in effect, Apple did what Icahn and Einhorn wanted. | So, in effect, Apple did what Icahn and Einhorn wanted. |
The share price has recovered from around $60 in mid 2013 to around $110 this week. | The share price has recovered from around $60 in mid 2013 to around $110 this week. |
But the cash mountain remains. | But the cash mountain remains. |
Chief Executive Tim Cook told Congress two years ago that much of it could eventually come back to the US. | Chief Executive Tim Cook told Congress two years ago that much of it could eventually come back to the US. |
He even admitted Apple would be happy to pay more tax, but only if there was a "dramatic simplification of the corporate tax code" including a "reasonable tax on foreign earnings that allows the free flow of capital back to the United States". | He even admitted Apple would be happy to pay more tax, but only if there was a "dramatic simplification of the corporate tax code" including a "reasonable tax on foreign earnings that allows the free flow of capital back to the United States". |
But of course if the money did flow freely back to the US, no one is guaranteeing it would be invested any more wisely than it is at the moment. | But of course if the money did flow freely back to the US, no one is guaranteeing it would be invested any more wisely than it is at the moment. |