This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/may/19/afghan-police-officers-jailed-farkhunda-death-mob-attack

The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Afghan police officers jailed over woman's death in mob attack Afghan police officers jailed over woman's death in mob attack
(about 3 hours later)
An Afghan judge has sentenced 11 police officers to one year in prison for their role in the mob killing of a woman in Kabul. A judge found the men guilty of dereliction of duty. Another eight were released due to lack of evidence. Eleven police officers have been sentenced to one year in prison for their role in the mob lynching of a woman in Kabul that caused outrage in Afghanistan and abroad. A primary court judge found the officers guilty of dereliction of duty, while acquitting another eight due to lack of evidence.
The officers were among 49 people charged over the death of 27-year-old Farkhunda, who was lynched by a mob in the centre of Kabul in March. The verdict has exasperated Afghans who had hoped to see the government make political strides in defence of women’s rights. Instead, the case has become emblematic of the lack of legal protection for Afghan women, and of a justice system many say is prone to political meddling.
Farkhunda’s death shocked Afghans for its brutality and spurred calls for authorities to uphold women’s rights to equality and protection from violence. She was beaten, then her body was burned and thrown in a river in a frenzied attack sparked by a bogus accusation that she had burned a copy of the Qur’an. Farkhunda, a 27-year-old religious teacher, was killed by a crowd of angry men in Kabul after an argument with a cleric whom she scolded for selling charms in the street, a practice some regard as un-Islamic.
Earlier this month, four defendants were sentenced to death, eight to 16 years in prison, and 18 were freed due to lack of evidence. The cleric retorted by claiming Farkhunda had burned the Qur’an, after which a mob set upon her, beat her to death, dragged her body behind a car and burned it on the riverbanks in the city centre.
A mob attacked Farkhunda after an amulet peddler accused her of burning a copy of the Qu’ran when she challenged him over selling his wares to women desperate to have children. Related: We are all Farkhunda: how one woman’s murder could change Afghanistan | Kristin Cordell
Her last hours were captured on mobile phone cameras by witnesses and those in the mob that attacked her. The videos of the assault circulated widely on social media. They showed Farkhunda – who, like many Afghans, went by only one name – being beaten, run over with a car and burned before her bloodied body was thrown into the river. Earlier this month, the judge, Safiullah Mujadidi, sentenced four men to death, including the cleric who argued with Farkhunda, and convicted eight others to 16 years behind bars. Eighteen other accused were freed.
Her death sparked protests in Kabul, with some demonstrators wearing masks bearing the image of her bloodied face. Mourners held candlelight vigils in her memory, including in Washington when the Afghan president, Ashraf Ghani, visited the US. The assault was filmed on mobile phones and the footage was widely shared on social media and shown in court. It triggered the largest protests in Kabul in recent memory. Demonstrators wore masks showing Farkhunda’s bloodied face, and re-enacted the murder in front of the shrine where she was killed.
An Afghan presidential investigation later found that she had not damaged a copy of the Muslim holy book. Some public and religious figures said the attack would have been justified if she had in fact damaged a Qur’an. Pressured by public outrage, the court acted promptly, but, according to some, not necessarily justly. The first 30 defendants were sentenced after only three days in court and one day of deliberations. The accused had approximately five minutes to present their case, and not all had access to defence lawyers. Some claimed they were tortured before confessing.
The trial was broadcast live on national TV, reflecting wide public interest. But the speed with which the first sentences were announced after just two full days of court hearings angered many, including Farkhunda’s family. Heather Barr, senior researcher on women’s rights in Afghanistan with Human Rights Watch, said the trial had been done “in a rushed and unprofessional manner, which has denied justice to both Farkhunda and the accused”.
The subsequent delay in announcing the verdicts for the police also raised concern about the possibility of political interference. She said: “Real justice would be for the government to change the way that police and prosecutors respond to violence against women, so that there could never be another murder like this. Real justice for Farkhunda would be for the government to take a hard look at how it is possible that a mob can beat to death a woman in the middle of Kabul, while police stand by and let her die.”
Related: 'Farkhunda belongs to all of the women of Kabul, of Afghanistan' | Frozan Marofi
Other activists worried that the swiftness of the trial, which saw 26 of the total 49 defendants acquitted, had let some perpetrators off.
“With this culture of impunity, they are providing a safe space for criminals in Afghanistan,” said rights activist Aziz Rafiee. He thought the police had managed to sway the judge.
“How come the police can be sentenced to one year in prison but the ordinary people have been sentenced to execution?” he said, adding that some of the main culprits had not been arrested, and were being sheltered by relatives connected to the government.
Fereshta Kazemi, an actor who like many others followed the trial closely, said: “It’s too lenient. I want to know how they came to this conclusion. I want to know what the piece of evidence is for each policeman.”
She thought the trial had been forced to a conclusion too soon. “When these things are rushed, it seems like the actual pain of Afghan women doesn’t matter,” Kazemi said.
The case has become a political lightning rod. The government has dispatched armed guards to protect Farkhunda’s family, and high-ranking officials have gone to the house with condolences.
Related: Family of Afghan woman lynched by mob take comfort from tide of outrage
But according to Farkhunda’s brother, Najibullah, the family was not invited to the final court proceedings. When he was informed about the outcome, Najibullah was disappointed. “The police neglected their job, and we expected something else to happen,” he told the Guardian in a succinct phone call.
Many of the capital’s residents shared the family disbelief over the verdict.
“This trial was not decided by the court but by the police department,” said Leyla Ayubi, a 23-year-old trainee teacher. “The trial was interfered with politically, and it was unjust,” she said.
Shafiqa, 25, a nursing student, said the accused policemen should have received at least three years in prison to teach their colleagues that it is their job to defend female victims of violence.
“God damn these policemen who just watched these uneducated people kill an innocent girl,” she said.
Others showed some sympathy for the police after the verdict.
“They need to be punished for job negligence but one year is a lot for them,” said Rahimullah, 27, a labourer. “I think that in the beginning, the police really believed she was burning the Qur’an. That’s why they didn’t interfere.”
Ultimately, the trial has stymied hope that the brutality of Farkhunda’s murder would force the government to stand up for women’s rights.
“Today’s verdict feels like an effort to be seen to be doing something, while sweeping the issue under the carpet,” Barr of Human Rights Watch said.
“Ashraf Ghani [Afghanistan’s president] has missed an important chance to do something meaningful to fight violence against women.”
Mokhtar Amiri contributed to this report from Kabul