This article is from the source 'independent' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/climatechange-sceptic-viscount-monckton-of-brenchley-claims-tombstone-artwork-critical-of-his-position-is-a-death-threat-10265255.html
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Climate-change sceptic Viscount Monckton of Brenchley claims tombstone artwork critical of his position is a ‘death threat’ | Climate-change sceptic Viscount Monckton of Brenchley claims tombstone artwork critical of his position is a ‘death threat’ |
(1 day later) | |
The prominent climate change sceptic Viscount Monckton of Brenchley has complained to police after a tombstone engraved with his name was exhibited at Anglia Ruskin University. | The prominent climate change sceptic Viscount Monckton of Brenchley has complained to police after a tombstone engraved with his name was exhibited at Anglia Ruskin University. |
Lord Monckton claims that the artwork – which features his name alongside those of other prominent sceptics such as Lord Lawson, the former Environment Secretary Owen Paterson and journalist James Delingpole – amounts to a death threat. | Lord Monckton claims that the artwork – which features his name alongside those of other prominent sceptics such as Lord Lawson, the former Environment Secretary Owen Paterson and journalist James Delingpole – amounts to a death threat. |
The piece comprises a tombstone with the names of six sceptics chiselled under the words “Lest We Forget Those Who Denied”. A constant stream of engine oil runs over the memorial. | The piece comprises a tombstone with the names of six sceptics chiselled under the words “Lest We Forget Those Who Denied”. A constant stream of engine oil runs over the memorial. |
The exhibit won this year’s Anglia Ruskin Sustainability Art Prize for “bringing together a powerful message with a beautiful piece of art”, according to a university press release. | The exhibit won this year’s Anglia Ruskin Sustainability Art Prize for “bringing together a powerful message with a beautiful piece of art”, according to a university press release. |
Viscount Monckton was far from impressed, saying the prize had been awarded by a “jumped-up polytechnic”. | Viscount Monckton was far from impressed, saying the prize had been awarded by a “jumped-up polytechnic”. |
He outlined his thoughts on the right-wing American website WorldNetDaily after visiting the exhibition “to gather evidence for the courts”. | He outlined his thoughts on the right-wing American website WorldNetDaily after visiting the exhibition “to gather evidence for the courts”. |
“To put one’s name on a tombstone while one is still alive is to make a death threat, the nastiest and most repellent form of hate speech. The implication was that, if we were not already dead, the ‘artist’ and the ‘university’ that promoted his ‘work’ would very soon see to it that we were,” he wrote. | “To put one’s name on a tombstone while one is still alive is to make a death threat, the nastiest and most repellent form of hate speech. The implication was that, if we were not already dead, the ‘artist’ and the ‘university’ that promoted his ‘work’ would very soon see to it that we were,” he wrote. |
He went on to draw comparisons with the Third Reich. | He went on to draw comparisons with the Third Reich. |
“A death threat is a death threat. It is no laughing matter… It is plain that the long, relentless campaign of intimidation by the Nazis of their opponents, with name-calling and death threats very similar to that perpetrated by the ‘university’, was an essential part of the process,” he wrote. | “A death threat is a death threat. It is no laughing matter… It is plain that the long, relentless campaign of intimidation by the Nazis of their opponents, with name-calling and death threats very similar to that perpetrated by the ‘university’, was an essential part of the process,” he wrote. |
Lord Monckton also took issue with the vice-chancellor of the university for painting him as a climate change “denier”. | Lord Monckton also took issue with the vice-chancellor of the university for painting him as a climate change “denier”. |
“It mattered not to the vice-chancellor, nor to the “artist”, that I do not deny the existence of climate change… I do not even deny that man may have some as yet unquantified but probably insignificant and even net-beneficial influence on the climate,” he said. | “It mattered not to the vice-chancellor, nor to the “artist”, that I do not deny the existence of climate change… I do not even deny that man may have some as yet unquantified but probably insignificant and even net-beneficial influence on the climate,” he said. |
A spokesman for the viscount said that a complaint had been made to police about the university press release, which he says reinforced the representation of the death threat in the art work. | A spokesman for the viscount said that a complaint had been made to police about the university press release, which he says reinforced the representation of the death threat in the art work. |
The work is by third year BA fine art student Ian Wolter, who lives in Saffron Walden. He told The Independent that the viscount’s reaction was “nonsense”. | The work is by third year BA fine art student Ian Wolter, who lives in Saffron Walden. He told The Independent that the viscount’s reaction was “nonsense”. |
“I don’t think any reasonable person would think of my plywood sculpture as a death threat,” he said, adding: “His extreme reaction is a great example of the power of political art.” | “I don’t think any reasonable person would think of my plywood sculpture as a death threat,” he said, adding: “His extreme reaction is a great example of the power of political art.” |
A spokesman for the university declined to comment. | A spokesman for the university declined to comment. |