This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/25/world/middleeast/businesses-doors-creak-open-in-hebron-ghost-town-decades-after-massacre.html

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Businesses’ Doors Creak Open in Hebron ‘Ghost Town,’ Decades After Massacre Businesses’ Doors Creak Open in a West Bank ‘Ghost Town,’ Decades After Massacre
(about 7 hours later)
HEBRON, West Bank — It took Mohammad Abu Halaweh a good 10 minutes to pry open the rusted metal doors of his butcher shop for the first time in two decades. He had the key, an old-fashioned iron number as big as his hand. But he had to press a sandaled foot against the door and leverage his body weight to yank off a second lock. A handful of curious children had gathered by the time he finally finished the job with the help of a hammer.HEBRON, West Bank — It took Mohammad Abu Halaweh a good 10 minutes to pry open the rusted metal doors of his butcher shop for the first time in two decades. He had the key, an old-fashioned iron number as big as his hand. But he had to press a sandaled foot against the door and leverage his body weight to yank off a second lock. A handful of curious children had gathered by the time he finally finished the job with the help of a hammer.
Inside, Mr. Abu Halaweh found what he had left back in 1994, when the Israeli military shuttered the shops of al-Sahla Street in the Old City of Hebron after an American-born Israeli doctor’s murderous rampage left 29 Muslim worshipers dead at the nearby Tomb of the Patriarchs. A scale covered in dust. The back room where the goats were killed, still a bit rank. An ancient ceiling fan. The shell of a refrigerator with empty meat hooks.Inside, Mr. Abu Halaweh found what he had left back in 1994, when the Israeli military shuttered the shops of al-Sahla Street in the Old City of Hebron after an American-born Israeli doctor’s murderous rampage left 29 Muslim worshipers dead at the nearby Tomb of the Patriarchs. A scale covered in dust. The back room where the goats were killed, still a bit rank. An ancient ceiling fan. The shell of a refrigerator with empty meat hooks.
“This is the table where we used to chop the meat,” he said.“This is the table where we used to chop the meat,” he said.
The reminiscing was cut short by an Israeli soldier, who ordered him to close up once again. It took Mr. Abu Halaweh, a bearded man of 50 in a gray jalabiya, almost as long to get the warped doors secured anew as it did to open them.The reminiscing was cut short by an Israeli soldier, who ordered him to close up once again. It took Mr. Abu Halaweh, a bearded man of 50 in a gray jalabiya, almost as long to get the warped doors secured anew as it did to open them.
This was the first Friday of Ramadan, when the Palestinian mayor of Hebron announced that 70 of the 300-odd shops on al-Sahla Street could reopen. But the Israeli military insisted that it had agreed to only seven, citing security concerns in a place where clashes with settlers are common. So al-Sahla, once a thriving marketplace off the storied Shuhada Street, remained a ghost town, as the Israeli human rights group B’tselem termed it in 2007.This was the first Friday of Ramadan, when the Palestinian mayor of Hebron announced that 70 of the 300-odd shops on al-Sahla Street could reopen. But the Israeli military insisted that it had agreed to only seven, citing security concerns in a place where clashes with settlers are common. So al-Sahla, once a thriving marketplace off the storied Shuhada Street, remained a ghost town, as the Israeli human rights group B’tselem termed it in 2007.
“It’s a progressive process,” said Matthieu Desselas of the Hebron office of the International Committee of the Red Cross, which helped negotiate the deal. “The more shops are open, the more movement there will be. It’s a long-term strategy.”“It’s a progressive process,” said Matthieu Desselas of the Hebron office of the International Committee of the Red Cross, which helped negotiate the deal. “The more shops are open, the more movement there will be. It’s a long-term strategy.”
Shway-shway, as they say in Arabic: slowly, slowly. Too slow, shop owners and residents complained. They said seven stores would not be enough to bring people back, especially since Israeli checkpoints surround the area and prevent Palestinian cars, and thus quantities of goods, from entering.Shway-shway, as they say in Arabic: slowly, slowly. Too slow, shop owners and residents complained. They said seven stores would not be enough to bring people back, especially since Israeli checkpoints surround the area and prevent Palestinian cars, and thus quantities of goods, from entering.
“You need three things to open a shop: owner, product and customers,” said Issa Amro of Youth Against Settlements, an advocacy group. “This is propaganda; on the ground, nothing is changing. It’s increasing the mistrust.”“You need three things to open a shop: owner, product and customers,” said Issa Amro of Youth Against Settlements, an advocacy group. “This is propaganda; on the ground, nothing is changing. It’s increasing the mistrust.”
The Old City of Hebron may be the most tense and fraught patch of the occupied West Bank. The remaining Palestinian families report a near-constant standoff with Israeli settlers, who began squatting in the neighborhood — where Jewish history is centuries old — shortly after Israel captured the West Bank in the 1967 war. Foreigners in white and red shirts and matching vehicles labeled Temporary International Presence in Hebron stand vigil to document problems, as soldiers and tanks stalk the still street.The Old City of Hebron may be the most tense and fraught patch of the occupied West Bank. The remaining Palestinian families report a near-constant standoff with Israeli settlers, who began squatting in the neighborhood — where Jewish history is centuries old — shortly after Israel captured the West Bank in the 1967 war. Foreigners in white and red shirts and matching vehicles labeled Temporary International Presence in Hebron stand vigil to document problems, as soldiers and tanks stalk the still street.
On Friday morning, a religious Jew with prayer fringes hanging over his shorts jogged through. Then came a group of European tourists in sun hats, cameras at the ready. New blue street signs, in Hebrew and English but not Arabic, call it Emek Hebron Street.On Friday morning, a religious Jew with prayer fringes hanging over his shorts jogged through. Then came a group of European tourists in sun hats, cameras at the ready. New blue street signs, in Hebrew and English but not Arabic, call it Emek Hebron Street.
Ghassan Abu Hadid, who has lived all his 32 years on this block, saw a different scene in his mind. The central taxi stand on one corner, buzzing with fares. Across the street, a stand filled with fresh produce. Behind the doors covered in peeling white paint, a home-appliance store. Next to it, a poultry market, and next to that a fragrant spice shop.Ghassan Abu Hadid, who has lived all his 32 years on this block, saw a different scene in his mind. The central taxi stand on one corner, buzzing with fares. Across the street, a stand filled with fresh produce. Behind the doors covered in peeling white paint, a home-appliance store. Next to it, a poultry market, and next to that a fragrant spice shop.
“You could barely walk here because it was so packed with people,” Mr. Abu Hadid recalled.“You could barely walk here because it was so packed with people,” Mr. Abu Hadid recalled.
That was before Baruch Goldstein’s 1994 massacre at the tomb, which Muslims call the Ibrahimi Mosque, and before the 1997 Hebron Protocol that divided the city of 200,000 Palestinians and perhaps 700 Jews, leaving this section under the control of the Israeli military. Before the violent second intifada that stretched from 2000 to 2005, when Palestinians killed 22 Israelis in Hebron, including 17 security officers and 10-month-old Shalhevet Pass, according to B’tselem, and Israeli forces killed 88 Palestinians, nine of them minors.That was before Baruch Goldstein’s 1994 massacre at the tomb, which Muslims call the Ibrahimi Mosque, and before the 1997 Hebron Protocol that divided the city of 200,000 Palestinians and perhaps 700 Jews, leaving this section under the control of the Israeli military. Before the violent second intifada that stretched from 2000 to 2005, when Palestinians killed 22 Israelis in Hebron, including 17 security officers and 10-month-old Shalhevet Pass, according to B’tselem, and Israeli forces killed 88 Palestinians, nine of them minors.
“The declared commitment to free movement and unity of the city was rendered meaningless,” the group’s 2007 report says, citing a new curfew and street closings that led Palestinians to abandon more than 1,000 apartments above the shuttered storefronts. “What was once the vibrant heart of Hebron has become a ghost town.”“The declared commitment to free movement and unity of the city was rendered meaningless,” the group’s 2007 report says, citing a new curfew and street closings that led Palestinians to abandon more than 1,000 apartments above the shuttered storefronts. “What was once the vibrant heart of Hebron has become a ghost town.”
Back then, Abed Muhtaseb’s souvenir shop, across from the Jewish entrance to the revered tomb — which also draws international tourists — and Khaled Fakhouri’s pottery workshop next door were the only businesses open on al-Sahla Street, according to the locals. A year ago, the Red Cross persuaded the Israelis to permit a few more to unlock their doors: There is now a tiny cafe and two places that type up official documents, residents said, but they operate only a few hours a day for lack of traffic.Back then, Abed Muhtaseb’s souvenir shop, across from the Jewish entrance to the revered tomb — which also draws international tourists — and Khaled Fakhouri’s pottery workshop next door were the only businesses open on al-Sahla Street, according to the locals. A year ago, the Red Cross persuaded the Israelis to permit a few more to unlock their doors: There is now a tiny cafe and two places that type up official documents, residents said, but they operate only a few hours a day for lack of traffic.
Now, another handful got the go-ahead, including several owned by Mr. Abu Hadid’s extended family. He has put in a new tile floor and painted the walls pink in one storefront, planning to invest about $8,000 to create a small grocery. On Friday, he examined the ancient, broken-down machines of the little factory where he used to help his grandfather grind wheat and local spices like zatar. And he put a cage of pigeons a few doors down: maybe a pet shop?Now, another handful got the go-ahead, including several owned by Mr. Abu Hadid’s extended family. He has put in a new tile floor and painted the walls pink in one storefront, planning to invest about $8,000 to create a small grocery. On Friday, he examined the ancient, broken-down machines of the little factory where he used to help his grandfather grind wheat and local spices like zatar. And he put a cage of pigeons a few doors down: maybe a pet shop?
“I’m going to buy a fridge, I’m going to bring some shelves,” he said of the grocery-to-be. As for the factory: “We’re going to renovate all these machines and get it back up and running.” But, he warned, “If they don’t remove the checkpoints, this whole thing is for nothing.”“I’m going to buy a fridge, I’m going to bring some shelves,” he said of the grocery-to-be. As for the factory: “We’re going to renovate all these machines and get it back up and running.” But, he warned, “If they don’t remove the checkpoints, this whole thing is for nothing.”
How will shop owners stock supplies when the turnstile at the checkpoint prevents them from even bringing through a handcart? Why would shoppers bother leaving the sprawling Old City souk, with its wondrous smells of baking sweets, to venture down to this contested, dilapidated stretch?How will shop owners stock supplies when the turnstile at the checkpoint prevents them from even bringing through a handcart? Why would shoppers bother leaving the sprawling Old City souk, with its wondrous smells of baking sweets, to venture down to this contested, dilapidated stretch?
The mayor, Daoud Zatari, said that unless storefronts on both sides were given permits – something the military had so far declined – he would “tell the shop owners not to open.”The mayor, Daoud Zatari, said that unless storefronts on both sides were given permits – something the military had so far declined – he would “tell the shop owners not to open.”
“It’s not logical; any security justification doesn’t make any sense,” Mr. Zatari said. “I will not be in a good position with my people to have this shop open on one side, and this shop closed on the other side.”“It’s not logical; any security justification doesn’t make any sense,” Mr. Zatari said. “I will not be in a good position with my people to have this shop open on one side, and this shop closed on the other side.”
Tamar Toledano, a military spokeswoman, said she had no idea why the mayor had announced that 70 shops would reopen, raising false hopes. “For now, it’s seven,” she said. “It’s a very complicated city. It’s little steps. It’s one step at a time.”Tamar Toledano, a military spokeswoman, said she had no idea why the mayor had announced that 70 shops would reopen, raising false hopes. “For now, it’s seven,” she said. “It’s a very complicated city. It’s little steps. It’s one step at a time.”
Mr. Abu Hadid took a little step on Friday. Actually, he took a seat, placing a plastic chair outside the shop, something he said Israeli soldiers had not allowed in a long time.Mr. Abu Hadid took a little step on Friday. Actually, he took a seat, placing a plastic chair outside the shop, something he said Israeli soldiers had not allowed in a long time.