This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-33388990

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Did Live 8 and G8 help cut Africa's debt burden? Did Live 8 and G8 help cut Africa's debt burden?
(about 3 hours later)
Hyde Park in central London. Sir Paul McCartney and U2 were part of a star-studded line up that took to the stage back in 2005 with a simple message to world leaders: "Make Poverty History". Hyde Park in central London. Sir Paul McCartney and U2 were part of a star-studded line up that took to the stage back in 2005 with a simple message to world leaders: "Make Poverty History."
Thousands of people wore white wristbands to show their support for the campaign.Thousands of people wore white wristbands to show their support for the campaign.
The immediate aim of the Live 8 concerts in London and elsewhere was to send a message to a summit that was about to take place in the UK.The immediate aim of the Live 8 concerts in London and elsewhere was to send a message to a summit that was about to take place in the UK.
It was the G8 Summit at Gleneagles in Scotland and the host, the British prime minister Tony Blair, had debt relief and aid on the agenda It was the G8 Summit at Gleneagles in Scotland and the host, the British Prime Minister Tony Blair, had debt relief and aid on the agenda
The group agreed to call for full cancellation of the debts owed by these countries to the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank and the African Development Bank, a move approved by the full membership of the two organisations later that year.The group agreed to call for full cancellation of the debts owed by these countries to the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank and the African Development Bank, a move approved by the full membership of the two organisations later that year.
It built on a scheme first launched back in 1996, "with the aim of ensuring that no poor country faces a debt burden it cannot manage".It built on a scheme first launched back in 1996, "with the aim of ensuring that no poor country faces a debt burden it cannot manage".
The point of the exercise was to free resources for countries to spend on reducing poverty.The point of the exercise was to free resources for countries to spend on reducing poverty.
In addition, there was a commitment at Gleneagles to increase development aid (compared with the 2004 level) by $50bn a year, with half of that amount to go to Africa. The target date for the increase was 2010.In addition, there was a commitment at Gleneagles to increase development aid (compared with the 2004 level) by $50bn a year, with half of that amount to go to Africa. The target date for the increase was 2010.
Did they deliver?Did they deliver?
Partly. A total of 36 countries have gone through the debt relief process and the sums of money involved are substantial.Partly. A total of 36 countries have gone through the debt relief process and the sums of money involved are substantial.
As of last December, the IMF estimated the total cost to creditors giving the relief as $116bn. More than half the total was accounted for by international agencies, especially the World Bank.As of last December, the IMF estimated the total cost to creditors giving the relief as $116bn. More than half the total was accounted for by international agencies, especially the World Bank.
There have also been contributions to the debt relief from aid donor countries and some from commercial creditors.There have also been contributions to the debt relief from aid donor countries and some from commercial creditors.
On aid there was an increase, but according to Oxfam it fell short of the full commitment: "the G8's collective $50bn promise was missed by around $20bn".On aid there was an increase, but according to Oxfam it fell short of the full commitment: "the G8's collective $50bn promise was missed by around $20bn".
The global financial crisis got in the way. It put new pressure on aid donor government budgets and aid did suffer, according to Eric LeCompte of the debt and development campaign network Jubilee USA.The global financial crisis got in the way. It put new pressure on aid donor government budgets and aid did suffer, according to Eric LeCompte of the debt and development campaign network Jubilee USA.
Did the process work?Did the process work?
It's certainly true that on many indicators, the developing world and Africa in particular are in much better shape than they were. The most recent progress report on the Millennium Development Goals showed progress in most areas, though Africa is expected to fall short.It's certainly true that on many indicators, the developing world and Africa in particular are in much better shape than they were. The most recent progress report on the Millennium Development Goals showed progress in most areas, though Africa is expected to fall short.
The figures - for 2010 - showed that for the world as a whole the target for halving the proportion in extreme poverty had been achieved ahead of schedule. That's not the case for Sub-Saharan Africa, although the rate was down from 56% in 1990 to 48%.The figures - for 2010 - showed that for the world as a whole the target for halving the proportion in extreme poverty had been achieved ahead of schedule. That's not the case for Sub-Saharan Africa, although the rate was down from 56% in 1990 to 48%.
There has also been an improvement in economic growth. In the 25 years before the 2005 Gleneagles summit, the average annual rate was 4.1% for the developing world as a whole and 3.2% for sub-Saharan Africa.There has also been an improvement in economic growth. In the 25 years before the 2005 Gleneagles summit, the average annual rate was 4.1% for the developing world as a whole and 3.2% for sub-Saharan Africa.
In the subsequent 10 years the corresponding figures were 5.8% and 5.5%, and those are annual figures - relatively small increases each year make a big difference if they are sustained.In the subsequent 10 years the corresponding figures were 5.8% and 5.5%, and those are annual figures - relatively small increases each year make a big difference if they are sustained.
Can the Gleneagles commitments take the credit for these improvements?Can the Gleneagles commitments take the credit for these improvements?
Tracking the changesTracking the changes
These charts shows how spending on programmes that alleviate poverty, such as health and basic education has increased - as a share of national income - in countries receiving debt relief, at the same time as the burden of spending on debt payments has eased.These charts shows how spending on programmes that alleviate poverty, such as health and basic education has increased - as a share of national income - in countries receiving debt relief, at the same time as the burden of spending on debt payments has eased.
According to Eric LeCompte, Gleneagles does account for part of the improvements that have occurred in Africa and the developing world.According to Eric LeCompte, Gleneagles does account for part of the improvements that have occurred in Africa and the developing world.
"It's because of [debt relief] that more than 50 million kids went to school in Africa who never would have seen the inside of a classroom if it wasn't for those debt relief initiatives.""It's because of [debt relief] that more than 50 million kids went to school in Africa who never would have seen the inside of a classroom if it wasn't for those debt relief initiatives."
Matthew Martin, director of Development Finance International, a group which gives advice to developing country governments says Gleneagles "in some degree, paved the way for all the 'Africa rising' narrative and all the successes we have seen over the last five to 10 years".Matthew Martin, director of Development Finance International, a group which gives advice to developing country governments says Gleneagles "in some degree, paved the way for all the 'Africa rising' narrative and all the successes we have seen over the last five to 10 years".
Renewed debt riskRenewed debt risk
It is certainly not the whole story. Many of the improvements in developing countries, Africa included, were already under way before Gleneagles.It is certainly not the whole story. Many of the improvements in developing countries, Africa included, were already under way before Gleneagles.
China's rise was an important factor. It has increasingly been a source of investment money in the developing countries and it's a major buyer of the commodities they sell. That helped push up the prices of those goods. And many commentators say there has been a very important contribution from the efforts of the countries themselves - citizens, private sectors and governments.China's rise was an important factor. It has increasingly been a source of investment money in the developing countries and it's a major buyer of the commodities they sell. That helped push up the prices of those goods. And many commentators say there has been a very important contribution from the efforts of the countries themselves - citizens, private sectors and governments.
So Gleneagles didn't do it on its own, and nor is it seen as a complete or permanent solution to the problems of Africa and the developing world.So Gleneagles didn't do it on its own, and nor is it seen as a complete or permanent solution to the problems of Africa and the developing world.
Eric LeCompte says 26 of the countries that went through the debt relief process are now at high or moderate risk of "debt distress" - not being able to meet their financial obligations.Eric LeCompte says 26 of the countries that went through the debt relief process are now at high or moderate risk of "debt distress" - not being able to meet their financial obligations.
"A lot of those countries are now in need of some kind of solution again," he says."A lot of those countries are now in need of some kind of solution again," he says.
Ghana is a case in point.Ghana is a case in point.
For countries with high levels of spending on debt and also defence, research by Oxfam and Development Finance International found:For countries with high levels of spending on debt and also defence, research by Oxfam and Development Finance International found:
"Spending on these areas is clearly crowding out spending on Millennium Development Goal sectors in a considerable number of countries.""Spending on these areas is clearly crowding out spending on Millennium Development Goal sectors in a considerable number of countries."
Among the most striking examples the report identified were countries that didn't get debt relief, sometimes because they were not poor enough to qualify. Sri Lanka and Jordan were spending two-thirds of their government budgets on servicing their debts.Among the most striking examples the report identified were countries that didn't get debt relief, sometimes because they were not poor enough to qualify. Sri Lanka and Jordan were spending two-thirds of their government budgets on servicing their debts.
There were also important areas which, Matthew Martin says, Gleneagles didn't touch at all - notably tax. He argues that it's too easy for wealthy people in developing countries and multinational companies to avoid paying tax to those nations.There were also important areas which, Matthew Martin says, Gleneagles didn't touch at all - notably tax. He argues that it's too easy for wealthy people in developing countries and multinational companies to avoid paying tax to those nations.
He says they need the rich world to agree much more fundamental reform of global tax rules, to provide enough revenue to achieve development goals that have been set for after the MDGs.He says they need the rich world to agree much more fundamental reform of global tax rules, to provide enough revenue to achieve development goals that have been set for after the MDGs.
Ten years on from Gleneagles, there is a credible case to be made that it has achieved something. But there are persistent calls for more action on debt, on aid and a wider agenda to promote development in the world's poorer nations.Ten years on from Gleneagles, there is a credible case to be made that it has achieved something. But there are persistent calls for more action on debt, on aid and a wider agenda to promote development in the world's poorer nations.