This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-33506841
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Harsh Greece deal leaves European vision tainted | Harsh Greece deal leaves European vision tainted |
(35 minutes later) | |
Athens has been offered a third bail-out. Bankruptcy, the spectre of a failed state, has been avoided, and Greece will stay inside the euro. | Athens has been offered a third bail-out. Bankruptcy, the spectre of a failed state, has been avoided, and Greece will stay inside the euro. |
But the deal, hammered out over 17 hours, has left many Greeks humiliated. | But the deal, hammered out over 17 hours, has left many Greeks humiliated. |
It is not just the ranks of the left that are using the word "surrender". | It is not just the ranks of the left that are using the word "surrender". |
Europe has avoided the worst crisis in the EU's history. | Europe has avoided the worst crisis in the EU's history. |
"The European project was on a knife edge," said one of its leaders. Its reputation, however, has been damaged. | "The European project was on a knife edge," said one of its leaders. Its reputation, however, has been damaged. |
It has shown solidarity with Greece, but divisions have been exposed and it was prepared to see the departure of one of its member states from the single currency. | It has shown solidarity with Greece, but divisions have been exposed and it was prepared to see the departure of one of its member states from the single currency. |
It struck a deal but only by making Greece accept conditions the majority of Greeks are likely to find unacceptable. | It struck a deal but only by making Greece accept conditions the majority of Greeks are likely to find unacceptable. |
The Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras will return to Greece. | The Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras will return to Greece. |
There will be no celebrations, just a weary sigh of relief the uncertainty, for the time being, is over. | There will be no celebrations, just a weary sigh of relief the uncertainty, for the time being, is over. |
Many people were scared Greece outside the euro would descend into bankruptcy and chaos. | Many people were scared Greece outside the euro would descend into bankruptcy and chaos. |
Bruising process | Bruising process |
Greece, said Mr Tsipras, had fought a tough battle and now faced difficult decisions. | Greece, said Mr Tsipras, had fought a tough battle and now faced difficult decisions. |
He will have to rush key measures on pension reforms, tax increases and a debt repayment fund through parliament in 48 hours. It will be a bruising process. | |
Only then will bridging loans be released that will enable Greece to meet a payment to the European Central Bank next Monday. | Only then will bridging loans be released that will enable Greece to meet a payment to the European Central Bank next Monday. |
In the election campaign in January, I heard Mr Tsipras tell an ecstatic crowd that tomorrow would mark the beginning of the end of austerity. Tomorrow never came. | In the election campaign in January, I heard Mr Tsipras tell an ecstatic crowd that tomorrow would mark the beginning of the end of austerity. Tomorrow never came. |
Greece remains a laboratory of austerity - with the country back into recession. | Greece remains a laboratory of austerity - with the country back into recession. |
The long months of negotiation have ended with Greece's debt on the agenda. | The long months of negotiation have ended with Greece's debt on the agenda. |
Mr Tsipras said: "We managed to win debt restructuring." | Mr Tsipras said: "We managed to win debt restructuring." |
But French President Francois Hollande perhaps put it more accurately when he said: "There will be a profiling of Greek debt by extending the maturities." | But French President Francois Hollande perhaps put it more accurately when he said: "There will be a profiling of Greek debt by extending the maturities." |
Germany has been shown to be unbending - it was prepared to see Greece removed from the single currency. | Germany has been shown to be unbending - it was prepared to see Greece removed from the single currency. |
It clearly did not trust Mr Tsipras and would have preferred to see him out of office and replaced by a technocratic government. | It clearly did not trust Mr Tsipras and would have preferred to see him out of office and replaced by a technocratic government. |
Snap election | Snap election |
It is a lesson for other countries that the eurozone wanted to reshape the Greek government even though it was democratically elected. | It is a lesson for other countries that the eurozone wanted to reshape the Greek government even though it was democratically elected. |
As it is, the deal will almost certainly lead to snap elections. | As it is, the deal will almost certainly lead to snap elections. |
Mr Tsipras will reshuffle his cabinet and discard those cabinet ministers who opposed his latest proposal. | Mr Tsipras will reshuffle his cabinet and discard those cabinet ministers who opposed his latest proposal. |
There may not be a national unity government - but he will be dependent on opposition parties who will have an eye on the elections. | There may not be a national unity government - but he will be dependent on opposition parties who will have an eye on the elections. |
Mr Tsipras may win an election, but a portion of the electorate will be unforgiving towards a leader who asked them to vote against more austerity but then signed up for even tougher measures. | Mr Tsipras may win an election, but a portion of the electorate will be unforgiving towards a leader who asked them to vote against more austerity but then signed up for even tougher measures. |
Nothing, perhaps, underlined the weakness of his hand as much as when he relented and accepted the International Monetary Fund (IMF) would stay involved in monitoring Greece's actions. | Nothing, perhaps, underlined the weakness of his hand as much as when he relented and accepted the International Monetary Fund (IMF) would stay involved in monitoring Greece's actions. |
For Europe, the single currency has changed. | For Europe, the single currency has changed. |
It used to be said it was "irreversible". That is no longer the case. | It used to be said it was "irreversible". That is no longer the case. |
On the table at the summit was a document which contained the words "in case no agreement could be reached, Greece should be offered swift negotiations on a time-out from the euro area, with possible debt restructuring". | On the table at the summit was a document which contained the words "in case no agreement could be reached, Greece should be offered swift negotiations on a time-out from the euro area, with possible debt restructuring". |
European divisions | European divisions |
Economic and monetary union now looks more like a group of countries with a fixed exchange rate system. | Economic and monetary union now looks more like a group of countries with a fixed exchange rate system. |
The crisis has exposed Europe's divisions. Already, leaders are claiming the Franco-German engine is purring smoothly. | The crisis has exposed Europe's divisions. Already, leaders are claiming the Franco-German engine is purring smoothly. |
Paris and Berlin ended up on the same side, but there were real tensions. | Paris and Berlin ended up on the same side, but there were real tensions. |
Chancellor Angela Merkel was furious to discover French technical experts had been advising the Greeks on their final proposal. | Chancellor Angela Merkel was furious to discover French technical experts had been advising the Greeks on their final proposal. |
Germany was ready to see Greece leave the euro. France was not. | Germany was ready to see Greece leave the euro. France was not. |
There is now a fault-line in Europe. On one side are Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, Slovakia, Belgium, Finland, Latvia and Lithuania. | There is now a fault-line in Europe. On one side are Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, Slovakia, Belgium, Finland, Latvia and Lithuania. |
They were prepared to see Greece leave the euro. | They were prepared to see Greece leave the euro. |
On the other side are France, Italy, Spain and others clinging to their idea of a Europe of solidarity. | On the other side are France, Italy, Spain and others clinging to their idea of a Europe of solidarity. |
For the Germans - whose parliament must meet this week to authorise Mrs Merkel to open talks on a new loan - the union is about sticking to rules and offering help only in exchange for conditions. | For the Germans - whose parliament must meet this week to authorise Mrs Merkel to open talks on a new loan - the union is about sticking to rules and offering help only in exchange for conditions. |
Hard road | Hard road |
So will the deal work? If the negotiations succeed, Greece will receive a third bailout and, for a period, it will be off the critical list. | So will the deal work? If the negotiations succeed, Greece will receive a third bailout and, for a period, it will be off the critical list. |
The country is almost certainly back in recession and yet having to accept structural reforms and tax increases - a policy that has failed in the past. Capital controls will stay in place for several months. | The country is almost certainly back in recession and yet having to accept structural reforms and tax increases - a policy that has failed in the past. Capital controls will stay in place for several months. |
It will be a long, hard road back to growth. | It will be a long, hard road back to growth. |
The facts remain. Greece has €320bn in debt. Its debt to gross domestic product ratio is above 180%. | The facts remain. Greece has €320bn in debt. Its debt to gross domestic product ratio is above 180%. |
What is missing is the means by which Greece will return to growth. | What is missing is the means by which Greece will return to growth. |
The deal brings to an end a long period of pretending. | The deal brings to an end a long period of pretending. |
The figures used for Greece to join the single currency were massaged. In 2009, their accounts were proved to be as good as fakes. | The figures used for Greece to join the single currency were massaged. In 2009, their accounts were proved to be as good as fakes. |
Reforms were never fully implemented. Paying taxes was a lifestyle choice. | Reforms were never fully implemented. Paying taxes was a lifestyle choice. |
Many middle-class and wealthy Greeks have their funds in London. | Many middle-class and wealthy Greeks have their funds in London. |
The best and the brightest are queuing up to move to Australia and Canada. | The best and the brightest are queuing up to move to Australia and Canada. |
As for Europe, it has presided over the economic collapse of a member state. Greece's economy has shrunk 25% in just five years. | As for Europe, it has presided over the economic collapse of a member state. Greece's economy has shrunk 25% in just five years. |
The Germans and others will argue they loaned Greece €240bn. | The Germans and others will argue they loaned Greece €240bn. |
But it was an experiment. Even the IMF conceded it had miscalculated the effects of austerity. | But it was an experiment. Even the IMF conceded it had miscalculated the effects of austerity. |
Political union | Political union |
What will Europe do now? When the dust has settled, it will convince many Europe must move beyond economic and monetary union and embrace fiscal union. | What will Europe do now? When the dust has settled, it will convince many Europe must move beyond economic and monetary union and embrace fiscal union. |
That will require another step towards political union. | That will require another step towards political union. |
Eventually, there will have to be a common treasury and shared debt. | Eventually, there will have to be a common treasury and shared debt. |
But the Germans will ensure even with deeper integration, the European Union will not become a transfer union with funds flowing from north to south. | But the Germans will ensure even with deeper integration, the European Union will not become a transfer union with funds flowing from north to south. |
With the Greek crisis, the European project has lost some of its vision, its idealism, its hope. | With the Greek crisis, the European project has lost some of its vision, its idealism, its hope. |
It is a project in need of revival. | It is a project in need of revival. |
Previous version
1
Next version