This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/media/live/2015/jul/16/bbc-future-set-out-in-government-green-paper-live-updates
The article has changed 10 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 6 | Version 7 |
|---|---|
| Tories announce biggest overhaul of BBC in a decade - live updates | Tories announce biggest overhaul of BBC in a decade - live updates |
| (5 months later) | |
| 2.12pm BST | |
| 14:12 | |
| Here’s a summary of the BBC review and reaction to it. | Here’s a summary of the BBC review and reaction to it. |
| That’s it for the live blog, there will be much more on the Guardian’s BBC section. | That’s it for the live blog, there will be much more on the Guardian’s BBC section. |
| Updated | |
| at 2.15pm BST | |
| 1.55pm BST | |
| 13:55 | |
| Jasper Jackson picks out the three options for the licence fee outlined in the paper. | Jasper Jackson picks out the three options for the licence fee outlined in the paper. |
| Licence fee options in green paper are: Reformed licence fee, universal household levy or public funding and subscription mix. | Licence fee options in green paper are: Reformed licence fee, universal household levy or public funding and subscription mix. |
| Reading over green paper, it seems last week's licence fee deal wasn’t end of story. Fee could be replaced w/ household levy at lower rate | Reading over green paper, it seems last week's licence fee deal wasn’t end of story. Fee could be replaced w/ household levy at lower rate |
| 1.47pm BST | |
| 13:47 | |
| Key points | Key points |
| The charter review will explore four areas of possible change: | The charter review will explore four areas of possible change: |
| With this in aim, Whittingdale announced the following plans: | With this in aim, Whittingdale announced the following plans: |
| 1.45pm BST | |
| 13:45 | |
| Here’s some initial reaction from media analysts. | Here’s some initial reaction from media analysts. |
| 'What size should the BBC be?' Try 'how many sweets are in this jar?' . | 'What size should the BBC be?' Try 'how many sweets are in this jar?' . |
| What do we want the BBC to do? That is the right question. https://t.co/AWYS4hO7or | What do we want the BBC to do? That is the right question. https://t.co/AWYS4hO7or |
| Ratings chasing perhaps the silliest BBC criticism. Imagine being put in charge of an organisation and told: 'Do well, but not too well'. | Ratings chasing perhaps the silliest BBC criticism. Imagine being put in charge of an organisation and told: 'Do well, but not too well'. |
| Updated | |
| at 1.52pm BST | |
| 1.36pm BST | |
| 13:36 | |
| Privatising BBC Worldwide? | Privatising BBC Worldwide? |
| Jasper Jackson | Jasper Jackson |
| The green paper appears to confirm plans to look at privatising BBC Worldwide. | The green paper appears to confirm plans to look at privatising BBC Worldwide. |
| Charter Review will consider the full range of options for reforming the BBC’s commercial operations, including full or part privatisation of Worldwide. | Charter Review will consider the full range of options for reforming the BBC’s commercial operations, including full or part privatisation of Worldwide. |
| Updated | |
| at 1.45pm BST | |
| 1.34pm BST | |
| 13:34 | |
| The BBC has welcomed the conclusions of the Perry review that licence fee evasion should remain criminalised. | The BBC has welcomed the conclusions of the Perry review that licence fee evasion should remain criminalised. |
| Statement in response to findings of the Perry Review into licence fee enforcement http://t.co/nDDjKEFopO pic.twitter.com/5egDLlOkEl | Statement in response to findings of the Perry Review into licence fee enforcement http://t.co/nDDjKEFopO pic.twitter.com/5egDLlOkEl |
| Updated | |
| at 1.54pm BST | |
| 1.30pm BST | |
| 13:30 | |
| Rona Fairhead, chair of the BBC Trust, called for a wide ranging debate about the future of the BBC. In her response she says: | Rona Fairhead, chair of the BBC Trust, called for a wide ranging debate about the future of the BBC. In her response she says: |
| “The green paper recognises the enormous contribution that the BBC makes to the UK, and all the trust’s analysis and audience feedback over the past eight years has underlined the value that it brings to people across the country. | “The green paper recognises the enormous contribution that the BBC makes to the UK, and all the trust’s analysis and audience feedback over the past eight years has underlined the value that it brings to people across the country. |
| “Of course there are also big questions to ask about the future of the BBC, but the debate must not be a narrow one and the clearest voice in it must that of the public. We will carry out our own research and consultation to make sure of that, and we welcome the government’s statement that they will work with us and will take full account of our findings.” | “Of course there are also big questions to ask about the future of the BBC, but the debate must not be a narrow one and the clearest voice in it must that of the public. We will carry out our own research and consultation to make sure of that, and we welcome the government’s statement that they will work with us and will take full account of our findings.” |
| Rona Fairhead, Chairman responds to @DCMS and @JWhittingdale Green Paper on future of BBC: http://t.co/LjVHso6Hsr pic.twitter.com/q6jogNk3S6 | Rona Fairhead, Chairman responds to @DCMS and @JWhittingdale Green Paper on future of BBC: http://t.co/LjVHso6Hsr pic.twitter.com/q6jogNk3S6 |
| Updated | |
| at 1.34pm BST | |
| 1.26pm BST | |
| 13:26 | |
| Whittingdale criticised a Sunday Times story about the proposals. Its political editor Tim Shipman takes umbrage. | Whittingdale criticised a Sunday Times story about the proposals. Its political editor Tim Shipman takes umbrage. |
| Whittingdale appears to have confirmed every single fact in my BBC splash on Sunday. Yet he's slagging it off. Brave under the circumstances | Whittingdale appears to have confirmed every single fact in my BBC splash on Sunday. Yet he's slagging it off. Brave under the circumstances |
| Updated | |
| at 1.26pm BST | |
| 1.23pm BST | |
| 13:23 | |
| The DCMS invites the public to express its views on the review. | The DCMS invites the public to express its views on the review. |
| You can have your say in the BBC Charter Review public consultation at http://t.co/a0shDMOloV #yourBBC pic.twitter.com/eQbYLEAPuZ | You can have your say in the BBC Charter Review public consultation at http://t.co/a0shDMOloV #yourBBC pic.twitter.com/eQbYLEAPuZ |
| 1.17pm BST | |
| 13:17 | |
| Jasper Jackson | Jasper Jackson |
| Jasper Jackson picks out another key passage in the green paper. | Jasper Jackson picks out another key passage in the green paper. |
| Given the vast choice that audiences now have there is an argument that the BBC might become more focused on a narrower, core set of services that can continue to meet its mission and objectives. A smaller BBC could see the public pay less for their TV licence and would also be likely to have a reduced market impact. | Given the vast choice that audiences now have there is an argument that the BBC might become more focused on a narrower, core set of services that can continue to meet its mission and objectives. A smaller BBC could see the public pay less for their TV licence and would also be likely to have a reduced market impact. |
| 1.14pm BST | |
| 13:14 | |
| John Plunkett | John Plunkett |
| Culture secretary John Whittingdale announced a fundamental review of the size of the BBC, what it does and the way it is funded and questioned whether the BBC should continue to strive to be “all things to all people”, writes John Plunkett in a first take on the plans. | Culture secretary John Whittingdale announced a fundamental review of the size of the BBC, what it does and the way it is funded and questioned whether the BBC should continue to strive to be “all things to all people”, writes John Plunkett in a first take on the plans. |
| Unveiling the government’s green paper on the future of the BBC on Thursday, Whittingdale said the scale and scope of the BBC had grown exponentially in the last decade and said the time was right to question “whether this particular range of services best serves licence fee payers”. | Unveiling the government’s green paper on the future of the BBC on Thursday, Whittingdale said the scale and scope of the BBC had grown exponentially in the last decade and said the time was right to question “whether this particular range of services best serves licence fee payers”. |
| He said an independent report into decriminalisation of non-payment of the licence fee - which the BBC has said would cost it £200m - had concluded it would not be appropriate under the current funding model. | He said an independent report into decriminalisation of non-payment of the licence fee - which the BBC has said would cost it £200m - had concluded it would not be appropriate under the current funding model. |
| On the BBC’s funding, he said there was “no easy solution” to how the BBC should be funded but described the current licence fee model as “regressive”. | On the BBC’s funding, he said there was “no easy solution” to how the BBC should be funded but described the current licence fee model as “regressive”. |
| He said subscription maybe an option in the longer term, but before then outlined three options - a reformed licence fee, a household levy, or a hybrid funding model. In the longer term he said they should consider a subscription model. | He said subscription maybe an option in the longer term, but before then outlined three options - a reformed licence fee, a household levy, or a hybrid funding model. In the longer term he said they should consider a subscription model. |
| The green paper will look at four key areas - the overall purpose of the BBC, what services and content it should provide, how the BBC should be funded and how it should be governed and regulated. | The green paper will look at four key areas - the overall purpose of the BBC, what services and content it should provide, how the BBC should be funded and how it should be governed and regulated. |
| “One key task is to assess whether the idea of universality still holds water. With so much more choice, we must at least question whether the BBC should try to be all things to all people,” said Whittingdale. | “One key task is to assess whether the idea of universality still holds water. With so much more choice, we must at least question whether the BBC should try to be all things to all people,” said Whittingdale. |
| With the BBC Trust widely expected to be axed, Whittingdale said the BBC’s governance would be reviewed after the BBC had on occasions “fallen well short of the standards expected of it” including the Savile crisis, the £100m Digital Media Initiative fiasco, and the multi-million payouts to former staff. | With the BBC Trust widely expected to be axed, Whittingdale said the BBC’s governance would be reviewed after the BBC had on occasions “fallen well short of the standards expected of it” including the Savile crisis, the £100m Digital Media Initiative fiasco, and the multi-million payouts to former staff. |
| He said there were concerns about how the BBC’s activities impacted on its commercial rivals, and there were “particular challenges” around how the corporation reached ethnic minorities and younger people. | He said there were concerns about how the BBC’s activities impacted on its commercial rivals, and there were “particular challenges” around how the corporation reached ethnic minorities and younger people. |
| 1.11pm BST | |
| 13:11 | |
| David Perry QC’s review into whether to decriminalise non-payment of the TV licence has found that the current system of criminal enforcement should be maintained. | David Perry QC’s review into whether to decriminalise non-payment of the TV licence has found that the current system of criminal enforcement should be maintained. |
| Announcing his findings, Perry said: | Announcing his findings, Perry said: |
| Following a detailed assessment of the various policy options the review has concluded that there should be no fundamental change in the sanctions regime as it applies to the current licence fee collection system. The current regime represents a broadly fair and proportionate response to the problem of licence fee evasion and provides good value for money both for licence fee payers and taxpayers. | Following a detailed assessment of the various policy options the review has concluded that there should be no fundamental change in the sanctions regime as it applies to the current licence fee collection system. The current regime represents a broadly fair and proportionate response to the problem of licence fee evasion and provides good value for money both for licence fee payers and taxpayers. |
| This Review has taken place shortly in advance of an in-depth review of the BBC’s royal charter. Any change to the method of licence fee collection is likely to have an impact on the viability of introducing a non-criminal scheme of enforcement. It is to be hoped that the recommendations and observations made in this report will be of assistance to those involved in the charter review. | This Review has taken place shortly in advance of an in-depth review of the BBC’s royal charter. Any change to the method of licence fee collection is likely to have an impact on the viability of introducing a non-criminal scheme of enforcement. It is to be hoped that the recommendations and observations made in this report will be of assistance to those involved in the charter review. |
| Updated | |
| at 1.38pm BST | |
| 1.08pm BST | |
| 13:08 | |
| BBC response | BBC response |
| The BBC says the Green Paper would “appear to herald a much diminished, less popular, BBC.” In its response it said: | The BBC says the Green Paper would “appear to herald a much diminished, less popular, BBC.” In its response it said: |
| The BBC is a creative and economic powerhouse for Britain. The starting point for any debate should be - how can a strong BBC benefit Britain even more at home and abroad? The BBC has embraced change in the past and will continue to do so in the future, and we will set out our own proposals in September. | The BBC is a creative and economic powerhouse for Britain. The starting point for any debate should be - how can a strong BBC benefit Britain even more at home and abroad? The BBC has embraced change in the past and will continue to do so in the future, and we will set out our own proposals in September. |
| We believe that this green paper would appear to herald a much diminished, less popular, BBC. That would be bad for Britain and would not be the BBC that the public has known and loved for over 90 years. | We believe that this green paper would appear to herald a much diminished, less popular, BBC. That would be bad for Britain and would not be the BBC that the public has known and loved for over 90 years. |
| It is important that we hear what the public want. It should be for the public to decide whether programmes like Strictly or Bake Off, or stations like Radio 1 or 2, should continue. | It is important that we hear what the public want. It should be for the public to decide whether programmes like Strictly or Bake Off, or stations like Radio 1 or 2, should continue. |
| As the director general said on Tuesday, the BBC is not owned by its staff or by politicians, it is owned by the public. They are our shareholders. They pay the licence fee. Their voice should be heard the loudest. | As the director general said on Tuesday, the BBC is not owned by its staff or by politicians, it is owned by the public. They are our shareholders. They pay the licence fee. Their voice should be heard the loudest. |
| Statement in response to Government Green Paper on the future of the BBC http://t.co/KkNAOnv2Fc pic.twitter.com/rnZVVJy5nn | Statement in response to Government Green Paper on the future of the BBC http://t.co/KkNAOnv2Fc pic.twitter.com/rnZVVJy5nn |
| Updated | |
| at 1.38pm BST | |
| 1.03pm BST | |
| 13:03 | |
| Is the BBC providing sufficiently distinctive content? the review asks in a key passage. It says: | Is the BBC providing sufficiently distinctive content? the review asks in a key passage. It says: |
| This does not mean that the BBC should not be entertaining; it is about the BBC providing distinctive programming across all genre types. For example, the BBC acquired the format for The Voice. This was a singing talent show developed overseas, bought by the BBC at a reported cost of around £20 million64 and similar to ITV’s X-Factor. This is in contrast to Strictly Come Dancing which was developed by the BBC in-house and then sold abroad. | This does not mean that the BBC should not be entertaining; it is about the BBC providing distinctive programming across all genre types. For example, the BBC acquired the format for The Voice. This was a singing talent show developed overseas, bought by the BBC at a reported cost of around £20 million64 and similar to ITV’s X-Factor. This is in contrast to Strictly Come Dancing which was developed by the BBC in-house and then sold abroad. |
| The BBC has faced similar questions about distinctiveness of its radio content, particularly in relation to its music stations in peak hours. In its recent report on BBC Radio 1, perhaps the BBC’s most ‘mainstream’ radio service, the BBC Trust found that the overlap of music played on Radio 1 with five comparator commercial stations was low, at around one third of its output. | The BBC has faced similar questions about distinctiveness of its radio content, particularly in relation to its music stations in peak hours. In its recent report on BBC Radio 1, perhaps the BBC’s most ‘mainstream’ radio service, the BBC Trust found that the overlap of music played on Radio 1 with five comparator commercial stations was low, at around one third of its output. |
| Similarly, questions have been raised about whether content carried on the BBC’s website is sufficiently distinctive from content that can and is being developed and delivered by others. | Similarly, questions have been raised about whether content carried on the BBC’s website is sufficiently distinctive from content that can and is being developed and delivered by others. |
| The growth of the internet as a medium for consuming information is one of the most notable developments over the current Charter period; in this context the challenge for the BBC will be in setting itself apart from others in the online space and potentially seeking to avoid providing services such as, for example, recipes where a range of other websites already do so. | The growth of the internet as a medium for consuming information is one of the most notable developments over the current Charter period; in this context the challenge for the BBC will be in setting itself apart from others in the online space and potentially seeking to avoid providing services such as, for example, recipes where a range of other websites already do so. |
| The BBC, as a public institution, should not have the same imperatives as commercial companies such as trying to maximise audience share. However, given the difficulty in measuring quality in an objective way, figures such as | The BBC, as a public institution, should not have the same imperatives as commercial companies such as trying to maximise audience share. However, given the difficulty in measuring quality in an objective way, figures such as |
| ratings can be given undue prominence by senior management. The question is, therefore, how to measure the success of programming when much depends on the BBC’s ability to deliver its public purposes through its content, and how to make sure the culture of the BBC is focused on quality and distinctiveness rather than driven by ratings. | ratings can be given undue prominence by senior management. The question is, therefore, how to measure the success of programming when much depends on the BBC’s ability to deliver its public purposes through its content, and how to make sure the culture of the BBC is focused on quality and distinctiveness rather than driven by ratings. |
| 12.59pm BST | |
| 12:59 | |
| Full text of charter review | Full text of charter review |
| Here’s the full text of the charter review. | Here’s the full text of the charter review. |
| 12.57pm BST | |
| 12:57 | |
| The DCMS has published this summary of the green paper: | The DCMS has published this summary of the green paper: |
| It quotes Whittingdale saying: | It quotes Whittingdale saying: |
| The BBC is at the very heart of Britain. It is one of this nation’s most treasured institutions - playing a role in almost all of our lives. Ten years ago, the last time the Government ran a Charter Review, the media landscape looked very different. The BBC has adapted to this changing landscape, and remains much-loved by audiences, a valuable engine of growth and an international benchmark for television, radio, online and journalism. | The BBC is at the very heart of Britain. It is one of this nation’s most treasured institutions - playing a role in almost all of our lives. Ten years ago, the last time the Government ran a Charter Review, the media landscape looked very different. The BBC has adapted to this changing landscape, and remains much-loved by audiences, a valuable engine of growth and an international benchmark for television, radio, online and journalism. |
| However we need to ask some hard questions during this Charter Review. Questions about what the BBC should be trying to achieve in an age where consumer choice is now far more extensive than it has been, what its scale and scope should be in the light of those aims, how far it affects others in television, radio and online, and what the right structures are for its governance and regulation. | However we need to ask some hard questions during this Charter Review. Questions about what the BBC should be trying to achieve in an age where consumer choice is now far more extensive than it has been, what its scale and scope should be in the light of those aims, how far it affects others in television, radio and online, and what the right structures are for its governance and regulation. |
| The BBC is a national institution, paid for by the public. It will have spent more than £30 billion of public money over the current Charter period. Everyone must be able to have their say on how well they think that money is spent. This consultation gives them that opportunity. It also invites them to comment on how the BBC is governed. | The BBC is a national institution, paid for by the public. It will have spent more than £30 billion of public money over the current Charter period. Everyone must be able to have their say on how well they think that money is spent. This consultation gives them that opportunity. It also invites them to comment on how the BBC is governed. |
| This publication is an important first step in an open and thorough Charter Review. It sets out the issues and some of the options for change. I want it to stimulate a national debate over the coming months as we map out the future for our BBC. | This publication is an important first step in an open and thorough Charter Review. It sets out the issues and some of the options for change. I want it to stimulate a national debate over the coming months as we map out the future for our BBC. |
| The consultation sets out four broad issues for public discussion, it says: | The consultation sets out four broad issues for public discussion, it says: |
| BBC’s mission, purpose and values | BBC’s mission, purpose and values |
| The BBC currently has six public purposes that were set out at the last Charter Review in 2006: | The BBC currently has six public purposes that were set out at the last Charter Review in 2006: |
| All of the BBC’s activity should be working towards one or more of these. The consultation paper looks at whether these purposes are still relevant, and in the context of recent challenges the organisation has faced, if there should be more direction set about how the BBC works by defining its values in the next Charter. | All of the BBC’s activity should be working towards one or more of these. The consultation paper looks at whether these purposes are still relevant, and in the context of recent challenges the organisation has faced, if there should be more direction set about how the BBC works by defining its values in the next Charter. |
| Scale and scope of the BBC’s services and operations | Scale and scope of the BBC’s services and operations |
| Twenty years ago the BBC had two television channels and five national radio stations. It is now the largest public service broadcaster in the world, with nine television channels, ten national radio stations, and a major online presence. The consultation paper looks at whether this particular range of services best serves licence fee payers and the impact it has on the commercial sector given the current and future media environment. | Twenty years ago the BBC had two television channels and five national radio stations. It is now the largest public service broadcaster in the world, with nine television channels, ten national radio stations, and a major online presence. The consultation paper looks at whether this particular range of services best serves licence fee payers and the impact it has on the commercial sector given the current and future media environment. |
| The way in which the BBC is funded | The way in which the BBC is funded |
| The BBC is currently funded via the TV licence fee, which has proven to be a very resilient form of funding – bringing in £3.7 billion last year. However it is not without its challenges - for example it is regressive, set at a flat rate and is not adjusted for different household incomes. It is also true that more people - especially younger people - now access television exclusively online and without a licence. This is perfectly legal, as the existing legislation was drawn up when the iPlayer did not even exist. The Government has already committed to dealing with this problem and the Charter Review will allow us to look at how to modernise the current system. | The BBC is currently funded via the TV licence fee, which has proven to be a very resilient form of funding – bringing in £3.7 billion last year. However it is not without its challenges - for example it is regressive, set at a flat rate and is not adjusted for different household incomes. It is also true that more people - especially younger people - now access television exclusively online and without a licence. This is perfectly legal, as the existing legislation was drawn up when the iPlayer did not even exist. The Government has already committed to dealing with this problem and the Charter Review will allow us to look at how to modernise the current system. |
| BBC’s governance and accountability | BBC’s governance and accountability |
| The BBC Trust – established by the current Charter - exists to represent licence fee payers and hold the BBC to account. At times the BBC has fallen well short of the standards that the public expect of it, such as the Digital Media Initiative, the failed £100m technology project which exposed governance issues at the BBC. There are three broad alternative options - to reform the Trust model, create a unitary board and a new standalone oversight body or move external regulation wholesale to Ofcom. The Government is seeking views on these models and the wider issues of how the BBC’s transparency and accountability can be improved. | The BBC Trust – established by the current Charter - exists to represent licence fee payers and hold the BBC to account. At times the BBC has fallen well short of the standards that the public expect of it, such as the Digital Media Initiative, the failed £100m technology project which exposed governance issues at the BBC. There are three broad alternative options - to reform the Trust model, create a unitary board and a new standalone oversight body or move external regulation wholesale to Ofcom. The Government is seeking views on these models and the wider issues of how the BBC’s transparency and accountability can be improved. |
| Updated | |
| at 1.20pm BST | |
| 12.53pm BST | |
| 12:53 | |
| Responding shadow culture secretary Chris Bryant says the BBC is the cornerstone of Britain’s culture. He says the public wants the BBC to inform, educate and entertain. This is includes broadcasting Strictly and Bake Off. The public want opera and soap opera, Bryant says. | Responding shadow culture secretary Chris Bryant says the BBC is the cornerstone of Britain’s culture. He says the public wants the BBC to inform, educate and entertain. This is includes broadcasting Strictly and Bake Off. The public want opera and soap opera, Bryant says. |
| He asks when the government will close the iPlayer loophole? | He asks when the government will close the iPlayer loophole? |
| 12.50pm BST | |
| 12:50 | |
| The BBC is a source of great pride, we want it to thrive, Whittingdale said in conclusion. | The BBC is a source of great pride, we want it to thrive, Whittingdale said in conclusion. |
| 12.50pm BST | |
| 12:50 | |
| Any organisation as large as the BBC needs effective governance, Whittingdale says. He said weaknesses in governance have contributed to recent failures such as investigations into Jimmy Savile. | Any organisation as large as the BBC needs effective governance, Whittingdale says. He said weaknesses in governance have contributed to recent failures such as investigations into Jimmy Savile. |
| 12.48pm BST | |
| 12:48 | |
| The licence fee is not without is challenges, he says. It is a regressive test. In the long term we should consider a subscription service, Whittingdale says. The fee will increase inline with CPI but this is subject to the charter review. | The licence fee is not without is challenges, he says. It is a regressive test. In the long term we should consider a subscription service, Whittingdale says. The fee will increase inline with CPI but this is subject to the charter review. |
| 12.46pm BST | |
| 12:46 | |
| The charter review will look at how content is produced. It will also look at BBC Worldwide. | The charter review will look at how content is produced. It will also look at BBC Worldwide. |
| 12.44pm BST | |
| 12:44 | |
| What’s the purpose of the BBC? Whittingdale asks. The charter review will look at the “scale and scope” of the BBC, he confirms. Do the range of service best serve the licence fee payers? he asks. | What’s the purpose of the BBC? Whittingdale asks. The charter review will look at the “scale and scope” of the BBC, he confirms. Do the range of service best serve the licence fee payers? he asks. |
| Analysis: this wording is important, and expands the government’s ambitions for reforms, as media editor Jane Martinson explains here: | Analysis: this wording is important, and expands the government’s ambitions for reforms, as media editor Jane Martinson explains here: |
| Related: Government review of BBC could result in U-turn on licence fee agreement | Related: Government review of BBC could result in U-turn on licence fee agreement |
| Updated | |
| at 12.48pm BST | |
| 12.42pm BST | |
| 12:42 | |
| Whittingdale says the BBC sets international standards of quality. It has “pivotal role” in reaching every corner of the world, he says. | Whittingdale says the BBC sets international standards of quality. It has “pivotal role” in reaching every corner of the world, he says. |
| The level of change has in the last decade has be unprecedented, Whittingdale says. | The level of change has in the last decade has be unprecedented, Whittingdale says. |
| We can’t predict the future, he says, but points out that people still enjoy radio and television. | We can’t predict the future, he says, but points out that people still enjoy radio and television. |
| 12.40pm BST | |
| 12:40 | |
| Culture secretary John Whittingdale sets out BBC green paper | Culture secretary John Whittingdale sets out BBC green paper |
| Here we go. Whittingdale has risen to his feet and begins his statement, 39 minutes later than scheduled. | Here we go. Whittingdale has risen to his feet and begins his statement, 39 minutes later than scheduled. |
| Updated | |
| at 12.46pm BST | |
| 12.39pm BST | |
| 12:39 | |
| While we wait for Whittingdale here’s more detail on the BBC’s role in organising that celebrity letter. | While we wait for Whittingdale here’s more detail on the BBC’s role in organising that celebrity letter. |
| Related: BBC organised stars' protest letter to David Cameron | Related: BBC organised stars' protest letter to David Cameron |
| 12.08pm BST | |
| 12:08 | |
| Questions in the Commons about NHS reforms have overrun, so we’re still waiting for Whittingdale’s statement. | Questions in the Commons about NHS reforms have overrun, so we’re still waiting for Whittingdale’s statement. |
| 12.01pm BST | |
| 12:01 | |
| Stanley Pignal from the Economist tweets his thoughts ahead of the green paper. | Stanley Pignal from the Economist tweets his thoughts ahead of the green paper. |
| The BBC is a sprawling presence in UK media. Fans point to its (actually quite few) successes as reason for defending it (1/6) | The BBC is a sprawling presence in UK media. Fans point to its (actually quite few) successes as reason for defending it (1/6) |
| Reuters, FT, and The Economist are superb brands. Publishing: Lonely Planet (ex-BBC), Penguin – list goes on. Less so in broadcasting (3/6) | Reuters, FT, and The Economist are superb brands. Publishing: Lonely Planet (ex-BBC), Penguin – list goes on. Less so in broadcasting (3/6) |
| Rolling back BBC would not lead to a vacuum, it would lead to more creative, diverse ecosystem. (5/6)) | Rolling back BBC would not lead to a vacuum, it would lead to more creative, diverse ecosystem. (5/6)) |
| Ask yourself why Britain has made no global mark in podcasting. Utter dominance of BBC radio must be a factor, even if you enjoy R4. (6/6) | Ask yourself why Britain has made no global mark in podcasting. Utter dominance of BBC radio must be a factor, even if you enjoy R4. (6/6) |
| The political agenda every morning and evening is set by BBC (Today/Newsnight). That means state employees deciding what matters. (finished) | The political agenda every morning and evening is set by BBC (Today/Newsnight). That means state employees deciding what matters. (finished) |
| Updated | |
| at 12.02pm BST | |
| 11.54am BST | |
| 11:54 | |
| You can share your views on the future of the BBC via GuardianWitness. Just click on the blue ‘contribute’ button. | You can share your views on the future of the BBC via GuardianWitness. Just click on the blue ‘contribute’ button. |
| 11.52am BST | |
| 11:52 | |
| Here’s a flavour of the pressure Whittingdale faces from the right. | Here’s a flavour of the pressure Whittingdale faces from the right. |
| Ukip’s only MP Douglas Carswell suggests he fears the green paper won’t go far enough. | Ukip’s only MP Douglas Carswell suggests he fears the green paper won’t go far enough. |
| I suspect John Whittingdale will pull his punch and neither abolish nor decriminalise non payment of BBC licence fee http://t.co/jpBGJvIDx5 | I suspect John Whittingdale will pull his punch and neither abolish nor decriminalise non payment of BBC licence fee http://t.co/jpBGJvIDx5 |
| Times columnist Tim Montgomerie hails “trimming the BBC” as part of the new government’s “pacey start”. | Times columnist Tim Montgomerie hails “trimming the BBC” as part of the new government’s “pacey start”. |
| Union reform. Living wage. Trimming BBC. EU vote. Weekend GPs. Welfare cuts. 2% on defence. A pacey start to this majority Tory government. | Union reform. Living wage. Trimming BBC. EU vote. Weekend GPs. Welfare cuts. 2% on defence. A pacey start to this majority Tory government. |
| Rob Wilson, minister for civil society, criticises the BBC-backing letter by celebrities. | Rob Wilson, minister for civil society, criticises the BBC-backing letter by celebrities. |
| It appears the #BBC concocted a letter for its well paid stars to sign. I guess it's a case of 'he who pays the piper calls the tune.' | It appears the #BBC concocted a letter for its well paid stars to sign. I guess it's a case of 'he who pays the piper calls the tune.' |
| 11.43am BST | |
| 11:43 | |
| Times columnist Deborah Ross says “the BBC is bloated ... its stars are overpaid [and it] gives off the feeling that being to the left is both natural and right.” | Times columnist Deborah Ross says “the BBC is bloated ... its stars are overpaid [and it] gives off the feeling that being to the left is both natural and right.” |
| But she has a long list of why she has no wish to live in country without the BBC. | But she has a long list of why she has no wish to live in country without the BBC. |
| Here’s a sample: | Here’s a sample: |
| ■ Wolf Hall, because it was genius. | ■ Wolf Hall, because it was genius. |
| ■ The World Service, which is listened to by 190 million people. | ■ The World Service, which is listened to by 190 million people. |
| ■ The Daily Mail hates it, which has to be worth £170 a year in anyone’s book. | ■ The Daily Mail hates it, which has to be worth £170 a year in anyone’s book. |
| ■ It leaves all documentaries on two sisters joined at their thumbs, and also at the nose, and who weigh 68st, and have to be lifted from their bed by a crane, to Channel 5. | ■ It leaves all documentaries on two sisters joined at their thumbs, and also at the nose, and who weigh 68st, and have to be lifted from their bed by a crane, to Channel 5. |
| ■ Not being part of the free market means it can persevere, as was the case with Blackadder, when the first series was a flop. | ■ Not being part of the free market means it can persevere, as was the case with Blackadder, when the first series was a flop. |
| ■ And last, when I used to tell people from other countries that you could go to university free here, I would feel proud, and now that’s gone, I’m thinking, the NHS and the BBC. We’d best hang on to them for dear life. | ■ And last, when I used to tell people from other countries that you could go to university free here, I would feel proud, and now that’s gone, I’m thinking, the NHS and the BBC. We’d best hang on to them for dear life. |
| 11.27am BST | |
| 11:27 | |
| Welcome to live coverage of the government’s plans for the future of the BBC. | Welcome to live coverage of the government’s plans for the future of the BBC. |
| At midday culture secretary John Whittingdale is due to launch a green paper on the future of the BBC with an oral statement to the House of Commons. | At midday culture secretary John Whittingdale is due to launch a green paper on the future of the BBC with an oral statement to the House of Commons. |
| It is expected to consider changing the way the BBC is funded in the long term, while committing to the licence fee for at least five years. | It is expected to consider changing the way the BBC is funded in the long term, while committing to the licence fee for at least five years. |
| Government pre-briefing on the plans say they will include a “root and branch” review that will question whether the BBC has been chasing mass ratings at the expense of its original public service brief. | Government pre-briefing on the plans say they will include a “root and branch” review that will question whether the BBC has been chasing mass ratings at the expense of its original public service brief. |
| The review will be guided by a panel of mainly commercial experts – many of whom are critical of the BBC . It is expected to challenge everything from the licence fee to the corporation’s mandate to provide universal programming. | The review will be guided by a panel of mainly commercial experts – many of whom are critical of the BBC . It is expected to challenge everything from the licence fee to the corporation’s mandate to provide universal programming. |
| The paper is also likely to call for an end to the BBC Trust – the corporation 10-year-old government’s arrangement. Earlier this year the culture committee, then under the chairmanship of Whittingdale, said the trust should be replaced. | The paper is also likely to call for an end to the BBC Trust – the corporation 10-year-old government’s arrangement. Earlier this year the culture committee, then under the chairmanship of Whittingdale, said the trust should be replaced. |
| The review comes after the BBC agreed to shoulder the cost of providing free television licences for people aged over 75 in a surprise deal that will cost it £750m by 2020. | The review comes after the BBC agreed to shoulder the cost of providing free television licences for people aged over 75 in a surprise deal that will cost it £750m by 2020. |
| On Wednesday several prominent figures including JK Rowling, Lenny Henry and Gary Lineker, wrote an open letter to the prime minister warning against major cuts to the BBC. | On Wednesday several prominent figures including JK Rowling, Lenny Henry and Gary Lineker, wrote an open letter to the prime minister warning against major cuts to the BBC. |
| And BBC’s director general, Tony Hall, signalled his willingness for fight by delivering a passionate defence of the corporation at the launch of its annual report. “The BBC does not belong to its staff or the government, but it belongs to the people … and what they want is a continually better BBC,” he said. | And BBC’s director general, Tony Hall, signalled his willingness for fight by delivering a passionate defence of the corporation at the launch of its annual report. “The BBC does not belong to its staff or the government, but it belongs to the people … and what they want is a continually better BBC,” he said. |
| The Guardian’s Charlotte Higgins, who has written a new book on the BBC, reckons the the green paper will set up “a dramatic confrontation over the corporation’s very purpose”. | The Guardian’s Charlotte Higgins, who has written a new book on the BBC, reckons the the green paper will set up “a dramatic confrontation over the corporation’s very purpose”. |
| In a long read article headlined the “The Battle for the BBC” she sets out what’s at stake: | In a long read article headlined the “The Battle for the BBC” she sets out what’s at stake: |
| The question for the country now, and its politicians, is whether the BBC’s founding vision still has any currency; whether the BBC can still be something different from a media business and something more than a “content provider”. Can it still be part of the essence of Britishness, existing as a public space through which we may all pass as equals, selling us nothing, simply there for our information, education and entertainment? Can it remain our “guide, philosopher and friend”, as [BBC Founder Lord] Reith had it? In the end, these are questions that cut to the heart of what British society consists of, and what kind of nation we want to be. It is an argument that the BBC can win or lose; and it is in the newly empowered Conservatives’ gift to decide its fate. All that could possibly stand in the government’s way is the will of the people. Britain will have the BBC it deserves. | The question for the country now, and its politicians, is whether the BBC’s founding vision still has any currency; whether the BBC can still be something different from a media business and something more than a “content provider”. Can it still be part of the essence of Britishness, existing as a public space through which we may all pass as equals, selling us nothing, simply there for our information, education and entertainment? Can it remain our “guide, philosopher and friend”, as [BBC Founder Lord] Reith had it? In the end, these are questions that cut to the heart of what British society consists of, and what kind of nation we want to be. It is an argument that the BBC can win or lose; and it is in the newly empowered Conservatives’ gift to decide its fate. All that could possibly stand in the government’s way is the will of the people. Britain will have the BBC it deserves. |
| On Wednesday several prominent figures including JK Rowling, Lenny Henry, and Gary Lineker, wrote an open letter to the prime minister warning against major cuts to the BBC. | On Wednesday several prominent figures including JK Rowling, Lenny Henry, and Gary Lineker, wrote an open letter to the prime minister warning against major cuts to the BBC. |
| I may be biased but the BBC is something we should be proud of and is well worth protecting. #backtheBBC http://t.co/EPI9Mdf0Cm | I may be biased but the BBC is something we should be proud of and is well worth protecting. #backtheBBC http://t.co/EPI9Mdf0Cm |
| But Luke Johnson, former chairman of Channel 4, gives a flavour of what the corporation’s critics are demanding. Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme he said the BBC should not waste licence fee money on programmes such as The Voice which could be provided by commercial rivals. | But Luke Johnson, former chairman of Channel 4, gives a flavour of what the corporation’s critics are demanding. Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme he said the BBC should not waste licence fee money on programmes such as The Voice which could be provided by commercial rivals. |
| He added: “Unfortunately long-established places like the BBC tend to resist change and tend to see their imperative as growth at all costs. But often more means worse.” | He added: “Unfortunately long-established places like the BBC tend to resist change and tend to see their imperative as growth at all costs. But often more means worse.” |
| 11.25am BST | |
| 11:25 | |
| Both the Sun and the Daily Mail have hostile pieces on what they dub the “luvvie letter” from celebrities defending the BBC. | Both the Sun and the Daily Mail have hostile pieces on what they dub the “luvvie letter” from celebrities defending the BBC. |
| The Mail says some signatories, including Michael Palin, were asked to sign the letter by senior figures in the BBC. | The Mail says some signatories, including Michael Palin, were asked to sign the letter by senior figures in the BBC. |
| The Sun dismisses the move as “luvvie aid” from celebs with a vested interest. | The Sun dismisses the move as “luvvie aid” from celebs with a vested interest. |
| Sun blasts 'luvvie aid' for BBC pic.twitter.com/DiWKehPPTR | Sun blasts 'luvvie aid' for BBC pic.twitter.com/DiWKehPPTR |
| 11.13am BST | |
| 11:13 | |
| While we wait for Whittingdale’s statement (at midday), here’s a reminder that the BBC has a long history of wheeling out the stars to defend the licence fee. | While we wait for Whittingdale’s statement (at midday), here’s a reminder that the BBC has a long history of wheeling out the stars to defend the licence fee. |
| Yesterday’s BBC-backing letter to the Telegraph by a series of celebrities had echoes of a publicity film put out in the late 1980s to justifying the then £58 annual fee. “What have BBC ever given us?” asks John Cleese. Various answers are provided by the likes of Bob Geldof, David Attenborough, Sue Lawley plus the late Patrick Moore, Michael Hordern, Brian Johnson, Alan Whicker and Ronny Barker. | Yesterday’s BBC-backing letter to the Telegraph by a series of celebrities had echoes of a publicity film put out in the late 1980s to justifying the then £58 annual fee. “What have BBC ever given us?” asks John Cleese. Various answers are provided by the likes of Bob Geldof, David Attenborough, Sue Lawley plus the late Patrick Moore, Michael Hordern, Brian Johnson, Alan Whicker and Ronny Barker. |
| Updated | |
| at 12.05pm BST | |
| 11.09am BST | |
| 11:09 | |
| Ahead of the announcement there’s much speculation in the today’s press about the government’s plans for the BBC. | Ahead of the announcement there’s much speculation in the today’s press about the government’s plans for the BBC. |
| The Telegraph says families could “a Finnish-style means-tested broadcasting levy to pay for the BBC”. | The Telegraph says families could “a Finnish-style means-tested broadcasting levy to pay for the BBC”. |
| Its says Whittingdale will consider “plans for a new means tested levy to be paid by better-off taxpayers based on their annual income – regardless of whether or not they own a television.” | Its says Whittingdale will consider “plans for a new means tested levy to be paid by better-off taxpayers based on their annual income – regardless of whether or not they own a television.” |
| It also previews David Perry QC report on whether to decriminalise the non-payment of the licence fee. It says Perry will urge ministers to continue prosecuting licence fee evaders despite expressing concerns that it is disproportionately affecting women and leaving hundreds of thousands of people facing court action. | It also previews David Perry QC report on whether to decriminalise the non-payment of the licence fee. It says Perry will urge ministers to continue prosecuting licence fee evaders despite expressing concerns that it is disproportionately affecting women and leaving hundreds of thousands of people facing court action. |
| Government sources briefing the FT have played down fears of an “inflammatory green paper” on the future of the BBC is in fact “extremely generic” and “doesn’t take a position”, people familiar with its contents have said. | Government sources briefing the FT have played down fears of an “inflammatory green paper” on the future of the BBC is in fact “extremely generic” and “doesn’t take a position”, people familiar with its contents have said. |
| One person close to the process said the green paper “asks genuine questions about what the BBC should be doing and how it should be financed. It is straight up and down.” | One person close to the process said the green paper “asks genuine questions about what the BBC should be doing and how it should be financed. It is straight up and down.” |
| That suggests at least a temporary detente while detailed discussions take place. | That suggests at least a temporary detente while detailed discussions take place. |
| The BBC will receive a further fillip on Thursday, when a government-commissioned review recommends that non-payment of the licence fee should not be decriminalised. The BBC has pushed hard against decriminalisation, arguing it could reduce its licence fee revenue by £200m a year. | The BBC will receive a further fillip on Thursday, when a government-commissioned review recommends that non-payment of the licence fee should not be decriminalised. The BBC has pushed hard against decriminalisation, arguing it could reduce its licence fee revenue by £200m a year. |
| Updated | |
| at 12.07pm BST |