This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/18/business/dealbook/samsung-ct-shareholders-back-cheil-industries-merger-defying-activist-hedge-fund-elliott-associates.html
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Samsung Fight Exposes Tension in Asia Over Activist Investors | Samsung Fight Exposes Tension in Asia Over Activist Investors |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| SEOUL, South Korea — Samsung fended off the challenge of a big activist investor on Friday as the founding family tightened its grip over the sprawling South Korean conglomerate. | SEOUL, South Korea — Samsung fended off the challenge of a big activist investor on Friday as the founding family tightened its grip over the sprawling South Korean conglomerate. |
| But the public fight, a rare bout of activism in Asia, also exposed broader concerns about shareholder rights and succession planning in a country dominated by family-controlled conglomerates known as chaebols. | But the public fight, a rare bout of activism in Asia, also exposed broader concerns about shareholder rights and succession planning in a country dominated by family-controlled conglomerates known as chaebols. |
| The battle centered on the $8 billion merger of two Samsung affiliates, Samsung C&T and Cheil Industries. | The battle centered on the $8 billion merger of two Samsung affiliates, Samsung C&T and Cheil Industries. |
| The restructuring would allow Samsung to transfer more power to Lee Jae-yong, the son of the conglomerate’s chairman, Lee Kun-hee, who has been incapacitated since a heart attack in May 2014. | The restructuring would allow Samsung to transfer more power to Lee Jae-yong, the son of the conglomerate’s chairman, Lee Kun-hee, who has been incapacitated since a heart attack in May 2014. |
| The New York hedge fund Elliott Associates wanted to scuttle the deal, saying it grossly undervalued Samsung C&T and represented an unlawful attempt by the Lee family to consolidate its hold. | The New York hedge fund Elliott Associates wanted to scuttle the deal, saying it grossly undervalued Samsung C&T and represented an unlawful attempt by the Lee family to consolidate its hold. |
| For weeks, both sides tried to drum up support through fierce campaigns that featured lawsuits and front-page newspaper ads. Samsung depicted Elliott, which owns 7.12 percent of Samsung C&T, as a vulture capitalist, out to disrupt an orderly generational change and make a quick profit. Elliott, which is run by Paul E. Singer, filed and lost a pair of lawsuits in South Korea seeking to block the shareholder meeting. | |
| In the end, it was close. The merger was backed by 69.53 percent of the shareholders who voted on Friday, narrowly above the amount needed. | In the end, it was close. The merger was backed by 69.53 percent of the shareholders who voted on Friday, narrowly above the amount needed. |
| Investor activism like the Samsung fight is relatively uncommon in Asia. | Investor activism like the Samsung fight is relatively uncommon in Asia. |
| Publicly traded companies often remain under the control of close-knit family groups or state-backed shareholders, and legal protections for minority investors can be patchy. In many cases, activism in Asia plays out over a longer horizon, with players favoring persistent behind-the scenes lobbying over public campaigns. | Publicly traded companies often remain under the control of close-knit family groups or state-backed shareholders, and legal protections for minority investors can be patchy. In many cases, activism in Asia plays out over a longer horizon, with players favoring persistent behind-the scenes lobbying over public campaigns. |
| The hedge fund Oasis Management, which built a small stake in the Japanese video game maker Nintendo, spent more than two years arguing that the company needed to move beyond its struggling console business. | The hedge fund Oasis Management, which built a small stake in the Japanese video game maker Nintendo, spent more than two years arguing that the company needed to move beyond its struggling console business. |
| In March, Nintendo announced a new partnership to push into mobile games, and in May, it announced plans to bring its video game characters to Universal Parks and Resorts. The company’s shares have risen about two-thirds since the start of this year. | In March, Nintendo announced a new partnership to push into mobile games, and in May, it announced plans to bring its video game characters to Universal Parks and Resorts. The company’s shares have risen about two-thirds since the start of this year. |
| “With Nintendo, I got a ‘no’ for a year, and then I got ‘yes,’ and then it took 10 months for them to execute the ‘yes,’ ” Seth Fischer, Oasis’s founder and chief investment officer, said in an interview. “The answer in Japan is that it works, but it takes time.” | “With Nintendo, I got a ‘no’ for a year, and then I got ‘yes,’ and then it took 10 months for them to execute the ‘yes,’ ” Seth Fischer, Oasis’s founder and chief investment officer, said in an interview. “The answer in Japan is that it works, but it takes time.” |
| The Wall Street activist investor Daniel S. Loeb of Third Point took on Sony two years ago, pressing for a board seat. He also pushed the company to spin off part of its entertainment arm, which includes a Hollywood film studio and a music label. Mr. Loeb was largely rebuffed and eventually sold his Sony stake. | The Wall Street activist investor Daniel S. Loeb of Third Point took on Sony two years ago, pressing for a board seat. He also pushed the company to spin off part of its entertainment arm, which includes a Hollywood film studio and a music label. Mr. Loeb was largely rebuffed and eventually sold his Sony stake. |
| He later invested in Fanuc, the Japanese robot maker, where he was better received. After a recent meeting with the company’s management, Fanuc agreed to double its dividend. “Nobody thought this could be done,” Mr. Loeb told the audience at an investment conference in May. | He later invested in Fanuc, the Japanese robot maker, where he was better received. After a recent meeting with the company’s management, Fanuc agreed to double its dividend. “Nobody thought this could be done,” Mr. Loeb told the audience at an investment conference in May. |
| Elliott has previously gone up against powerful Asian tycoons. | Elliott has previously gone up against powerful Asian tycoons. |
| Last year, it built up a 2.5 percent stake in the Bank of East Asia, one of Hong Kong’s biggest local banks, which is controlled by the family of David Li. But the hedge fund’s stake was diluted after the bank sold new shares to the Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group of Japan. | Last year, it built up a 2.5 percent stake in the Bank of East Asia, one of Hong Kong’s biggest local banks, which is controlled by the family of David Li. But the hedge fund’s stake was diluted after the bank sold new shares to the Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group of Japan. |
| Elliott sought to challenge the decision, which some analysts described as a defensive move by the Li family, asking a Hong Kong court to order Bank of East Asia to disclose the reasons for the share placement. But the hedge fund has so far stopped short of suing the bank or its directors. | Elliott sought to challenge the decision, which some analysts described as a defensive move by the Li family, asking a Hong Kong court to order Bank of East Asia to disclose the reasons for the share placement. But the hedge fund has so far stopped short of suing the bank or its directors. |
| The face-off over Samsung loomed large in South Korea. | The face-off over Samsung loomed large in South Korea. |
| Samsung’s 70 subsidiaries, engaged in businesses as varied as shipbuilding, home appliances, apartment buildings and mobile phones, generate revenue equaling a quarter of South Korea’s gross domestic product. The group’s influence is so pervasive that the country is often referred to as “Republic of Samsung.” | Samsung’s 70 subsidiaries, engaged in businesses as varied as shipbuilding, home appliances, apartment buildings and mobile phones, generate revenue equaling a quarter of South Korea’s gross domestic product. The group’s influence is so pervasive that the country is often referred to as “Republic of Samsung.” |
| As the fight raged between Samsung and Elliott, editorials in leading domestic newspapers suggested that the country allow top companies to adopt dual-class stocks, “poison pills” and other shields against hostile moves by foreign hedge funds. | As the fight raged between Samsung and Elliott, editorials in leading domestic newspapers suggested that the country allow top companies to adopt dual-class stocks, “poison pills” and other shields against hostile moves by foreign hedge funds. |
| “Samsung’s battle should not be a lonely fight,” Lee Chul-ho, the chief editorial writer of the local mass-circulation daily JoongAng Ilbo, wrote in a recent column. “If Samsung loses, other companies could fall prey to outside predators.” | “Samsung’s battle should not be a lonely fight,” Lee Chul-ho, the chief editorial writer of the local mass-circulation daily JoongAng Ilbo, wrote in a recent column. “If Samsung loses, other companies could fall prey to outside predators.” |
| Going into the Samsung vote, Elliott did drum up support from big international investors like the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board and outside advisory firms like Institutional Shareholder Services and Korea Corporate Governance Service. Thousands of small local shareholders also rallied online to support Elliott’s activist strategy as a catalyst for better corporate governance at the chaebol. | Going into the Samsung vote, Elliott did drum up support from big international investors like the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board and outside advisory firms like Institutional Shareholder Services and Korea Corporate Governance Service. Thousands of small local shareholders also rallied online to support Elliott’s activist strategy as a catalyst for better corporate governance at the chaebol. |
| To win over investors, Samsung dispatched executives on overseas trips and rank-and-file employees on door-to-door visits at home. Samsung won the backing of domestic institutional investors, including South Korea’s National Pension Service, which was the single largest shareholder at Samsung C&T, with an 11.9 percent stake. | To win over investors, Samsung dispatched executives on overseas trips and rank-and-file employees on door-to-door visits at home. Samsung won the backing of domestic institutional investors, including South Korea’s National Pension Service, which was the single largest shareholder at Samsung C&T, with an 11.9 percent stake. |
| “Elliott is disappointed that the takeover appears to have been approved against the wishes of so many independent shareholders and reserves all options at its disposal,” the hedge fund said in a statement. | “Elliott is disappointed that the takeover appears to have been approved against the wishes of so many independent shareholders and reserves all options at its disposal,” the hedge fund said in a statement. |
| Although it lost the vote, Elliott’s activism appeared to have some effect. Cheil and Samsung C&T have promised to bolster corporate governance by increasing dividends and creating a shareholder rights committee. | Although it lost the vote, Elliott’s activism appeared to have some effect. Cheil and Samsung C&T have promised to bolster corporate governance by increasing dividends and creating a shareholder rights committee. |
| “We will listen to those who opposed the deal and pledge to better engage with our shareholders and be more open to their input and feedback,” Cheil and Samsung C&T said in a joint statement. | “We will listen to those who opposed the deal and pledge to better engage with our shareholders and be more open to their input and feedback,” Cheil and Samsung C&T said in a joint statement. |