This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/aug/06/pilot-scheme-forcing-landlords-check-tenants-immigration-status-failed

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Pilot scheme forcing landlords to check tenants' immigration status 'has failed' Pilot scheme forcing landlords to check tenants' immigration status 'has failed'
(about 2 hours later)
A pilot scheme to force landlords to check the immigration status of prospective tenants has been a failure, the government’s own data suggests.A pilot scheme to force landlords to check the immigration status of prospective tenants has been a failure, the government’s own data suggests.
In the nine months since the rules were implemented across the Black Country, only seven landlords have been penalised, according to documents released to the Economist under the Freedom of Information Act.In the nine months since the rules were implemented across the Black Country, only seven landlords have been penalised, according to documents released to the Economist under the Freedom of Information Act.
A separate investigation has found that the scheme, a key part of the government’s immigration crackdown, may also have encouraged discrimination against non-British prospective tenants.A separate investigation has found that the scheme, a key part of the government’s immigration crackdown, may also have encouraged discrimination against non-British prospective tenants.
Since December 2014, landlords in five local authority areas in the West Midlands have been forced to check the immigration status of renters or face a fine of up to £3,000 per tenant.Since December 2014, landlords in five local authority areas in the West Midlands have been forced to check the immigration status of renters or face a fine of up to £3,000 per tenant.
The scheme is now set to be extended across the country and the penalties stiffened – including potential jail sentences of up to five years – as part of a new immigration bill. Under the proposals landlords would also be given powers to evict people who don’t have leave to remain in the country without first getting a court order.The scheme is now set to be extended across the country and the penalties stiffened – including potential jail sentences of up to five years – as part of a new immigration bill. Under the proposals landlords would also be given powers to evict people who don’t have leave to remain in the country without first getting a court order.
But documents released to the Economist showed that since the pilot scheme took effect, just seven landlords have been issued notices, and they faced average fines of just £800.But documents released to the Economist showed that since the pilot scheme took effect, just seven landlords have been issued notices, and they faced average fines of just £800.
Separate research into the trial by a charity also found that only half of those looking for rental accommodation were asked by a landlord and agent if they had permission to stay in the UK.Separate research into the trial by a charity also found that only half of those looking for rental accommodation were asked by a landlord and agent if they had permission to stay in the UK.
A third investigation found the pilot may have encouraged landlords to discriminate against prospective tenants from overseas. A mystery shopping exercise found non-Britons were blocked from renting properties on 11 out of 27 occasions.A third investigation found the pilot may have encouraged landlords to discriminate against prospective tenants from overseas. A mystery shopping exercise found non-Britons were blocked from renting properties on 11 out of 27 occasions.
Under the Right to Rent scheme, central to the government’s immigration crackdown, landlords will be obliged to see evidence of a person’s right to remain in the UK by examining their passport or biometric residence permit.Under the Right to Rent scheme, central to the government’s immigration crackdown, landlords will be obliged to see evidence of a person’s right to remain in the UK by examining their passport or biometric residence permit.
The legislation will create a blacklist of persistent rogue landlords and letting agents to allow councils to know where to concentrate their enforcement action.The legislation will create a blacklist of persistent rogue landlords and letting agents to allow councils to know where to concentrate their enforcement action.
But the damning assessment presented by the government data and additional investigations into the pilot will raise fears that the scheme will prove unworkable and, if it is seen as encouraging discrimination, could be open to challenge.But the damning assessment presented by the government data and additional investigations into the pilot will raise fears that the scheme will prove unworkable and, if it is seen as encouraging discrimination, could be open to challenge.
Landlords will be responsible for recognising – and spotting fakes of – 444 documents issued by different countries in the European economic area, one immigration lawyer told the Economist.Landlords will be responsible for recognising – and spotting fakes of – 444 documents issued by different countries in the European economic area, one immigration lawyer told the Economist.
Rose Carey, an immigration specialist at Charles Russell Speechlys, added that any landlord who does face charges of discrimination could also be embroiled in expensive civil litigation.Rose Carey, an immigration specialist at Charles Russell Speechlys, added that any landlord who does face charges of discrimination could also be embroiled in expensive civil litigation.
Related: Concerns raised over plan to strip failed asylum seeker families of benefitsRelated: Concerns raised over plan to strip failed asylum seeker families of benefits
The plans come as the government struggles to respond to a refugee crisis in Calais, where as many as 5,000 people are camping out in the hope of smuggling themselves into Britain aboard ferries or through the Channel tunnel.The plans come as the government struggles to respond to a refugee crisis in Calais, where as many as 5,000 people are camping out in the hope of smuggling themselves into Britain aboard ferries or through the Channel tunnel.
David Cameron, the prime minister, came under fire after he described those migrants as a “swarm of people” when he vowed more measures to throw failed asylum seekers out of Britain and dissuade others from trying to reach the country.David Cameron, the prime minister, came under fire after he described those migrants as a “swarm of people” when he vowed more measures to throw failed asylum seekers out of Britain and dissuade others from trying to reach the country.
On Sunday the Home Office confirmed it was planning to strip families with children of the automatic right to benefits if their asylum applications were rejected, bringing their entitlements into line with those for single migrants.On Sunday the Home Office confirmed it was planning to strip families with children of the automatic right to benefits if their asylum applications were rejected, bringing their entitlements into line with those for single migrants.
Responding to that announcement and the proposals to force landlords to check their tenants’ immigration statuses, Stephen Hale of Refugee Action called the government’s plans “seriously flawed”.Responding to that announcement and the proposals to force landlords to check their tenants’ immigration statuses, Stephen Hale of Refugee Action called the government’s plans “seriously flawed”.
“Families in the asylum system are already forced to survive on around 50% of the equivalent level of income support, and we know this is pushing vulnerable families into poverty,” Hale said. “It seems ludicrous to assume that any family would choose to live under such constraints unless they were in fear of their lives.“Families in the asylum system are already forced to survive on around 50% of the equivalent level of income support, and we know this is pushing vulnerable families into poverty,” Hale said. “It seems ludicrous to assume that any family would choose to live under such constraints unless they were in fear of their lives.
“These plans might be designed to make the government look tough on asylum, but they will not dissuade anyone from seeking the safety from persecution they so desperately need – and they will leave refugee families in poverty.”“These plans might be designed to make the government look tough on asylum, but they will not dissuade anyone from seeking the safety from persecution they so desperately need – and they will leave refugee families in poverty.”
A Home Office spokesperson said: “The evaluation of Right to Rent is currently being completed, but there are no indications so far to suggest landlord checks are being carried out unfairly.
“Right to Rent is not designed to be a money-making scheme or to catch out honest landlords. Instead, we want to help landlords carry out the proper checks so that those who do not have the right to be in the UK cannot access rented accommodation.
“We do not recognise figures suggesting only half of landlords checked potential tenants’ right to rent.”