This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2017/mar/21/malcolm-turnbull-bill-shorten-liberals-parliament-racial-discrimination-act-politics-live

The article has changed 17 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 12 Version 13
Labor grills Turnbull over weakening of race hate laws on Harmony Day – question time live Labor grills Turnbull over weakening of race hate laws on Harmony Day – question time live
(35 minutes later)
4.55am GMT
04:55
4.53am GMT
04:53
4.50am GMT
04:50
There are debates going on everywhere on 18C.
.@timwilsoncomau says #18c changes preserve freedom to discuss ideas, @GrahamPerrettMP says there's laws already in place that do #auspol pic.twitter.com/CGThpQxA4m
4.43am GMT
04:43
Read Katharine Murphy on 18C.
The Coalition is unable to drop this particular hot potato, despite senior players like Barnaby Joyce and Scott Morrison saying very clearly that the issue really isn’t a priority down the back paddock, or in the cafe where you picked up your coffee this morning, because a significant bloc in the right faction of the Liberal party intended to keep on pushing until the Freedom™ lady sang.
This is an internal crusade, a little passion play for the conservative base, pure and simple, and never mind the casualties – even if the casualties are your hard-working government colleagues, attempting to defend marginal seats with large ethnic populations.
Updated
at 4.48am GMT
4.38am GMT
04:38
Meanwhile, former Labor senator Nova Peris is sharing some examples of free speech possible under the current system.
#FreedomofSpeech pic.twitter.com/tUgistooGV
#FreedomofSpeech pic.twitter.com/zpafGj5fil
#FreedomofSpeech pic.twitter.com/TpkZq8oNQX
Updated
at 4.40am GMT
4.32am GMT
04:32
The justice minister, Michael Keenan, has been sent out to bat for the changes to 18C.
It’s all about striking the right balance, he says.
Keenan is talking about the treatment of Bill Leak and the appalling prosecution of the QUT students.
Updated
at 4.33am GMT
4.24am GMT
04:24
Tony Burke gives a very strong speech.
No one expected the member for Wentworth would be less sympathetic than his predecessor...
Today the end of the Turnbull prime ministership is complete.
4.21am GMT
04:21
Tim Wilson is champing at the bit in his seat on the backbench.
Tony Burke says the Coalition has no idea of the real effect of the 18C changes, then quips maybe that’s because they had so many at the Cronulla riots.
4.15am GMT4.15am GMT
04:1504:15
Labor’s Tony Burke is speaking on a matter of public importance on the changes to 18C.Labor’s Tony Burke is speaking on a matter of public importance on the changes to 18C.
Do they want to lower the bar on racial hate speech in Australia?Do they want to lower the bar on racial hate speech in Australia?
Will be interesting to see who does the speech defending the changes for the Coalition.Will be interesting to see who does the speech defending the changes for the Coalition.
There appears to be no one in the chair at this stage.There appears to be no one in the chair at this stage.
UpdatedUpdated
at 4.17am GMTat 4.17am GMT
4.10am GMT4.10am GMT
04:1004:10
Shorten to Turnbull: Wages growth is at record lows. Underemployment is at record highs. The unemployment rate has increased to nearly 6%. Is the prime minister still committed to his entire $50bn tax cut for big business, a plan that the prime minister has previously modestly described as his greatest achievement? And if not, what’s left of the prime minister’s 1-point plan for jobs and growth?Shorten to Turnbull: Wages growth is at record lows. Underemployment is at record highs. The unemployment rate has increased to nearly 6%. Is the prime minister still committed to his entire $50bn tax cut for big business, a plan that the prime minister has previously modestly described as his greatest achievement? And if not, what’s left of the prime minister’s 1-point plan for jobs and growth?
Malcolm Turnbull says the suggestion from Shorten and Plibersek was utterly false.Malcolm Turnbull says the suggestion from Shorten and Plibersek was utterly false.
He reads a transcript of the interview concerned, when he was asked “what would you say is your greatest achievement since being prime minister?” Turnbull says he responded, “Jobs and growth, 3.3% economic growth”.He reads a transcript of the interview concerned, when he was asked “what would you say is your greatest achievement since being prime minister?” Turnbull says he responded, “Jobs and growth, 3.3% economic growth”.
Completely and utterly false. The answer is there. Once again, no regard for the truth. Talk about post-truth politics. The parallel universe in which they inhabit.Completely and utterly false. The answer is there. Once again, no regard for the truth. Talk about post-truth politics. The parallel universe in which they inhabit.
UpdatedUpdated
at 4.13am GMTat 4.13am GMT
4.06am GMT4.06am GMT
04:0604:06
4.01am GMT4.01am GMT
04:0104:01
Bowen to Morrison: Days after last year’s budget, the treasurer said, “At the centre of our plan for jobs and growth is a 10-year enterprise tax plan.” Is the treasurer still committed to his entire 10-year plan, a plan the prime minister described as his greatest achievement? If not, isn’t the government’s so-called plan for jobs and growth just in tatters?Bowen to Morrison: Days after last year’s budget, the treasurer said, “At the centre of our plan for jobs and growth is a 10-year enterprise tax plan.” Is the treasurer still committed to his entire 10-year plan, a plan the prime minister described as his greatest achievement? If not, isn’t the government’s so-called plan for jobs and growth just in tatters?
Morrison says he is absolutely committed to his tax plan.Morrison says he is absolutely committed to his tax plan.
Then he attacks Labor’s change of support for company tax cuts (as Keating once supported).Then he attacks Labor’s change of support for company tax cuts (as Keating once supported).
UpdatedUpdated
at 4.03am GMTat 4.03am GMT
3.57am GMT3.57am GMT
03:5703:57
Plibersek to Turnbull: On 9 September last year, when asked to name his greatest achievements since deposing the former prime minister, the member for Warringah, the current prime minister said, “Reforms to business tax.” Is the prime minister still committed to his centre piece $50bn tax cut for big business in full? If not, what will the prime minister’s new greatest achievement be?Plibersek to Turnbull: On 9 September last year, when asked to name his greatest achievements since deposing the former prime minister, the member for Warringah, the current prime minister said, “Reforms to business tax.” Is the prime minister still committed to his centre piece $50bn tax cut for big business in full? If not, what will the prime minister’s new greatest achievement be?
The PM does not exactly answer but he sings the praises of the policy.The PM does not exactly answer but he sings the praises of the policy.
UpdatedUpdated
at 4.00am GMTat 4.00am GMT
3.55am GMT3.55am GMT
03:5503:55
UpdatedUpdated
at 3.57am GMTat 3.57am GMT
3.53am GMT3.53am GMT
03:5303:53
UpdatedUpdated
at 3.55am GMTat 3.55am GMT
3.51am GMT3.51am GMT
03:5103:51
Government question on secret payments between unions and employers to Christopher Pyne.Government question on secret payments between unions and employers to Christopher Pyne.
3.50am GMT3.50am GMT
03:5003:50
Chris Bowen to Scott Morrison: There are reports today that the government is preparing to back down on its centrepiece $50bn tax cut for big business. Just like the treasurer backed down on an increase to the GST, state income taxes and dealing with the excesses in negative gearing. Can the treasurer name one major tax reform he has been able to hold on to for more than a year?Chris Bowen to Scott Morrison: There are reports today that the government is preparing to back down on its centrepiece $50bn tax cut for big business. Just like the treasurer backed down on an increase to the GST, state income taxes and dealing with the excesses in negative gearing. Can the treasurer name one major tax reform he has been able to hold on to for more than a year?
Morrison says:Morrison says:
Multinational anti-avoidance legislation,Multinational anti-avoidance legislation,
diverted profits tax legislation,diverted profits tax legislation,
low-value goods legislation to make sure that people are paying taxes on the goods that they buy from overseas,low-value goods legislation to make sure that people are paying taxes on the goods that they buy from overseas,
superannuation “that those opposite didn’t have the gall to bring into this chamber”.superannuation “that those opposite didn’t have the gall to bring into this chamber”.
UpdatedUpdated
at 3.53am GMTat 3.53am GMT
3.46am GMT3.46am GMT
03:4603:46
Labor’s Brendan O’Connor to Turnbull: The Reserve Bank ofAustralia has today said, “Growth in labour incomes had been unusually weak and if it were to persist it would have implications for consumption growth and the risks posed to household debt.” Why is the government threatening demand and the economy by supporting pay cuts for Australians?Labor’s Brendan O’Connor to Turnbull: The Reserve Bank ofAustralia has today said, “Growth in labour incomes had been unusually weak and if it were to persist it would have implications for consumption growth and the risks posed to household debt.” Why is the government threatening demand and the economy by supporting pay cuts for Australians?
Turnbull says O’Connor supported the Fair Work Commission as did Bill Shorten.Turnbull says O’Connor supported the Fair Work Commission as did Bill Shorten.
But not now. What did they justify those changes for? The increase in employment. More jobs. More businesses opening. Page after page of examples of small businesses that said that the high rate of Sunday penalty rates and public holiday rates at the moment prevented them from opening. There are pages and pages of them, Mr Speaker. It was a decision based on evidence. The Fair Work Commission is backing small business and so are we.But not now. What did they justify those changes for? The increase in employment. More jobs. More businesses opening. Page after page of examples of small businesses that said that the high rate of Sunday penalty rates and public holiday rates at the moment prevented them from opening. There are pages and pages of them, Mr Speaker. It was a decision based on evidence. The Fair Work Commission is backing small business and so are we.
UpdatedUpdated
at 3.53am GMTat 3.53am GMT