This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-48519746
The article has changed 13 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 5 | Version 6 |
|---|---|
| No-deal Brexit: Can MPs overrule the new prime minister? | No-deal Brexit: Can MPs overrule the new prime minister? |
| (about 11 hours later) | |
| Prime Minister Boris Johnson has said the UK will leave the EU on 31 October "do or die" - even if it means walking away without a deal. | Prime Minister Boris Johnson has said the UK will leave the EU on 31 October "do or die" - even if it means walking away without a deal. |
| Many MPs oppose no-deal Brexit, but can they stop it now that the government has asked the Queen to suspend Parliament? | Many MPs oppose no-deal Brexit, but can they stop it now that the government has asked the Queen to suspend Parliament? |
| What is no deal? | What is no deal? |
| A no-deal Brexit means the UK would immediately leave the EU with no agreement in place about the "divorce" process - or how they separate. | A no-deal Brexit means the UK would immediately leave the EU with no agreement in place about the "divorce" process - or how they separate. |
| Overnight, the UK would leave the single market and customs union - arrangements designed to help trade between EU members. | Overnight, the UK would leave the single market and customs union - arrangements designed to help trade between EU members. |
| Many politicians and businesses say this would damage the economy. | Many politicians and businesses say this would damage the economy. |
| Others say the risks are exaggerated. | Others say the risks are exaggerated. |
| Former prime minister Theresa May couldn't persuade her own MPs to support her agreement with the EU, which would have avoided no deal. That's why she resigned. | Former prime minister Theresa May couldn't persuade her own MPs to support her agreement with the EU, which would have avoided no deal. That's why she resigned. |
| Unless Mr Johnson can get his own - as yet non-existent - Brexit deal passed, the UK will face the prospect of leaving without an agreement at the end of October. | Unless Mr Johnson can get his own - as yet non-existent - Brexit deal passed, the UK will face the prospect of leaving without an agreement at the end of October. |
| The alternative would be to extend the deadline again - or cancel Brexit altogether. | The alternative would be to extend the deadline again - or cancel Brexit altogether. |
| How could the prime minister make no deal happen? | How could the prime minister make no deal happen? |
| In theory, unless a new plan is agreed, Mr Johnson does not need to do anything for a no-deal Brexit to happen. | In theory, unless a new plan is agreed, Mr Johnson does not need to do anything for a no-deal Brexit to happen. |
| This is because the UK's departure on 31 October is already written into law. He could just run the clock down. | This is because the UK's departure on 31 October is already written into law. He could just run the clock down. |
| But it's not as simple as that. | But it's not as simple as that. |
| Most MPs in the UK Parliament are against leaving without a deal. And they could try to stop it from happening. | Most MPs in the UK Parliament are against leaving without a deal. And they could try to stop it from happening. |
| What can MPs do to stop no deal? | What can MPs do to stop no deal? |
| MPs have two potential routes: take control of Parliament's timetable, or get rid of the government. | MPs have two potential routes: take control of Parliament's timetable, or get rid of the government. |
| Neither would guarantee blocking a no-deal Brexit, but they could lead them there. | Neither would guarantee blocking a no-deal Brexit, but they could lead them there. |
| Route 1: Take control of Parliament | Route 1: Take control of Parliament |
| After a cross-party meeting of MPs opposed to a no-deal Brexit, this emerged as the preferred option when Parliament resumes on 3 September. | After a cross-party meeting of MPs opposed to a no-deal Brexit, this emerged as the preferred option when Parliament resumes on 3 September. |
| If the government tries to pass new laws, MPs could attempt to make changes that would force the government's hand. However, ministers have said no legislation will be needed between now and exit day, potentially blocking this route for MPs | If the government tries to pass new laws, MPs could attempt to make changes that would force the government's hand. However, ministers have said no legislation will be needed between now and exit day, potentially blocking this route for MPs |
| Instead, MPs could try to take control of the timetable and set aside time to pass a new law that would block a no deal. Any legislation, if passed, could force the government to request another extension from the EU. | Instead, MPs could try to take control of the timetable and set aside time to pass a new law that would block a no deal. Any legislation, if passed, could force the government to request another extension from the EU. |
| MPs would have to wrest control of the timetable from the government, which usually decides what happens in Parliament. | MPs would have to wrest control of the timetable from the government, which usually decides what happens in Parliament. |
| This might be through an emergency debate, granted to MPs by the Speaker. These are usually non-binding debates, but could be given more teeth in certain circumstances. | This might be through an emergency debate, granted to MPs by the Speaker. These are usually non-binding debates, but could be given more teeth in certain circumstances. |
| However, Boris Johnson's decision to prorogue parliament makes taking control of Parliament less easy. | However, Boris Johnson's decision to prorogue parliament makes taking control of Parliament less easy. |
| Is there enough time to pass a new law? | Is there enough time to pass a new law? |
| The prime minister's decision to close Parliament on 10 September makes it very difficult to pass a law before the suspension. | The prime minister's decision to close Parliament on 10 September makes it very difficult to pass a law before the suspension. |
| MPs return to Westminster on 3 September, leaving them with around five sitting days to take action. | MPs return to Westminster on 3 September, leaving them with around five sitting days to take action. |
| A new law can only be passed if it completes all stages in Parliament - both in the House of Commons and the Lords. | A new law can only be passed if it completes all stages in Parliament - both in the House of Commons and the Lords. |
| Labour MP Yvette Cooper managed to pass a law in three days in April, so there is precedence. | Labour MP Yvette Cooper managed to pass a law in three days in April, so there is precedence. |
| After MPs return to Parliament on 14 October, there will still be almost three weeks before the UK leaves the EU. | After MPs return to Parliament on 14 October, there will still be almost three weeks before the UK leaves the EU. |
| But, because a new session is beginning, the House of Commons will be busy debating the Queen's Speech for up to six days. This further narrows the window for action. | But, because a new session is beginning, the House of Commons will be busy debating the Queen's Speech for up to six days. This further narrows the window for action. |
| Route 2: Bring down the government | Route 2: Bring down the government |
| Seen by some as the "nuclear option", MPs have the option to vote out the government. | Seen by some as the "nuclear option", MPs have the option to vote out the government. |
| This could happen as early as 4 September, the day after Westminster returns from its summer break. Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has said he will call a vote of no confidence "at the appropriate and very early time to do it". | This could happen as early as 4 September, the day after Westminster returns from its summer break. Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has said he will call a vote of no confidence "at the appropriate and very early time to do it". |
| If a majority of MPs vote against the government, a formal process kicks off under the Fixed-Term Parliaments Act: | If a majority of MPs vote against the government, a formal process kicks off under the Fixed-Term Parliaments Act: |
| The 14-day period could produce a temporary government of national unity, whose main aim could be to request an extension from the EU and organise an election in the meantime. | The 14-day period could produce a temporary government of national unity, whose main aim could be to request an extension from the EU and organise an election in the meantime. |
| This would require a huge amount of cross-party cooperation - not seen since World War Two - to bring together MPs from different parties. | This would require a huge amount of cross-party cooperation - not seen since World War Two - to bring together MPs from different parties. |
| Is there enough time to do this? | Is there enough time to do this? |
| A vote of no confidence could be held as soon as 4 September, | A vote of no confidence could be held as soon as 4 September, |
| But MPs would then only have three or four sitting days to form an alternative government and prove it has majority support in the House of Commons, rather than the full 14 days. | But MPs would then only have three or four sitting days to form an alternative government and prove it has majority support in the House of Commons, rather than the full 14 days. |
| It is unclear what would happen if the PM lost a no confidence and Parliament was suspended before the 14-day period was up. | It is unclear what would happen if the PM lost a no confidence and Parliament was suspended before the 14-day period was up. |
| However, there would certainly be political pressure on the government to postpone prorogation. | However, there would certainly be political pressure on the government to postpone prorogation. |
| What else could happen? | What else could happen? |
| It isn't just MPs who could try and get in the way of the PM's prorogation plans - others have suggested a legal challenge. | |
| Although it is the government's decision to prorogue Parliament, it is the Queen who has the power to enact it - but it would be impossible to take the Queen to court. | |
| However, campaigner Gina Miller has made an application to the Supreme Court, seeking permission for a judicial review of the PM's decision. | |
| She told the BBC the case would question Mr Johnson's advice to the Queen and challenge whether he was using his powers to suspend Parliament and call a Queen's speech legally. | |
| She hopes the case will be heard before prorogation begins. | |
| Ms Miller said it was not for her to say whether the PM's plan was legal, but "it was for the courts to decide with evidence". | |
| Former Prime Minister Sir John Major also raised the prospect of a judicial review in July. | |
| After prorogation was announced, he said he believed Mr Johnson's motive was to "bypass a Sovereign Parliament that opposes his policy on Brexit" and that he would "continue to seek advice on the legality of this and other matters". |