This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/6446887.stm
The article has changed 11 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Lords expected to oppose reforms | Lords expected to oppose reforms |
| (about 3 hours later) | |
| The House of Lords is expected to oppose government plans to elect most, or all, of its members in future. | The House of Lords is expected to oppose government plans to elect most, or all, of its members in future. |
| Peers are ending a two-day debate by voting on choices ranging from creating an all-elected second chamber to keeping an all-appointed one. | |
| They are expected to come out strongly against last week's Commons vote in favour of all members being elected. | They are expected to come out strongly against last week's Commons vote in favour of all members being elected. |
| The last government attempt to reform the Lords, in 2003, failed after MPs could not agree on a way forward. | The last government attempt to reform the Lords, in 2003, failed after MPs could not agree on a way forward. |
| Manifesto | Manifesto |
| On Tuesday, the Archbishop of York, the Most Rev John Sentamu, told peers that elected members would be less independent. His views were echoed on all sides. | On Tuesday, the Archbishop of York, the Most Rev John Sentamu, told peers that elected members would be less independent. His views were echoed on all sides. |
| Commons leader Jack Straw, who proposed the plans, is battling to reach a compromise with the widest possible backing. | Commons leader Jack Straw, who proposed the plans, is battling to reach a compromise with the widest possible backing. |
| There have been suggestions that some MPs who voted in favour of a 100% elected second chamber wanted to scupper the plans by ensuring an option unacceptable to either the government or peers was chosen. | There have been suggestions that some MPs who voted in favour of a 100% elected second chamber wanted to scupper the plans by ensuring an option unacceptable to either the government or peers was chosen. |
| REFORM PROPOSALS A 'hybrid' of elected and appointed peersReduce size of House from 746 to 540 membersEnd hereditary and life peerages over timeElected peers to be voted in at same time as Euro electionsMaximum time in office of 15 years for elected and appointed peersAppointees a mixture of party politicians and non-party figuresLords may be renamed - possibly 'The Reformed Chamber'Anglican bishops and archbishops to keep seats Plans at-a-glance Full text of White Paper | REFORM PROPOSALS A 'hybrid' of elected and appointed peersReduce size of House from 746 to 540 membersEnd hereditary and life peerages over timeElected peers to be voted in at same time as Euro electionsMaximum time in office of 15 years for elected and appointed peersAppointees a mixture of party politicians and non-party figuresLords may be renamed - possibly 'The Reformed Chamber'Anglican bishops and archbishops to keep seats Plans at-a-glance Full text of White Paper |
| Labour's Baroness Symons said she would vote for a 100% appointed Lords, as an elected House would threaten the primacy of the Commons. | Labour's Baroness Symons said she would vote for a 100% appointed Lords, as an elected House would threaten the primacy of the Commons. |
| She said it would be "misleading to give the electorate the right to vote, without the right of the elected to deliver on that vote". | She said it would be "misleading to give the electorate the right to vote, without the right of the elected to deliver on that vote". |
| Labour's Lord Desai, who supports a fully elected House, described the MPs' vote as "revolutionary". | Labour's Lord Desai, who supports a fully elected House, described the MPs' vote as "revolutionary". |
| "If we have an all-elected House it will be a new constitutional arrangement. | "If we have an all-elected House it will be a new constitutional arrangement. |
| "All the conventions we have fashioned will have to be carefully examined and we may have to face up to a written constitution. | "All the conventions we have fashioned will have to be carefully examined and we may have to face up to a written constitution. |
| "We have no reason to fear that if we are removed, the world would come to an end. Perhaps there are other people who could be as good. Let's give the reforms a chance." | "We have no reason to fear that if we are removed, the world would come to an end. Perhaps there are other people who could be as good. Let's give the reforms a chance." |
| Priority | Priority |
| Conservative Lord Trefgarne said he was not opposed to reform but only when presented in a more considered manner by the government. | Conservative Lord Trefgarne said he was not opposed to reform but only when presented in a more considered manner by the government. |
| In theory the Commons could force through changes against the wishes of the House of Lords, but that would be controversial and take up a great deal of Parliamentary time. | In theory the Commons could force through changes against the wishes of the House of Lords, but that would be controversial and take up a great deal of Parliamentary time. |
| The issue then would be whether Gordon Brown, or whoever succeeds Tony Blair as prime minister, sees the reform as a high enough priority to justify the amount of government time it would be likely to take up. | The issue then would be whether Gordon Brown, or whoever succeeds Tony Blair as prime minister, sees the reform as a high enough priority to justify the amount of government time it would be likely to take up. |