This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-20664793
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| GCSE English grades 'statistical fix', High Court told | |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| Lawyers challenging this summer's GCSE English grades have accused two exam boards and the watchdog Ofqual of grade manipulation and a statistical fix. | Lawyers challenging this summer's GCSE English grades have accused two exam boards and the watchdog Ofqual of grade manipulation and a statistical fix. |
| An alliance of pupils, teaching unions, schools and councils is seeking a judicial review of last-minute shifts in grade boundaries in June's exams. | An alliance of pupils, teaching unions, schools and councils is seeking a judicial review of last-minute shifts in grade boundaries in June's exams. |
| The hearing is expected to last up to three days with a verdict likely before Christmas. | The hearing is expected to last up to three days with a verdict likely before Christmas. |
| Ofqual and exam boards AQA and Edexcel will give their evidence later. | Ofqual and exam boards AQA and Edexcel will give their evidence later. |
| Clive Sheldon QC, representing the claimants, said there was evidence of "manifest unfairness by AQA and Edexcel, procured and approved and certainly not corrected by Ofqual". | Clive Sheldon QC, representing the claimants, said there was evidence of "manifest unfairness by AQA and Edexcel, procured and approved and certainly not corrected by Ofqual". |
| He added that the raising of the mark needed to get a C grade between the January and June exam units left thousands of students victim to "inconsistency within the year group" and "a lack of even-handedness". | He added that the raising of the mark needed to get a C grade between the January and June exam units left thousands of students victim to "inconsistency within the year group" and "a lack of even-handedness". |
| Mr Sheldon told the High Court in London that in one AQA exam unit the mark needed to achieve a C rose from 43 to 53 marks out of 80 from January to June although there was no change in the difficulty of the paper. | Mr Sheldon told the High Court in London that in one AQA exam unit the mark needed to achieve a C rose from 43 to 53 marks out of 80 from January to June although there was no change in the difficulty of the paper. |
| The claimants are calling for GCSE English exam papers taken by pupils last June to be regraded in line with grade boundaries used for the same exams in January 2012. | The claimants are calling for GCSE English exam papers taken by pupils last June to be regraded in line with grade boundaries used for the same exams in January 2012. |
| 'Unprecedented margin' | 'Unprecedented margin' |
| The alliance says some 10,000 pupils consequently missed out on a C grade in GCSE English, which is a crucial benchmark used for entry into further education, vocational training and employment, but the decision affected all the grade margins. | The alliance says some 10,000 pupils consequently missed out on a C grade in GCSE English, which is a crucial benchmark used for entry into further education, vocational training and employment, but the decision affected all the grade margins. |
| In total up to 50,000 pupils in England, Wales and Northern Ireland could receive higher grades if the judges uphold the challenge, says the alliance. | In total up to 50,000 pupils in England, Wales and Northern Ireland could receive higher grades if the judges uphold the challenge, says the alliance. |
| Some 2,300 students who took exams set by the Welsh exam board WJEC in Wales have already been regraded on the orders of the Welsh government, which regulates exams set there. | Some 2,300 students who took exams set by the Welsh exam board WJEC in Wales have already been regraded on the orders of the Welsh government, which regulates exams set there. |
| The case has been brought by a total of 167 individual pupils, supported by 150 schools and 42 councils, plus six professional bodies, including teaching unions. | The case has been brought by a total of 167 individual pupils, supported by 150 schools and 42 councils, plus six professional bodies, including teaching unions. |
| They will say that between January and June 2012 it was decided that too many students were going to get a C grade or better in GCSE English, so a decision was taken to push up grade boundaries for the exams marked in June to bring down the numbers of good grades for the year as a whole. | They will say that between January and June 2012 it was decided that too many students were going to get a C grade or better in GCSE English, so a decision was taken to push up grade boundaries for the exams marked in June to bring down the numbers of good grades for the year as a whole. |
| They argue that this amounts to a crude "statistical fix" which was unfair and against "natural justice". | They argue that this amounts to a crude "statistical fix" which was unfair and against "natural justice". |
| "Now that we have looked at all the evidence and made final preparations for the court case, we remain certain that it is the right thing to do," said Brian Lightman of the Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL). | "Now that we have looked at all the evidence and made final preparations for the court case, we remain certain that it is the right thing to do," said Brian Lightman of the Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL). |
| "Thousands of young people in England were unfairly downgraded in June in order to compensate for mistakes made earlier in the year. | "Thousands of young people in England were unfairly downgraded in June in order to compensate for mistakes made earlier in the year. |
| 'Systemic failure' | 'Systemic failure' |
| "The only fair course of action for these students is to regrade the papers. While many of them will have moved on to college courses or to other options, their grades will remain with them for years to come and that is unjust." | "The only fair course of action for these students is to regrade the papers. While many of them will have moved on to college courses or to other options, their grades will remain with them for years to come and that is unjust." |
| Ofqual and the two exam boards have said they will not be commenting on the proceedings until they are over, but Ofqual has vowed to "rigorously defend" its decisions. In its final report into the grading row, Ofqual insisted the June boundaries were correct. It also suggested the grade boundaries had had to be moved in response to teachers "significantly" overmarking controlled assessment papers. | Ofqual and the two exam boards have said they will not be commenting on the proceedings until they are over, but Ofqual has vowed to "rigorously defend" its decisions. In its final report into the grading row, Ofqual insisted the June boundaries were correct. It also suggested the grade boundaries had had to be moved in response to teachers "significantly" overmarking controlled assessment papers. |
| Some 45,000 pupils resat GCSE English last month, with the results expected next week. | Some 45,000 pupils resat GCSE English last month, with the results expected next week. |
| Are you affected by this story? If you are willing to take part in TV and radio interviews about this subject please fill in the form below. | Are you affected by this story? If you are willing to take part in TV and radio interviews about this subject please fill in the form below. |