This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2016/oct/10/clinton-trump-pence-campaign-heated-presidential-debate-live

The article has changed 21 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 8 Version 9
Hillary Clinton opens up 11-point lead in pre-debate poll – campaign live Hillary Clinton opens up 11-point lead in pre-debate poll – campaign live
(35 minutes later)
8.39pm BST
20:39
Clinton is in Detroit, motor city, going hard on Trump for using Chinese steel.
“The steelworkers, they know that this is a big, big deal... [Trump] is putting steelworkers out of work and shutting down steel mills..
I do have some advice for Donald. If he wants to make America great again he can start by buying American steel for his construction project.
“Friends don’t let friends vote for Trump,” she says.
8.36pm BST
20:36
A protester is escorted from Clinton’s event:
Looks like a man wearing a Bill Clinton "rape" shirt was just escorted out of Clinton's rally pic.twitter.com/KLaN2gNxI8
There's one at the Trump rally too. I don't think he is being escorted out https://t.co/Nx5JW50JMG https://t.co/Qo4jCuHLvg
Clinton is also hitting Trump on taxes, and now on his use of “cheap Chinese steel.”
Clinton: "For starters, Warren Buffett is a real billionaire." Then she reads Buffett's statement on Trump's tax tactics.
8.35pm BST
20:35
Trump protesters target RNC headquarters
Supporters of the Republican presidential nominee are marching on the national party headquarters:
HAPPENING NOW: Pro Trump rally in front of the RNC HQ in DC. Unbelievable how ignorant some of the signs are. The GOP must reject this crap! pic.twitter.com/ILSLvkKhZb
.@KellyannePolls tells me this protest is "absolutely not" organized by the campaign. "Unauthorized," she says https://t.co/U8xuIzJ1TY
8.27pm BST
20:27
Clinton is onstage in Detroit now:
Clinton in Detroit on last night's debate: "Donald Trump spent his time attacking when he should have been apologizing."
Updated
at 8.28pm BST
8.26pm BST
20:26
Trump is flying on Pence’s plane today – and no word on Pence’s ride, the press pool reports:
Donald Trump disembarked here in Pittsburgh International at 3:15pm. He arrived in the plane typically used by Mike Pence. A campaign aide said Trump didn’t use his usual plane because of “crew rest issues.” Could not confirm how Pence is traveling today.
Also spotted with Trump: Jared Kushner, Rudy Giuliani, Tiffany Trump, Stephen Miller, and Hope Hicks.
The motorcade is now en route to Ambridge for the rally, which is open press.
8.25pm BST
20:25
Here’s another elected Republican (after Mitch McConnell) with no comment on the presidential race: Representative Sean Duffy of Wisconsin’s 7th district (all of northern Wisconsin basically):
Just talked to @RepSeanDuffy. He wouldn't tell me if he supports Trump as the nominee. Told me I should have called spokesman instead of him
I asked @RepSeanDuffy the question about Trump four or five times before he hung up on me. https://t.co/FoMzwtNtwf
(h/t: @bencjacobs)
Updated
at 8.29pm BST
8.17pm BST
20:17
Sessions: 'grab them by the pussy' not sexual assault
Alabama senator Jeff Sessions, an early and ardent supporter of Donald Trump, has declared that what Trump described on the hot mic tape released Friday is not sexual assault.
“I don’t characterize that as sexual assault,” he said. “I think that’s a stretch”:
Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-AL) says even if Trump had grabbed women by their genitals, it would not be sexual assault https://t.co/qVernRsGCK pic.twitter.com/cIjFzHsMbu
A comparison has been drawn between Session’s parsing of sexual assault and the parsing by US senate candidate Todd Akin in 2012 of rape. Akin, a Republican who was trying to unseat incumbent Claire McCaskill, said that “if it’s a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down” – meaning pregnancy.
McCaskill tweets that the comparisons are unfair... to Akin:
That's not fair to Todd Akin. No comparison. This much worse. https://t.co/3a9EYqkoKT
8.07pm BST
20:07
The Trump rally in Ambridge, Pennsylvania, outside Pittsburgh, is getting going:
8.04pm BST8.04pm BST
20:0420:04
McConnell on presidential race: no commentMcConnell on presidential race: no comment
A month before the presidential election, the senate majority leader just doesn’t have anything to say about it:A month before the presidential election, the senate majority leader just doesn’t have anything to say about it:
This is remarkable: Mitch McConnell tells Chamber of Commerce in KY "I don't have any observations to make" about the presidential election.This is remarkable: Mitch McConnell tells Chamber of Commerce in KY "I don't have any observations to make" about the presidential election.
8.01pm BST8.01pm BST
20:0120:01
Brilliant animated gif applied to the latest 538 polls-plus forecast, which takes in economic and historical data:Brilliant animated gif applied to the latest 538 polls-plus forecast, which takes in economic and historical data:
Clinton at 79% in our conservative, polls-plus forecast, which is tied for her high on the year. 82% in polls-only. https://t.co/zo8rbYw56E pic.twitter.com/iqs9F14Ip7Clinton at 79% in our conservative, polls-plus forecast, which is tied for her high on the year. 82% in polls-only. https://t.co/zo8rbYw56E pic.twitter.com/iqs9F14Ip7
ok @mutedestro @teddygoff @NateSilver538 pic.twitter.com/lK8X82KGobok @mutedestro @teddygoff @NateSilver538 pic.twitter.com/lK8X82KGob
7.44pm BST
19:44
Clinton camp turns fire on GOP: 'they have a lot to answer for'
The Clinton communications director advises the press that congressional Republicans have made their beds and now they’re going to sleep in them:
.@jmpalmieri: "Paul Ryan and other [Republican] leaders ... there was a time where they could have spoken out. That time was this summer."
On GOP turmoil, Clinton spox @jmpalmieri says Republican leaders helped legitimize Trump: "I think they have a lot to answer for."
Ryan is still endorsing Trump. https://t.co/L30EZvUbm0
Updated
at 7.45pm BST
7.36pm BST
19:36
Here’s a live stream of Clinton’s rally in Detroit, Michigan. The warmup speakers are on – and the Guardian’s Sabrina Siddiqui is in attendance:
7.30pm BST
19:30
The Trump campaign seems to be hacking at the remaining stitching tying it to congress. Here’s spokeswoman Katrina Pierson:
I can't keep my phone charged due to the mass volume of texts from people all over the country who will #VoteTrump but⬇️ballot not so much.
7.28pm BST
19:28
Ratings slip for second presidential debate
Sam Thielman
Viewership of the second presidential debate was down 20m from the first debate, writes the Guardian’s Sam Thielman (@samthielman):
Total viewers across the three major cable and three broadcast networks for the 90-minute debate came to more than 60m, while millions more watched on streaming services including Hulu and YouTube, according to preliminary Nielsen figures. Additional viewership on Spanish-language networks and PBS probably won’t bump the final tally over 63m, so viewership was down by a full 20m Americans who either just couldn’t bring themselves to tune in or watched football instead.
Part of the reason for the falloff was certainly at NBC, which broadcast an NFL game instead of the debate.
But while most of the might-have-been NBC loyalists went to CBS, which had the largest number of viewers by a comfortable margin, with 16.5m, ABC and Fox News were both down against the last debate with 11.5m and 9.9m viewers respectively – even with the broadcast network’s Martha Raddatz co-moderating.
6.49pm BST
18:49
Ben Jacobs mingles before the Trump event in Ambridge, which is a suburb of Pittsburgh:
This Trump voter doesn't mind his remark about jailing Hillary from last night pic.twitter.com/Wa2ZXowGkN
6.47pm BST
18:47
Donald Trump registers 35% support in the new NBC/WSJ poll of a four-way presidential race.
The peanut gallery wonders whether he’s at risk of falling below the threshold needed to earn a debate lectern:
@StuPolitics With a bit of luck Trump will drop below the 15% national threshold and the 3rd debate will be cancelled. :D
Ha! Hilarious. https://t.co/w1INl8AiHf
6.42pm BST
18:42
This is interesting. Going by HuffPost Pollster’s average of polls of a two-way race, Hillary Clinton is not only performing a lot better against Trump than Barack Obama did against Mitt Romney - her average support at this stage is also higher than Obama’s was:
A quick comparison of 2012 vs. 2016 HuffPost Pollster averages pic.twitter.com/o6hZ6bkc1n
6.37pm BST
18:37
Donald Trump and Ben Jacobs are in Ambridge, Pennsylvania, this afternoon. Trump is scheduled to speak at 3.30pm (we’ll have a live video stream for you).
Ben is already on the scene:
Spotted in Ambridge PA pic.twitter.com/xL73hXu0XL
6.31pm BST
18:31
Trump attacks Ryan
Trump hits the House speaker on Twitter. This morning Ryan told members he would not be campaigning with Trump or defending him. Ryan has not withdrawn his endorsement of Trump. But he did suggest that he expected Hillary Clinton to become president, saying he would direct all his energies toward preventing a Democratic sweep that would give her a “blank check.”
Trump thinks Ryan is wasting time:
Paul Ryan should spend more time on balancing the budget, jobs and illegal immigration and not waste his time on fighting Republican nominee
6.28pm BST
18:28
Dole stands by Trump
Ben Jacobs
“Mr. Trump has expressed regret for making the comments, and I believe we should refocus on the primary issues that matter to the American people.”
– 1996 Republican presidential nominee Bob Dole, in a statement to the Guardian