This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2016/oct/19/donald-trump-hillary-clinton-third-presidential-debate-live

The article has changed 29 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 16 Version 17
Presidential debate: polls widen between Trump and Clinton – live Presidential debate: polls widen between Trump and Clinton – live
(35 minutes later)
12.11am BST
00:11
Trump campaign manager Kellyanne Conway is proud to be joined at the debate by Malik Obama, the president’s half-brother:
Malik Obama and I hanging post-debate prep today. He told me why he is a Republican and voting for @realDonaldTrump pic.twitter.com/sAGXDj4GHg
Washington Post editor and Obama biographer David Maraniss has more on Malik Obama:
As Obama biographer, I dealt with many Kenyan relatives. Now Trumpster Malik by far the least reliable, consumed with pub & money.
3) He has gone by 32 names during his life. Roy, Bobby, and finally Malik.
8) By the time Barack Obama reached global fame, Malik wanted to be his Kenyan spokesman, setting up shop in Kisumu and Kogelo.
9) At one point, and I’m sure Trump would love thi about his newfound friend, Malik tried to build a mosque on the Obama compound in Kogelo.
10) By the time I reached Kenya to research biography, Malik wanted to control all interviews and get paid for them.
11.59pm BST
23:59
A new Pew research survey finds that “more than seven in ten (72%) white evangelical Protestants say an elected official can behave ethically even if they have committed transgressions in their personal life—a 42-point jump from 2011, when only 30 % of white evangelical Protestants said the same.”
What changed? And does this even count as a voting bloc anymore, if the whole “family values” thing has been jettisoned?
White evangelicals have jumped 42 pts (!) in accepting politicians' immoral personal acts: 30% (2011) to 72% (2016) https://t.co/VHqP8r5BU0 pic.twitter.com/ohhWsXt5b0
11.54pm BST
23:54
The Cleveland Indians (that’s baseball) have just won the pennant and are headed to the World Series. The governor noticed:
Amazing! Four wins away from a second Cleveland championship in 2016. All of Ohio, let's #RallyTogether for the World Series. @Indians pic.twitter.com/Z9uUGaanQd
You’ll recall that the Cleveland Cavaliers (basketball) are the current NBA champions, and when they won the city did this:
Other awesome things to have occurred this year in Cleveland:
11.50pm BST
23:50
We know what you’re all thinking. Where’s the vacuuming picture? When are we going to post the pre-debate vacuuming picture?
Additional photojournalism from the scene:
Fun fact – Trump is entirely out of the casino business, and he has never owned a Las Vegas casino, although he’s in talks to build one, the Wall Street Journal reported in February:
Mr. Trump owned casinos in Atlantic City for decades but never had any gambling interests in Nevada. The casinos he developed and owned in Atlantic City went through bankruptcy four times. He no longer has any interest them.
The Trump hotel in Las Vegas is near the northern end of the Las Vegas Strip. It is across from the Wynn Las Vegas, but the rest of the surrounding area is largely underdeveloped because several large-scale projects stopped when they were only partially built during the recession. Now with the casino market in Las Vegas improving, some of the projects have new owners and may be moving forward. Gambling revenue on the Las Vegas Strip was flat last year, but revenue from hotel room rates improved.
11.32pm BST11.32pm BST
23:3223:32
She’s with her.She’s with her.
11.29pm BST11.29pm BST
23:2923:29
Palin to attend debate - reportPalin to attend debate - report
Former vice-presidential hopeful Sarah Palin, also a former governor of Alaska and former Fox News contractor, will attend tonight’s debate as a guest of Donald Trump, CNN reports.Former vice-presidential hopeful Sarah Palin, also a former governor of Alaska and former Fox News contractor, will attend tonight’s debate as a guest of Donald Trump, CNN reports.
Is this a great opportunity to revisit Palin’s historic on-camera endorsement of Trump in January? Can I get a hallelujah?Is this a great opportunity to revisit Palin’s historic on-camera endorsement of Trump in January? Can I get a hallelujah?
Trump also has invited Malik Obama, an estranged half-brother of the president with possible Hamas ties; Pat Smith, the mother of a state department IT technician killed in the 2012 attacks in Benghazi; Leslie Millwee, a former TV reporter from Arkansas who has accused former president Bill Clinton of sexually assaulting her; and somebody even at some point said Wayne Newton was coming?Trump also has invited Malik Obama, an estranged half-brother of the president with possible Hamas ties; Pat Smith, the mother of a state department IT technician killed in the 2012 attacks in Benghazi; Leslie Millwee, a former TV reporter from Arkansas who has accused former president Bill Clinton of sexually assaulting her; and somebody even at some point said Wayne Newton was coming?
1) Some basic facts about Malik Obama, who will be at the presidential debate as guest of Donald Trump in Las Vegas tonight.1) Some basic facts about Malik Obama, who will be at the presidential debate as guest of Donald Trump in Las Vegas tonight.
Hillary Clinton’s guests are by comparison topical and boring. She has invited Meg Whitman, Hewlett-Packard CEO and erstwhile Republican; Astrid Silva, the immigration activist; Kareem Abdul Jabbar, Kareem Abdul Jabbar; and Mark Cuban, billionaire owner of Dallas Mavericks-slash-bee in Trump’s bonnet. Oh and Le-yawn Panetta.Hillary Clinton’s guests are by comparison topical and boring. She has invited Meg Whitman, Hewlett-Packard CEO and erstwhile Republican; Astrid Silva, the immigration activist; Kareem Abdul Jabbar, Kareem Abdul Jabbar; and Mark Cuban, billionaire owner of Dallas Mavericks-slash-bee in Trump’s bonnet. Oh and Le-yawn Panetta.
Cant wait to give a big hug to my bestie @realDonaldTrump at the debate tomorrow night. I know you miss me !Cant wait to give a big hug to my bestie @realDonaldTrump at the debate tomorrow night. I know you miss me !
Also all these people, attending with Clinton:Also all these people, attending with Clinton:
UpdatedUpdated
at 11.34pm BSTat 11.34pm BST
11.08pm BST11.08pm BST
23:0823:08
Reminder: As ugly as things get onstage tonight, tomorrow night these people have to eat next to one another.Reminder: As ugly as things get onstage tonight, tomorrow night these people have to eat next to one another.
Trump and Clinton have both said they’ll attend the annual Al Smith dinner Thursday night, “the white-tie Manhattan ritual that drops like an Alka Seltzer every four years, as the race for the White House enters a stage of maximum partisan discomfort,” we said in 2012.Trump and Clinton have both said they’ll attend the annual Al Smith dinner Thursday night, “the white-tie Manhattan ritual that drops like an Alka Seltzer every four years, as the race for the White House enters a stage of maximum partisan discomfort,” we said in 2012.
The candidates don formal attire and sit with the archbishop between them, and each must rise and deliver a comedic monologue. Awkward!The candidates don formal attire and sit with the archbishop between them, and each must rise and deliver a comedic monologue. Awkward!
Hosted by the archbishop of New York, the dinner promotes itself as a light-hearted break from the campaign trail. In fact it’s a duty to which presidential nominees have docilely submitted since 1960, except when the whiff of controversy, usually over abortion, has made it politically inconvenient for the Catholic Church to invite them.Hosted by the archbishop of New York, the dinner promotes itself as a light-hearted break from the campaign trail. In fact it’s a duty to which presidential nominees have docilely submitted since 1960, except when the whiff of controversy, usually over abortion, has made it politically inconvenient for the Catholic Church to invite them.
Here are 2012 highlights:Here are 2012 highlights:
10.58pm BST10.58pm BST
22:5822:58
Can Trump win without New Hampshire?Can Trump win without New Hampshire?
A new University of New Hampshire poll has Trump down 15 (fifteen) points in the state, where he notched a 20-point victory in February in a solid six-way primary contest. The National Journal’s Josh Kraushaar notes that the poll squares with reports earlier this week that internal Republican polling had Trump down 14 points in the state.A new University of New Hampshire poll has Trump down 15 (fifteen) points in the state, where he notched a 20-point victory in February in a solid six-way primary contest. The National Journal’s Josh Kraushaar notes that the poll squares with reports earlier this week that internal Republican polling had Trump down 14 points in the state.
New Hampshire poll(UNH)Clinton 48Trump 33Johnson 7Stein 2other 4Don't know 5#nhpoliticsNew Hampshire poll(UNH)Clinton 48Trump 33Johnson 7Stein 2other 4Don't know 5#nhpolitics
Does Trump even have a path to victory any longer? “No,” thinks Stuart Rothenberg, author of the eponymous politics report.Does Trump even have a path to victory any longer? “No,” thinks Stuart Rothenberg, author of the eponymous politics report.
Let’s take a quick look at why. Here’s a picture of what was thought to be Trump’s path of least resistance to the presidency, involving a scenario that gets him right to 270, barely, with victory in Maine’s second district and in four or five states where Clinton currently holds solid polling leads.Let’s take a quick look at why. Here’s a picture of what was thought to be Trump’s path of least resistance to the presidency, involving a scenario that gets him right to 270, barely, with victory in Maine’s second district and in four or five states where Clinton currently holds solid polling leads.
Take New Hampshire out of this picture, and how does Trump win? A new Monmouth poll today had Clinton up seven points in Wisconsin. Trump claims to be in the lead in Colorado, where polling averages have him down five. Etc, etc.Take New Hampshire out of this picture, and how does Trump win? A new Monmouth poll today had Clinton up seven points in Wisconsin. Trump claims to be in the lead in Colorado, where polling averages have him down five. Etc, etc.
UpdatedUpdated
at 10.58pm BSTat 10.58pm BST
10.41pm BST10.41pm BST
22:4122:41
Mike Pence is “wheels down in Las Vegas!” and steps off the plane looking very vice presidential. That’s his wife, Karen, beside him.Mike Pence is “wheels down in Las Vegas!” and steps off the plane looking very vice presidential. That’s his wife, Karen, beside him.
We're wheels down in Las Vegas! Ready to cheer on @realDonaldTrump tonight as he takes the stage to fight for you, America. pic.twitter.com/W6do1fprSVWe're wheels down in Las Vegas! Ready to cheer on @realDonaldTrump tonight as he takes the stage to fight for you, America. pic.twitter.com/W6do1fprSV
10.31pm BST10.31pm BST
22:3122:31
The band Le Tigre has reassembled and released a track called “I’m with her” in support of Hillary Clinton:The band Le Tigre has reassembled and released a track called “I’m with her” in support of Hillary Clinton:
For the sake of balance here also is a Donald Trump song discovered quickly and at random on YouTube:For the sake of balance here also is a Donald Trump song discovered quickly and at random on YouTube:
10.18pm BST
22:18
Have you ever thought you could come up with a better campaign slogan than “Stronger together” or “Make America great again”?
Here are 85 tries by the Clinton campaign to come up with a slogan, if this purported John Podesta email released by Wikileaks is genuine. Can you do better?
Here's a list of the 85 slogan possibilities that Clinton campaign consultants floated in August 2015 https://t.co/9gPRE9xGoz pic.twitter.com/0WDem84xqy
9.30pm BST
21:30
Barack Obama reflects on presidency at final White House state dinner
Ciara McCarthy
Barack Obama hosted his final state dinner last night, welcoming the Italian prime minister, Matteo Renzi to the White House and spurring nostalgia for the Obamas’ final months on Pennsylvania Avenue.
"Do I have anything in my teeth?""No one is looking at you Barack." pic.twitter.com/AjI2OchgzK
State dinners are a longstanding presidential tradition to host international heads of state in the US. Renzi and his wife, Agnese Landini, were treated to a night featuring Italian-influenced food, decor and fashion. Michelle Obama dazzled quite literally in an Atelier Versace gown. The rose-gold, chain mail dress elicited instant reactions online, as well as several look backs at the first lady’s fashion over the years.
The president made brief remarks at the dinner, toasting the relationship between the two countries and touting Italy’s influence on American culture.
“Some days our presidential campaign can seem like Dante’s ‘Inferno,’” he quipped.
The first lady tapped Babbo chef and Food Network regular Mario Batali to prepare the multi-course meal, featuring vegetables from the White House garden. As usual, the chef donned his familiar orange Crocs while preparing and serving the meal.
9.13pm BST
21:13
Donald Trump in 2008: Hillary Clinton will 'go down down at a minimum as a great senator'
Donald Trump’s flip-flopping on issues relating to trade, borders, abortion, gay marriage, the proposed ban on Muslim immigration, the minimum wage, taxation, the Iraq War, the Libyan intervention, gun control, climate change and the Republican Party have been well documented, but CNN just uncovered past statements by the real estate tycoon that even Trump might have a hard time explaining: flattering Hillary Clinton.
“I think she’s a wonderful woman,” Trump said in 2008 in an interview with NY1, according to CNN. “I think that she’s a little bit misunderstood. Hillary’s a very smart woman, very tough women, that’s fine. She’s also a very nice person. I think she’s gonna go down at a minimum as a great senator.”
“I think she is a great wife to a president and I think Bill Clinton was a great president,” Trump continued. “Lot of people hated him because they were jealous as hell. Bill Clinton was a great president. Hillary Clinton is a great woman and a good woman.”
8.44pm BST
20:44
Ivanka Trump: My father will accept the outcome of the election
Joining campaign manager Kellyanne Conway in undercutting her father’s baseless accusation that the impending general election will be stolen due to voter fraud, Ivanka Trump told Time Magazine editor Nancy Gibbs that her father will concede the election to Democratic rival Hillary Clinton if he loses.
“Well, look, my father is in this to win it and, you know, I’m not interested in talking about alternative outcomes and, of course, I think my father will always do the right thing,” Trump said. “That’s the type of person he is.”
Speaking at Fortune’s Most Powerful Women Summit, Trump highlighted what she characterized as “vicious” behavior on behalf of the political press, before assuring Gibbs that her father will accept the outcome of the election.
“When you asked me before, do I think it’s rigged, I think from a media perspective, it’s very hard to get an accurate portrayal of who he is as a person or the business he’s built, his professional accomplishments,” Trump said. “It’s borderline impossible. In large part, we’ve stopped even trying with a lot of the mainstream publications because they just don’t - you know, I was going crazy around a year ago calling these reporters, trying to get them to at least hear our perspective and it’s just a waste of time. You fall down such a rabbit hole with this and it doesn’t yield a result.”
“But to your point, if - he’ll either win or he won’t win,” Trump said, “and I believe he’ll accept the outcome either way.”
8.20pm BST
20:20
Election causing uptick in Twitter abuse for Jews and journalists
Nicky Woolf
The 2016 presidential election is causing a “significant uptick” in antisemitism on Twitter, and journalists – particularly Jewish journalists – are especially targeted, according to a new study by the Anti-Defamation League (ADL).
Looking between August 2015 and July 2016, the ADL found 2.6m tweets containing antisemitic language.
The study focused on 19,253 overtly antisemitic tweets aimed at 800 journalists, 68% of which were sent by just 1,600 Twitter users, which the study said confirms a persistent attack on journalists by a small cohort of Twitter users.
Just 10 journalists received of 83% of these 19,253 tweets; Ben Shapiro, a former Breitbart News editor and outspoken critic of Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, received 7,400 of the antisemitic tweets, including one calling him a “Christ-Killer”.
Another example picked out by the study is Julia Ioffe, whose profile of Melania Trump for GQ magazine caused a storm of antisemitic responses on Twitter, including a tweet calling her a “filthy Russian kike” and another that includedphotos from Nazi concentration camps, the study described.
Shapiro told the ADL that it was “amazing what’s been unleashed. I honestly didn’t realize they were out there. It’s every day, every single day.” He said that his wife and infant son had also been targeted. “When my child was born there were lots of antisemitic responses talking about cockroaches,” he said.
“I think this is a first-of-a-kind study that we’ve put out, that we think is instructive in terms of understanding how antisemitism is spread in the modern age through social media,” said Oren Segal, the director of the ADL’s Center on Extremism. “It reinforces the work that the ADL does in terms of needing to find ways to mitigate antisemitism, threats of antisemitism, no matter where they are.”
8.11pm BST
20:11
From the press pool: Donald Trump skipped his walk-through at the debate venue in Las Vegas, which had been scheduled for 11:00 am.
The pool had not been informed of the walk through plans.
“He didn’t do the walk through,” a campaign aide told the pool.
When pressed about why, and whether a stand-in participated, the aide said “his debate team is taking care of it.”
7.55pm BST
19:55
59% of Americans say Donald Trump has no sense of decency
“Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last? Have you left no sense of decency?”
The fifties are back, according to the latest survey from Quinnipiac University, which found that nearly three in five likely voters believe that Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump does not have a sense of decency. Nearly the same number say that Trump is not fit to be president.
A full 59% of likely voters surveyed by Quinnipiac said that Trump has no sense of decency, while 36% said that he does. Hillary Clinton, according to the surveys, does have a sense of decency, 55% to 42% .
In a four-way race, the poll finds that Clinton leads Trump by 7 points among likely voters, 47% to Trump’s 40% among likely voters, with 7% of likely voters supporting Libertarian nominee Gary Johnson and 1% supporting Green candidate Jill Stein.
7.20pm BST
19:20
The tabloid of record.
The Weekly World News would have crushed 2016 campaign coverage. pic.twitter.com/oVANxkkH3U
7.07pm BST
19:07
Poll: Paul Ryan's support among Republicans collapses following Trump feud
If you lay down with dogs, you get up with an approval rating that collapses on itself like a dying star.
Buried in new poll results from YouGov that show Hillary Clinton with a commanding lead over Republican rival Donald Trump with less than three weeks to go before the general election are data showing that House speaker Paul Ryan’s favorability rating among Republicans has cratered. Last week, he had a net positivity of 23%.
This week: -5%.
And that’s not even counting Ryan’s popularity (or lack thereof) among Trump supporters. Last week, Ryan had a net 8% positivity rating, which has dropped to a negative 36% disapproval in the week since.
6.47pm BST
18:47
Nigel M Smith
Amy Schumer has written an open letter to fans who walked out of her Sunday standup show in Tampa, Florida, after she made jokes about Donald Trump.
The actor and writer read the letter aloud during her Tuesday show at New York’s Madison Square Garden, according to People.
“I’ve written an open letter to Tampa and I’d like to read it tonight,” she began. “Dearest Tampa, I’m sorry you didn’t want me, a comedian who talks about what she believes in, to mention the biggest thing going on in our country right now. How could I think it was OK to spend five minutes having a peaceful conversation with someone with different views?
“After the show, I want you to know that I will go straight to a rehab facility that will teach me how to make all people happy. Both the rich, entitled, white people who are gonna vote for him and the very poor people – who’ve been tricked into it.”